Guitar editor with one pair of speakers
If you edit acoustic guitar tracks at a small desk, an easy-to-reach volume control, along with Mono and Mute functions, can be useful. Palmer and Mackie list these features for their respective models.
You don’t necessarily need a separate monitor controller if your audio interface is easy to reach and already has the features you need. For a single pair of speakers, a compact controller with Mono, Dim and Mute may be enough. If you work quietly on headphones or want to switch between several sets of monitors, check which signal paths are actually available. A controller is no substitute for a recording interface or suitably positioned speakers.
If you edit acoustic guitar tracks at a small desk, an easy-to-reach volume control, along with Mono and Mute functions, can be useful. Palmer and Mackie list these features for their respective models.
If you switch between speakers and headphones because of housemates or quiet hours, check whether your interface already has a suitable headphone output. ESI notes that the MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier, while Palmer describes the MONICON L G2 as having a separate headphone output.
If you regularly compare sources or pairs of speakers, you’ll need switchable stereo paths. Mackie and ESI list this kind of switching on their respective models.
For a student-bedroom setup, start by checking your existing signal path and what you actually need from your headphones. Extra switching options only matter if you’ll use them.
The proportions below reflect the main buying priorities for editing acoustic guitar in the student-bedroom setup described here.
| Priority | What to check before buying | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Volume and quick control | Controls on your existing interface; on a controller, Mono, Dim and Mute. | If you often change the volume while editing or want to check a guitar track in mono, easy access to the controls matters. Around 29% of consumers prioritise volume and monitoring control. |
| Quiet headphone listening | A headphone output on your interface; if there isn’t one, a separate headphone path with its own level control. | If you can’t use speakers at certain times in a shared room, a suitable headphone path matters more than extra speaker outputs. Around 29% of consumers see headphone monitoring as a top priority. |
| Connections and desk space | The sockets and signal routing across your whole setup, plus space for the unit and its connectors. | If you have limited space on a small desk, your controller, interface and speakers all need to work with the connections you have. Around 21% of consumers focus mainly on compatibility and space. |
| Comparing sources or speakers | The stereo inputs and outputs you need, and whether you can switch between them. | If you genuinely compare several sources or pairs of speakers, switchable paths can save you from unplugging and reconnecting cables. Around 14% of consumers put monitor comparison first. |
| Multiple headphone or cue paths | The number of independently controlled headphone outputs and the option to choose between Main and Cue. | If you work with other people and need different monitoring signals, separate level controls are important. Around 7% of consumers prioritise monitoring for multiple people. |
According to ESI, the MoCo has no integrated headphone amplifier. The built-in headphone amplifier in the Palmer MONICON L G2 needs power.
First check your interface’s headphone output, then check the controller’s exact specifications.
Connections vary from model to model. ESI notes that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced input signal to a balanced one.
Before buying, compare your interface’s outputs with the controller’s inputs and your speakers’ connections.
According to Genelec, room acoustics and speaker positioning affect what you hear, regardless of the controller.
Check your speaker placement and listening position separately, and choose extra switching options only if you really need them.
The MONICON range covers everything from a single stereo path to setups with extra sources, outputs and a separate headphone path.
The Big Knob Passive is designed to switch between two sources and two pairs of monitors.
The MoCo is a passive controller with two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs, as well as a range of connection types.
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for setups with several speaker, headphone and cue paths.
According to Audient, the Nero is designed for setups with up to three pairs of speakers, subwoofer assignment and multiple headphone paths.
No. According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive switches between sources and monitors, but doesn’t offer USB audio I/O. You’ll still need to check your interface’s recording and headphone features.
For your speaker path, connect a suitable analogue output on your interface to the controller’s input, then connect its output to your speakers. Check the connections and signal routing for your specific model. For example, ESI notes that the MoCo does not balance unbalanced signals.
No. Genelec explains that room acoustics and speaker positioning affect what you hear. An extra volume or switching control won’t remove these effects.
Keep the volume low and take regular breaks. The World Health Organization gives up to 40 hours per week at an average of 80 dB as an example of safe listening; this doesn’t translate into a fixed setting on any particular controller.