Who can benefit from a monitor controller?

Percussion editors with one pair of monitors

If you edit at your desk, you’ll want to monitor levels and your mix directly, and quickly check it in mono. You won’t need additional speaker outputs for this. Audient describes mono and other direct controls as useful additions if these functions aren’t available on your audio interface.

Editors with multiple monitoring options

If you switch between reference sources or pairs of monitors while editing, the stereo inputs and outputs you need are what matter. Mackie says the Big Knob Passive supports two sources and two pairs of monitors; ESI also lists corresponding switching options for the MoCo.

Editors using headphones or a 2.1 monitoring setup

If you sometimes work on headphones or want to switch an existing subwoofer separately, check the specific output options. ESI points out that the MoCo doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier; PreSonus lists a sub bypass for the MicroStation BT.

What should you look for when buying?

First, check which functions are already easy to access on your audio interface. Only add a controller for controls or signal paths that are missing from your actual setup.

What you need What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Level, mono and mute Check whether mono, dim and mute are available and easy to reach at your workstation. Palmer lists these buttons on the MONICON M G2, and Mackie also lists them for the Big Knob Passive. If I want to adjust the level at my workstation while editing percussion and listen to the mix in mono, I don’t want to have to open software menus first. Around 36% of consumers put direct level and mono controls first.
Switching between sources or pairs of monitors Count the stereo sources and pairs of monitors you actually need, then compare this with the available inputs and outputs. Mackie lists two sources and two pairs of monitors for the Big Knob Passive. If I need to switch between existing sources or pairs of monitors, I want to do it without unplugging and reconnecting anything. Around 29% of consumers prioritise these switching options.
Headphone outputs Check whether your interface already provides the headphone outputs you need, and whether a controller offers suitable outputs and level controls. ESI states that the MoCo doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier. If I work on headphones or need separate headphone outputs, having the right output on the device matters to me. Around 21% of consumers prioritise headphone options.
Switching an existing subwoofer Check whether the specific model has a suitable subwoofer output and bypass. PreSonus lists a sub bypass for the MicroStation BT. If I want to switch off an existing subwoofer separately when comparing what I hear, I need a suitable signal path. Around 14% of consumers prioritise subwoofer control.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming “passive” means “has a headphone socket”

    A passive controller doesn’t automatically have a built-in headphone amplifier. ESI confirms that you can’t plug headphones directly into the MoCo.

    Check the headphone signal path on the exact model and your existing audio interface.

    If neither device has a suitable headphone output, you may need a separate device.

  • Assuming compatible sockets mean a compatible signal path

    According to ESI, an unbalanced input signal isn’t converted into a balanced signal by the ESI MoCo.

    Compare your source’s outputs with the controller’s inputs and outputs, and with the inputs on your monitors. Check the connector types and whether the signal path is balanced or unbalanced.

    Depending on the signal path, you may need different cables or a device with suitable signal handling.

  • Expecting a subwoofer bypass to fix bass problems in your room

    A bypass switches the subwoofer off; it won’t automatically eliminate the effect of room reflections or speaker placement on bass reproduction.

    Use the switch to compare the sound with and without the subwoofer, and assess the room and speaker positions separately.

  • Confusing features across different versions in a product range

    The Mackie versions differ in their additional outputs. Specifications for other Big Knob models don’t necessarily apply to the Big Knob Passive.

    Check the full model name and the connection table for the specific version.

Key brands to consider

Palmer

The MONICON M G2 is designed for compact monitoring setups with one stereo monitoring path and direct mono, dim and mute buttons.

  • Palmer says this model has XLR/TRS and 3.5 mm inputs, as well as XLR and 3.5 mm outputs.
  • Palmer lists one stereo input and output; this isn’t a substitute for switching between multiple pairs of monitors.

Mackie

According to Mackie, the Big Knob Passive is designed for switching between two stereo sources and two pairs of monitors.

  • Mackie lists mono, mute and dim functions for this model.
  • Mackie’s model comparison doesn’t list a headphone output for the Passive version.

ESI

The passive MoCo combines source and monitor switching with mono, mute and left-right swap functions.

  • ESI describes different balanced and unbalanced connection options.
  • According to ESI, the MoCo doesn’t convert an unbalanced input signal into a balanced signal and doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier.

PreSonus

PreSonus describes the MicroStation BT as suitable for stereo or 2.1 setups with a switchable subwoofer.

  • PreSonus lists a sub bypass and a headphone/aux output for the MicroStation BT.
  • According to PreSonus, the four separately controlled headphone outputs are on the Monitor Station V2, not the MicroStation BT.

Audient

According to Audient, the Nero is designed for more complex monitoring setups with multiple speaker, headphone and subwoofer paths.

  • Audient lists three stereo speaker outputs, four headphone outputs and an assignable subwoofer output.
  • Claims of especially precise or superior-sounding playback are manufacturer claims, not the result of an independent comparison.

Matching products on Joybuy

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I need to buy a controller as well as an audio interface for percussion editing?

Not if your interface already gives you easy access to the level controls and monitoring options you need. First, compare the functions you’re missing with the connections and controls on each controller.

How do I connect a passive monitor controller?

Compare the line outputs on your audio interface with the controller’s inputs and outputs, as well as the inputs on your active monitors. Check the connector types and whether the signal paths are balanced or unbalanced. According to ESI, the MoCo doesn’t convert an unbalanced input signal to balanced.

Can I connect headphones to any passive monitor controller?

No. According to ESI, you can’t plug headphones directly into the MoCo because it doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier. Check the specific features of other models, or use a suitable headphone output on your audio interface.

What are your rights if a product develops a fault after purchase in Germany?

Statutory consumer rights are separate from a voluntary guarantee and, for consumer purchases, generally apply against the seller. The Verbraucherzentrale says the period is generally two years from delivery. If a product is faulty, the seller must first be given the opportunity to put things right by repairing or replacing it.

Can a discarded electronic monitor controller go in household waste?

No. The German Environment Agency points out that waste electrical and electronic equipment must be disposed of separately, for example at local collection points. Retailer take-back options depend on the conditions in force at the time.