If your audio interface provides the monitoring features you need, you don’t necessarily need an additional monitor controller. A simple controller may be enough for quick level, mute and mono checks. But if several people need to hear different signals, or you need cue and talkback functions, separate, independently adjustable paths are key. Check the connections, monitor pairs and headphone outputs on the specific model. Mackie, ESI, PreSonus and Sound On Sound describe different uses for these features.
Who could benefit from a monitor controller?
People mixing backing vocals around a shared desk
If you want to adjust levels, mute the sound and switch to mono while working together, check whether your existing interface offers these features or whether a controller would make them easier to access. Mackie and ESI describe relevant controls on their respective models, while Sound On Sound discusses the use of dedicated desktop controllers.
People working quietly on headphones
If you don’t want to monitor through speakers at a shared desk, a suitable headphone output with level control is important. Palmer describes a separately adjustable headphone output on the MONICON L G2 G; PreSonus lists several independently adjustable outputs on the Monitor Station V2.
Teams recording vocalists
During recording sessions, the person recording and the control room may need to hear different monitor signals. You may also need to set up a talkback connection. Depending on the model, PreSonus and Mackie describe cue and talkback features for this purpose.
What should you look for when buying?
Keep using your existing audio interface
A good fit if: The level control is within easy reach, and the available features and outputs meet the needs of everyone at the desk.
Consider: How quickly you can access mono, mute, dim or separate cue paths depends on the specific interface.
Simple passive monitor controller
A good fit if: You mainly want to control speaker levels, mute and mono directly from your desk, and can power your headphones another way.
Consider: A controller like this doesn’t automatically provide separate headphone amplification, cue or talkback. The ESI MoCo also doesn’t convert an unbalanced signal to balanced.
Controller with its own headphone output
A good fit if: One person wants to switch between speakers and independently controlled headphones. Palmer lists a dedicated stereo headphone output on the MONICON L G2 G.
Consider: A single headphone path doesn’t automatically provide independent mixes for several people.
Multiple headphone paths with cue and talkback
A good fit if: Several people need to monitor at the same time and communicate with the person recording during sessions.
Consider: Extra paths need suitable connections and space. With the Mackie Big Knob Studio, you should also check that its integrated USB recording interface suits your existing setup.
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who it matters most to |
| Level, mute and mono |
Check the controls on your interface and the specific controller. Mono, mute and dim aren’t available in the same way on every model. |
If I want to adjust the level, mute the sound and switch to mono while working at a shared desk, the controls on the device itself matter. Around 31 % of consumers mainly want level and mono controls. |
| Quiet headphone monitoring |
Compare the number of headphone sockets and separate level controls with the number of people who need to listen at the same time. |
If I don’t want to disturb others at the desk with speakers, I need a suitable headphone path with level control. Around 31 % of consumers mainly want to monitor quietly on headphones. |
| Cue mix and talkback |
Check the main/cue selection, independently adjustable headphone paths, talkback destination and any recording hardware you already have. |
If I need to hear a different signal from the control room while recording vocals, or talk to the people there, separate monitoring paths and suitable communication features are important. Around 23 % of consumers mainly need cue and talkback. |
| Switching between sources and monitor pairs |
Count your stereo sources and monitor pairs, then check that the connections and level controls you need work with your interface and speakers. |
If I want to switch between existing sources or pairs of speakers, the connections need to suit my setup. Around 15 % of consumers mainly want to switch between sources or monitor pairs. |
Common buying misconceptions
-
“Passive” doesn’t automatically mean an extra headphone path
Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as a speaker controller; headphone outputs are listed on other models in the Big Knob range.
Check whether the exact model version has a headphone output and its own level control.
Depending on your setup, you may still need to use your interface’s headphone output or a separate device.
-
When connecting several headphones, don’t just count the sockets
According to the manufacturer, the PreSonus Monitor Station V2 offers individual headphone level controls as well as a main/cue selection for each output. These are different features: a socket on its own doesn’t tell you which signal the person connected to it will hear.
Decide who needs to listen at the same time, and whether everyone needs the same signal or different ones.
For different signals, you may need extra cue cabling or a controller with suitable routing features.
-
A balanced output won’t automatically balance an unbalanced signal
ESI notes that the MoCo doesn’t convert an unbalanced input signal to balanced.
Plan the signal path from the source through your interface and controller to the monitors, and check that the connections are compatible.
If your cables and signal path aren’t suitable, you may need to change your setup later.
Key brands at a glance
Mackie
The Big Knob range includes the simple Big Knob Passive and the more fully featured Big Knob Studio, which has a USB recording interface.
- Mackie lists two source and monitor paths, plus mono, mute and dim, for the Passive.
- Two independently adjustable headphone outputs, cue mix and talkback are features of the Big Knob Studio and aren’t automatically included with the Passive.
ESI
The MoCo is a passive controller with two stereo input and output paths and direct speaker controls.
- ESI lists mono downmix, mute and output selection.
- According to ESI, an unbalanced input signal isn’t converted to balanced. The manufacturer’s claim about maximum audio quality isn’t an independent comparative test.
Palmer
The MONICON L G2 G connects several sources and speaker outputs with an independently adjustable headphone output.
- Palmer lists two stereo speaker outputs, one mono output, and mono, dim and mute functions.
- The model has a listed stereo headphone output; you’ll need another solution for several independent headphone paths.
PreSonus
With several monitoring, cue and headphone paths, the Monitor Station V2 is designed for more extensive mixing and recording setups.
- PreSonus specifies four independently adjustable headphone outputs with main/cue selection, three stereo speaker pairs and integrated talkback.
- These manufacturer claims about sound quality haven’t been independently verified.
Audient
Audient describes the Nero as a central controller for a desktop monitoring setup with a wide range of connections.
- Audient describes a dedicated technology for stereo level adjustment.
- The claimed benefits for mixing accuracy aren’t backed up by a comparison with other controllers. Check that the connections and signal paths you need suit your specific setup.
Joybuy product selection
Suitable products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Can a passive monitor controller replace an audio interface?
Not if you need your interface’s recording functions. Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as a controller for levels, sources and speakers; the Big Knob Studio also has a USB recording interface, according to Mackie. Check what your existing interface does.
How do I connect a controller, interface and monitors?
Compare your interface’s outputs with the inputs on your chosen controller, then check that the controller’s outputs match your speakers’ inputs. With the ESI MoCo, take particular care: according to ESI, feeding it an unbalanced signal won’t make that signal balanced.
How should I care for a controller at a shared desk?
Follow the instructions for your specific model. Mackie says to clean the Big Knob Studio and Studio+ with a dry cloth and to leave servicing to qualified personnel if the devices are damaged.
What should I know about a fault or an online return in Germany?
When you buy as a consumer from a business seller, you’re generally entitled to a statutory warranty of at least two years from receipt of the goods. This is separate from a voluntary guarantee. For an online distance purchase, you generally have 14 days from delivery to withdraw from the contract, subject to statutory exceptions. Check who the seller is and which terms apply to your specific order.
What documentation should I check for a monitor controller sold in Germany?
For market surveillance, the German Federal Network Agency lists checks including CE marking, an identifiable product, correct manufacturer details and German-language instructions with any necessary warnings. These criteria don’t prove that a particular product listing is compliant, so check the documentation for the specific product.