A separate monitor controller isn’t essential if your audio interface already controls the levels and monitoring paths you need. If you’re missing easily accessible mono, dim or mute buttons, switching between existing pairs of speakers, or a suitable headphone output, choose a controller that fills that specific gap and connects to your equipment. A controller won’t change your room acoustics, and a passive speaker output doesn’t automatically work as a headphone amplifier.
Which solution do you need?
Mixers using one pair of speakers
You want to adjust the level directly at your small desk and check your piano mix in mono when needed. First, find out whether your interface can already do this and whether a simple stereo monitoring path is enough. Bonedo notes that audio interfaces take on some of the tasks of a mixer in certain home studios.
Headphone users who need to keep the volume down
Your living situation means you switch between speakers and headphones, so you need a suitable signal path for both. A passive speaker controller doesn’t automatically include a headphone amplifier: ESI explicitly confirms this for the MoCo, while PreSonus describes a headphone/aux output on the MicroStation BT.
Mixers using multiple monitoring systems
You actually have two pairs of speakers or several sources at your workstation and want to compare piano recordings without unplugging anything. Count your existing stereo inputs and outputs before buying. Mackie and ESI list switching options for their respective models.
What should you look for?
First, check whether your interface already offers the features you need. Then choose between direct level and mono control, a suitable headphone path, and switching for any additional monitoring systems you actually have.
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| Level and mono |
How easily you can reach the level control, mono, dim and mute buttons, as well as the features on your interface. |
If I use one pair of speakers at a small workstation, I want direct control over the level and mono setting. Around 36% of consumers put level and mono control first. |
| Headphone path |
Check your interface’s headphone output and whether the controller explicitly offers a headphone socket and the switching you need. |
If my living situation means I need to keep the volume down, I need a suitable way to switch from listening on speakers to listening on headphones. Around 29% of consumers prioritise headphone use. |
| Multiple monitoring systems or sources |
Count your existing stereo sources and pairs of speakers; check that balanced and unbalanced connections are compatible throughout the signal chain. |
If I already compare multiple monitoring systems or sources, I want to switch between them without unplugging anything. Around 21% of consumers put this comparison first. |
| Connections or subwoofer |
Compare the sockets on your interface, controller and speakers. Only plan for a subwoofer bypass if your system is connected in a way that supports it. |
If I want to connect an existing subwoofer or use specific connections, the signal path needs to support them. Around 14% of consumers prioritise this integration. |
Common misconceptions
-
‘Passive’ doesn’t automatically mean ‘with a headphone socket’
A passive speaker controller may not have a built-in headphone amplifier. ESI confirms that the MoCo doesn’t have one; check the connections on the specific version of the Mackie Big Knob Passive you’re considering.
Check for a headphone output on the controller, or use a suitable output that’s already available on your interface.
-
More sockets don’t automatically mean the signal path is right for you
The type of connection and balanced signal routing aren’t the same thing. ESI points out that the MoCo doesn’t convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones.
Before buying, sketch out the connection from your interface through the controller to both speakers, then check that the connections are compatible.
Depending on your wiring, you may need different cables or a controller with different connections.
-
A subwoofer bypass won’t automatically fix your room
A switch on the controller won’t correct changes to the sound caused by your room. Genelec explains that room acoustics and speaker placement affect what you hear.
Choose a controller based on the switching functions you need, and assess speaker placement and your listening position separately.
-
USB-C on the MicroStation BT isn’t an audio input
PreSonus states that the USB-C port on this model is for power only and doesn’t provide an audio connection to a computer.
Plan your audio connections and power supply separately. PreSonus says a USB power adapter isn’t included.
Relevant brands at a glance
Palmer
The MONICON range includes compact solutions for a single stereo monitoring path.
- Palmer lists mono, dim and mute switches, along with XLR/TRS and 3.5 mm connections, for the MONICON M G2.
- The model specifications describe one stereo input and one stereo output, not a second speaker path. Sound quality claims are from the manufacturer.
Mackie
The Big Knob Passive is designed to switch between up to two stereo sources and two pairs of speakers.
- Mackie lists mono, mute and dim as features of this model.
- Check the headphone path on the specific Passive version you’re considering; features on other Big Knob models don’t automatically apply to it.
ESI
MoCo offers two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs, with different connection types.
- ESI lists mono, mute and left/right swap as features.
- ESI makes clear that the MoCo doesn’t convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones and doesn’t have a headphone amplifier. Sound quality claims on the product page come from the manufacturer.
PreSonus
The MicroStation BT combines a stereo monitoring path with a headphone/aux output, Bluetooth input and a connection for an existing subwoofer.
- PreSonus lists switchable main outputs and a subwoofer output.
- The unit needs USB power; PreSonus says USB-C isn’t an audio input. Check that the connections are compatible with your interface.
Joybuy products
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need to buy a separate monitor controller for recording piano?
No, not necessarily. First, check whether your audio interface already controls the levels and monitoring paths you actually need. A separate controller is mainly worth considering if you’re missing specific controls or switching functions.
How do I connect a basic monitor controller?
With a compatible setup, the line signal runs from the audio interface to the controller, then on to the active speakers. Before buying, check that all three devices have compatible connections and signal types; ESI explicitly points out that MoCo doesn’t convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones.
Can I use the PreSonus MicroStation BT as an audio interface via USB-C?
No. PreSonus says the USB-C connection on the MicroStation BT is for power only; audio signals use the designated inputs. PreSonus also says a USB power adapter isn’t included.
Can I connect headphones to any passive monitor controller?
No. A passive line output isn’t automatically a headphone output with a suitable amplifier. ESI confirms that the MoCo doesn’t have a built-in headphone amplifier; check the connections listed for the model you want, or use a suitable output on your interface.