Who can benefit from a monitor controller?

Solo editor with one pair of monitors

If you edit alone and want easy access to the monitoring level or to switch between mono and mute, first check what your audio interface can do. Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as offering source and monitor-pair switching; Behringer lists features including mono and mute for the MONITOR1.

Editor with multiple monitoring paths

If you actually switch between sources or pairs of speakers while editing, count the inputs and outputs you need and check that the connections will work with your existing setup. Mackie and Palmer describe different switching options for their respective models.

Editing station with other contributors

If several people need to listen on headphones, independently adjustable outputs and suitable cue signals can be important. Talkback may also be useful for additional recording; PreSonus and Audient list these features on certain models.

What should you look for when buying?

First check whether your audio interface already provides the level control and signal routing you need. Then choose an additional controller based on the monitoring paths you’ll actually use while editing.

What matters What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Quick access to level control Check whether the control on your interface is easy to reach and whether the controller offers the features you need, such as mono or mute. If I want to adjust the monitoring level at my workstation while editing and switch to mono or mute when needed, ease of use is my priority. Around 36% of consumers prioritise quick access to level control.
Source and speaker switching Count stereo sources and monitor pairs separately, then check which paths you can select on the specific model. If I regularly compare existing sources or pairs of speakers, I need the right switching options rather than connections I won’t use. Around 29% of consumers put switching options first.
Headphone and cue paths Check the number of headphone outputs, whether their levels can be adjusted individually, and how Main/Cue can be assigned. If several contributors need to listen on headphones while I edit, I want to know who is hearing which signal and be able to set the level accordingly. Around 21% of consumers prioritise separate headphone or cue paths.
Connections for your existing setup Compare the input and output connectors and required signal paths on the exact model with your equipment. If I want to keep using my existing equipment and cabling, the connections and signal routing need to work together. Around 14% of consumers focus above all on compatibility with their existing setup.

Common buying misconceptions

  • “2×2” means two headphone outputs

    For the Big Knob Passive, Mackie’s specification refers to two sources and two monitor pairs, not two headphone outputs.

    Check the full model name and count source, speaker and headphone paths separately.

    If you need an additional headphone amplifier, factor it and its cabling into your setup.

  • Talkback is essential for editing alone

    Talkback can help you communicate with people over a cue path, but you don’t need it simply to edit a session that has already been recorded.

    Only plan for talkback if your workflow actually requires you to speak to contributors.

    Features you don’t need can mean extra cabling.

  • Comparing connections only after choosing a model

    Inputs and outputs vary from one controller to another. A model may offer the right features, but that alone doesn’t guarantee it will work with your interface and speakers.

    Before ordering, map out the signal path from your interface through the controller to your speakers and, if needed, your headphones.

    Different connections may mean you need to buy suitable cables.

Key brands at a glance

Mackie

Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as a passive switching solution for two sources and two monitor pairs. The Big Knob Studio is a different model, with a USB interface, two headphone outputs and talkback.

  • The range covers different switching needs and additional features.
  • The Studio model’s headphone and USB features aren’t automatically included with the Big Knob Passive.

Behringer

Behringer describes the MONITOR1 as a passive stereo level controller for one monitor path, with mono and mute.

  • The manufacturer lists XLR/TRS combo inputs and XLR outputs.
  • The specifications don’t establish that this model is suitable for several independently selectable pairs of speakers.

Palmer

Palmer describes the MONICON L G2 as having several types of input, two stereo outputs, one mono output and a separately adjustable headphone output.

  • The connections listed offer different routing options for a suitable setup.
  • Bluetooth and additional outputs are only relevant if you’ll actually use them at your editing station.

PreSonus

PreSonus lists three stereo speaker pairs and four individually adjustable headphone outputs with Main/Cue selection for the Monitor Station V2.

  • PreSonus also says that it has a built-in talkback microphone.
  • A small editing setup used by one person may not need these additional paths.

Audient

Audient lists multiple speaker, headphone and source paths for the Nero, including digital S/PDIF inputs.

  • The manufacturer’s specifications include four headphone outputs and internal and external talkback.
  • Before buying, check how the signals will be assigned in your specific setup.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

How do I connect a monitor controller for editing?

Place the controller in the analogue monitoring path between the appropriate outputs on your audio interface and the inputs on your active monitors. Check the sockets on the specific model before connecting it; plan headphone and cue paths separately.

Do I need talkback if I’m only editing an existing live session?

No, not just for editing. Talkback can be useful if you need to speak to contributors through their headphone path, for example during additional recording. PreSonus lists a built-in talkback microphone on the Monitor Station V2.

How do I care for a Mackie Big Knob Passive?

Mackie recommends using a dry cloth in the manual and advises against using the unit near water. For other models, follow the relevant manufacturer’s instructions.