Choir editing at a shared desk
When several people use the same editing desk, an easy-to-reach level control, mute and mono functions make it quicker to check your audio. Mackie lists these features for the Big Knob Passive.
For a shared editing desk, a passive monitor controller may be enough if you mainly want to adjust the level directly, check in mono and switch between two sets of monitors. If several people need to listen independently, or you need cue and talkback functions, a model with the right additional signal paths is a better choice. Before deciding, check the specific inputs and outputs and how much desk space you have. The documented features are not a comparative sound test.
When several people use the same editing desk, an easy-to-reach level control, mute and mono functions make it quicker to check your audio. Mackie lists these features for the Big Knob Passive.
If you want others to listen alongside you or need to manage recording sessions, check which headphone and cue paths you need, as well as whether you need talkback. PreSonus, Audient and Palmer list these features on certain models.
If you switch between several pairs of speakers, you’ll need the right outputs and a clear way to match their levels. PreSonus, Audient and Palmer list relevant features on their respective models.
A good fit if: You mainly want to adjust the level directly, check in mono or switch between speakers, and your audio interface provides the headphone output you need.
The trade-off: The Mackie Big Knob Passive, ESI MoCo and Swissonic M-Control + are examples with different features and connections. A passive controller does not automatically provide extra headphone or talkback paths.
A good fit if: You and other people need to listen at the same time, or hear different signals.
The trade-off: The PreSonus Monitor Station V2 and Audient Nero each have four headphone paths. Check that the signal sources, connections and talkback features suit your set-up.
A good fit if: You want to compare several pairs of speakers and two local headphone sockets are enough.
The trade-off: The Palmer MONICON XL has three speaker outputs and two headphone outputs with a Main/Cue selector. If you need more headphones connected directly, you’ll need another solution.
Start by deciding who needs to listen at the same time and which monitors you’ll connect. Then check whether a simple level control and switching path will do, or whether you need separate headphone, cue and talkback functions.
| Buying criterion | What to look for | Who needs it? |
|---|---|---|
| Level and mono | Check that the level, mute and mono controls are easy to reach, and that your interface provides the headphone path you need. | If I want to quickly turn the level down, mute the sound or check a passage in mono at a shared desk, easy access to the controls is essential. Around 36% of consumers say level and mono controls are their top priority. |
| Headphones, cue and talkback | Count how many people need to use headphones at the same time, and check whether the outputs can play Main or Cue. | If other people need to listen in or receive instructions during a recording, I want to route the signals and set the levels to suit. Around 29% of consumers put separate listening paths first. |
| Multiple pairs of speakers | Check the number of stereo outputs and whether you can match the levels of the connected pairs. | If I want to compare choir recordings across several reference monitors, I need the right switching options and a way to match levels. Around 21% of consumers prioritise comparing speakers. |
| Connections and desk space | Check the inputs and outputs, balanced or unbalanced signal paths, any digital connections you need and the space available on your desk. | If the controller needs to fit into an existing set-up, I want to know in advance that the signal path and footprint are right. Around 14% of consumers say connection and space requirements are their top priority. |
Some basic controllers don’t have a headphone socket of their own. In that case, the controller alone won’t give you an extra listening position.
Make a note of how many people need headphones at the same time and check which outputs your audio interface already has.
If you need an extra headphone path, you may need to add a separate headphone amplifier to your set-up.
ESI explicitly states that the MoCo does not convert an unbalanced input signal into a balanced output signal.
Compare the controller’s signal path and connections with your existing equipment, rather than looking only at the shape of the plugs.
Depending on your existing signal path, you may need additional suitable cables or other equipment.
Models vary in how many headphone paths they have built in. Extra outputs are only useful if they suit the listening positions and signals you actually need.
Before you buy, sketch out who needs to listen to the speakers, the Main headphones or the Cue feed at the same time.
The examples below refer to specific model ranges and features. Mentioning a brand does not mean a product is available.
The Big Knob range includes several monitor controllers, with the Big Knob Passive as its simple passive option.
The Monitor Station V2 is designed for set-ups with multiple sources, speaker paths and headphone positions.
The Nero is designed for set-ups with multiple monitors, a cue signal and extra headphone positions.
The MONICON XL combines several speaker outputs with two local headphone paths.
The MoCo is a passive controller for switching sources and speakers, as well as mono and left/right swaps.
The M-Control + is an example of a simple passive controller with two switchable speaker paths.
No. A passive monitor controller such as the Mackie Big Knob Passive does not replace an audio interface’s recording functions. Mackie describes this model as offering source and monitor switching, as well as level and monitoring controls. Check separately which tasks your interface already handles.
Connect the speakers using the available connections and match their levels for the comparison, if your controller allows you to do so. PreSonus lists level matching for its speaker outputs, Audient lists support for multiple monitors, and Palmer lists three speaker outputs.
Keep the listening level moderate and take regular breaks. The Federal Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (BAuA) covers how to prevent hearing damage in the music and entertainment industries in its guidance. This does not mean that any particular controller safely limits listening levels.
For a typical distance purchase from a business seller, you generally have 14 days from delivery to cancel. Exceptions may apply, and return costs may need to be considered. Your Europe explains the right to cancel distance purchases in the EU. Your statutory rights if goods are faulty are separate from a voluntary manufacturer’s guarantee, as the consumer advice centre explains.
Check the specific listing for labelling, product identification and manufacturer details, as well as German-language instructions with any required warnings. The Federal Network Agency covers these points as part of its market surveillance. A brand name alone does not prove that a particular device conforms to the requirements.