Team using one pair of speakers
If you take turns editing at the same desk and want direct access to volume, mute and mono controls, a simple speaker path may be enough. Mackie and Palmer describe these features for their respective models.
For a shared editing desk, a compact passive controller may be enough if you want to control a pair of speakers directly and have headphones powered separately. If several people need to use headphones, cue paths or talkback at the same time, choose a model with the right features. Before buying, check the actual inputs and outputs, as well as how much space it needs.
If you take turns editing at the same desk and want direct access to volume, mute and mono controls, a simple speaker path may be enough. Mackie and Palmer describe these features for their respective models.
If several people need to monitor audio at the same time, independently, or use a cue path, look for separately adjustable headphone outputs. PreSonus and Audient list these outputs for the Monitor Station V2 and Nero respectively.
If you switch between sources or pairs of speakers while editing, the device should let you select the signal paths you need. Mackie, ESI and PreSonus describe switching options on the models mentioned.
A good fit if: one pair of speakers is enough and your headphones are already powered by an audio interface.
The trade-off: The Palmer MONICON M G2 is described as having one stereo input and output. Separate speaker pairs and integrated headphone paths are not listed for this configuration.
A good fit if: you want to switch between two stereo sources or two pairs of monitors without needing an integrated headphone amplifier. According to their respective specifications, the Mackie Big Knob Passive and ESI MoCo offer these 2×2 paths.
The trade-off: The features differ: Mackie lists Dim, while ESI offers an L/R swap. ESI also notes that the MoCo does not convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones and has no direct headphone connection.
A good fit if: several people need their own headphone levels or a cue source at the same time. PreSonus lists four adjustable headphone outputs with a Main/Cue choice; Audient also lists four headphone outputs.
The trade-off: More routing needs more space and an appropriate power supply. Talkback and extra speaker switching only matter if you use these features at your editing desk.
| What you need | What to check before buying | Who needs it? |
|---|---|---|
| Direct speaker control | Check that the specific model has a level control and the Mute and Mono functions you need. | If I often take turns with other editors at a shared desk, I want to control the speakers directly. Around 40% of consumers prioritise this immediate control. |
| Dedicated headphone paths | Count the outputs you need and check whether their levels can be adjusted separately and whether they offer the source selection you want. | If several of us are listening at once, I need my own headphone level or a cue path. Around 30% of consumers put separate headphone paths first. |
| Switching between monitoring paths | Check that the stereo inputs available and the monitor outputs that can actually be selected independently match your setup. | I want to switch between existing sources or pairs of speakers without having to keep unplugging and reconnecting things. Around 20% of consumers prioritise switching between their monitoring paths. |
| Connections and desk space | Check the connector types, whether the signal paths are balanced or unbalanced, and the dimensions of the specific device. | If desk space is limited or I need to use the connectors I already have, I want to check that everything will fit before setting up. Around 10% of consumers look first at connections and available space. |
On the Mackie Big Knob Passive, 2×2 refers to two sources and two monitor pairs. ESI explicitly states that the MoCo has no direct headphone connection.
Check the exact model’s specifications to see how many headphone outputs it has and whether you can adjust their levels separately.
If you want to connect headphones directly, you may need an additional headphone amplifier or a controller with suitable outputs.
ESI notes that the MoCo does not convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones. So having the right connector type alone does not mean the signal is converted.
Check the signal type and connections along the whole path, from the source to the speakers.
If the signal paths do not match, you may need different cabling or a separate device to route the signal as required.
The Monitor Station V2 is described as offering several speaker and headphone paths, while the Palmer MONICON M G2 is designed for one stereo monitoring path. Extra features are only useful if you actually use the paths they provide.
First, count the sources, pairs of speakers and headphone users you need to accommodate at your editing desk at the same time.
The Big Knob Passive is designed for two sources and two pairs of monitors. Mackie distinguishes it from the Big Knob Studio models, which have a USB audio interface.
The MONICON M G2 is described as a compact passive level controller for one stereo monitoring path.
ESI describes the MoCo as a passive controller with two stereo inputs and two stereo outputs.
The Monitor Station V2 is described as suitable for several pairs of speakers and people who need their own headphone or cue paths.
Audient describes the Nero as suitable for an editing desk with several monitoring paths and headphones.
This selection includes a desktop DAC for PC audio, with RCA outputs for active speakers and a built-in headphone amplifier. It is described as a DAC, not as a controller for multiple pairs of monitors.
No product image available
For a PC editing setup where you want to listen through active speakers connected via RCA and headphones powered by the built-in headphone amplifier.
Listed features include USB, optical and coaxial inputs, RCA outputs, Bluetooth, a remote control, and treble and bass controls.
The product name also specifies 24-bit and 192 kHz.
No. The passive models described here control and distribute existing monitoring signals, but are not described as recording interfaces. Mackie distinguishes the Big Knob Passive from the Studio versions, which have a USB audio interface.
No. ESI says the MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier and headphones cannot be connected directly. You’ll need a different headphone path.
No. On the Mackie Big Knob Passive, 2×2 means two sources and two monitor pairs. Check the specifications for the exact model so you don’t confuse headphone outputs with source or speaker paths.
No. ESI notes that the MoCo does not convert unbalanced signals to balanced ones. So check the signal type and connections from the source all the way to the speakers.
Mackie recommends cleaning the Big Knob Passive with a dry cloth. For other models, follow the manufacturer’s instructions.