Who can benefit from a monitor controller?

Editors who need quick level control

You share a workspace and want to turn your speakers down or mute them directly, without having to adjust playback in your software.

People working together on headphones

You need separate headphone connections or individual listening levels while you work. A passive speaker controller alone won’t necessarily offer these features.

Anyone switching between listening setups

You compare your demo using the sources or pairs of speakers you actually have, and want to avoid repeatedly unplugging and reconnecting cables.

What should you look for when buying?

First check what your audio interface already offers. Then count how many headphone feeds you need at the same time, along with the sources and pairs of speakers you’ll actually use.

Requirement What to check before buying Who is it important for?
Level control and quick listening checks Check for a direct volume control and the mute, dim and mono functions actually provided. If I want to adjust the level or playback directly at my desk while editing, I don’t want to have to search for the right control in my DAW. Around 33% of consumers put direct level control first.
Separate headphone feeds Count how many headphones you need to use at the same time, and check the outputs, level controls and, where relevant, listening-source selection. If several people are listening at a shared desk at the same time, I need a separate connection and listening level for each person. Around 27% of consumers prioritise separate headphone feeds.
Switching between sources and pairs of speakers Count stereo sources and pairs of speakers separately; source switching is not the same as an extra headphone output. If I want to compare my demo using the sources or pairs of speakers I have, I don’t want to keep unplugging and reconnecting cables. Around 20% of consumers put monitor switching first.
Compatible signal connections Check that the connectors, stereo signal path and balanced or unbalanced connections match across your interface, controller and speakers. If I need to connect equipment I already own, it’s important that the whole signal chain works together, not just that the connectors fit. Around 20% of consumers prioritise connection compatibility.

Avoiding buying pitfalls

  • Assuming “passive” means “has a headphone socket”

    A passive speaker controller doesn’t have to include a headphone amplifier. ESI explicitly states that headphones can’t be connected to the MoCo.

    Check whether the exact model lists a headphone output before choosing it for your shared workspace.

    If it doesn’t have one, you’ll need another suitable headphone feed in your signal chain.

  • Assuming similarly named models have the same features

    Mackie describes the Big Knob Studio as having headphone outputs; the Big Knob Passive is a different model for passive source and monitor switching.

    Check the full model name and list of connections rather than assuming that features carry over from one model in the range to another.

  • Assuming a matching socket means the signal path is compatible

    The ESI MoCo does not convert an unbalanced input signal into a balanced one.

    Check the input and output signals across the complete chain of audio interface, controller and speakers.

    Depending on the connections you already have, you may need different cables or a signal path with different features.

Key brands at a glance

Mackie

The Big Knob Passive is designed for workspaces where you want to switch passively between sources and pairs of speakers.

  • Mackie lists two sources, two monitor pairs, plus mono, mute and dim for the Big Knob Passive.
  • The headphone features of the Big Knob Studio are not included on the Big Knob Passive.

Palmer

The MONICON S G2 is designed for a compact stereo signal path with RCA connections; the MONICON M G2 G is a different model with different connections and controls.

  • Palmer lists RCA stereo inputs and outputs, plus a mono switch, for the S G2. For the M G2 G, Palmer lists features including mono, dim and mute, as well as XLR/TRS and 3.5 mm connections.
  • The connections and features of the M G2 G are not automatically available on the S G2.

ESI

The MoCo is a passive controller for switching between two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs.

  • ESI lists various line connections, along with mono and mute functions.
  • ESI notes that the MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier and does not balance unbalanced signals.

PreSonus

According to PreSonus, the Monitor Station V2 offers multiple speaker and headphone feeds for workspaces that need them.

  • PreSonus lists three stereo speaker pairs, four headphone outputs, cue selection and talkback.
  • If you only use one pair of speakers and the existing headphone output at your desk, you may not need the extra connections.

Audient

According to Audient, the Nero is designed to handle more extensive speaker and headphone setups.

  • Audient lists up to three speaker sets and four headphone outputs.
  • The manufacturer’s claims about sound accuracy are its own and do not constitute an independent listening comparison.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Do I definitely need a monitor controller as well as an audio interface?

No. Base your decision on the controls and outputs your existing interface actually offers. An extra controller is most useful when it gives you more direct level control at your desk or the switching features you need.

Can I connect headphones to a passive monitor controller?

Not necessarily. ESI explicitly states that the MoCo has no headphone amplifier and that headphones can’t be connected to it. Check whether the specific model lists a headphone output, or use a suitable output on your existing interface.

How do I connect a controller at my desk?

First compare the line outputs on your audio interface with the controller’s inputs, then check its outputs against your speaker inputs. Make sure you have the right cables. The ESI MoCo does not convert an unbalanced input signal into a balanced one.

Do the Big Knob Passive and Big Knob Studio have the same features?

No. Mackie describes the Big Knob Passive as a passive controller for switching between sources and monitors; the headphone outputs with individual level control are part of the Big Knob Studio. Check the connections on the full model you’re choosing.

What should I bear in mind when setting listening levels at a shared desk?

When someone else takes over, reset the listening level deliberately, and use any mute or dim buttons when you need to pause. The German Environment Agency notes that exposure to high sound levels can damage your hearing; this doesn’t mean there’s one safe control setting for every model.