If you’re mixing a stereo version and your audio interface already gives you the monitoring routes and controls you need, you may not need an additional monitor controller. A stereo controller can give you quick access to level, mute or mono; a dedicated headphone route or the ability to use several headphones at once requires the relevant connections on the specific device. Delivering a true 5.1 mix requires discrete multichannel routes: several pairs of stereo speakers are no substitute, as the specifications from Mackie, PreSonus and Audient make clear.
Who can benefit from a monitor controller?
Stereo mixers sharing a desk
If you’re mixing a stereo version, an easy-to-reach level control and features such as mute or mono can make working at a shared desk more convenient. Check whether your interface already provides these controls and the connections you need; Mackie and Palmer document these features on selected models.
Those who need to work quietly on headphones
If you want to mute your speakers and carry on working through headphones, you’ll need a usable headphone signal path. ESI states that MoCo has no built-in headphone amplifier; Palmer lists a separately controlled headphone output for the MONICON L G2.
Mixers delivering multichannel audio
If you need to assess a true 5.1 mix on discrete speakers, the number and assignment of channels must be right. Audient describes the ASP510 as supporting surround routes up to 5.1; several switchable stereo pairs don’t automatically meet this requirement.
What should you look for when buying?
First, work out whether you’re monitoring in stereo or discrete 5.1. Then consider the available routes on your interface, and whether you’ll be listening alone or sharing headphones with others.
| Requirement |
What to check before buying |
Who should pay particular attention? |
| Level control and monitoring buttons |
Check whether your interface already provides the controls you need. Compare the controller’s level control and mono, dim and mute functions, and check that the line connections are compatible. |
If I want to reach the level control and monitoring buttons easily at a shared desk, this is my top priority; around 36% of consumers prioritise direct control. |
| Quiet working on headphones |
Check whether your interface already has a suitable headphone output. If not, the device you choose must provide an appropriate headphone route and level control. |
Anyone who wants to mute the speakers and carry on working alone on headphones needs a usable, separately controlled signal path; around 29% of consumers prioritise this. |
| Stereo routes and shared listening |
Count the stereo sources, monitor pairs and headphones you actually need to use at the same time. If several people will be listening, individual level controls and a suitable Main/Cue selection are important. |
If I want to switch between sources or stereo monitoring routes, or listen with other people, I check that there are enough suitable routes; around 21% of consumers put this need first. |
| Discrete 5.1 |
Identify the delivery format, interface outputs and speaker channels. Check that the controller supports discrete surround signals and provides the outputs you need. |
Anyone who needs to assess a true 5.1 mix on separate channels needs a suitable multichannel monitoring chain; around 14% of consumers prioritise discrete 5.1 monitoring. |
Avoiding buying and connection mistakes
-
Assuming a passive controller has a headphone output
A passive speaker controller doesn’t necessarily include a headphone amplifier. ESI explicitly states that you can’t connect headphones directly to MoCo.
Before buying, check the headphone signal path on the exact model and confirm whether your interface provides a suitable output.
-
Assuming several stereo speaker pairs provide discrete 5.1
Switchable stereo pairs aren’t the same as separate 5.1 channels. PreSonus documents stereo speaker routes for Monitor Station V2, while Audient describes the ASP510 as supporting surround sources up to 5.1.
First, confirm the delivery format and the discrete outputs you have available. Choose a multichannel controller only if your monitoring chain really does need to support a 5.1 mix.
-
Choosing connections by plug shape alone
Signal types and connections can vary from one device to another. ESI explains that MoCo doesn’t convert an unbalanced input signal to a balanced one.
Check the signal type and connections from your interface through the controller to each speaker before choosing a model.
Key brands at a glance
Mackie
According to Mackie, Big Knob Passive is designed for switching between stereo sources and monitor pairs, as well as providing essential monitoring controls.
- Mackie lists two sources, two monitor pairs, and mono, mute and dim functions.
- Mackie’s model comparison lists neither USB audio I/O nor headphone outputs for the Passive version. These specifications don’t automatically apply to other Big Knob models.
Palmer
The manufacturer describes the MONICON M G2 as a compact stereo signal path; the MONICON L G2 adds further stereo routes and a separately controlled headphone output.
- Palmer lists a stereo input and output, plus mono, dim and mute functions, for the M G2. The L G2 adds two stereo outputs, a mono output and headphone level control.
- The L G2’s additional headphone features aren’t automatically included with the M G2.
ESI
ESI describes MoCo as a passive stereo controller for switching sources and speakers, with different connection types.
- ESI lists two stereo input and output routes, as well as mono and mute functions.
- According to ESI, MoCo doesn’t convert an unbalanced input signal to a balanced one and has no built-in headphone amplifier.
PreSonus
According to the manufacturer, Monitor Station V2 is designed for set-ups with several stereo monitoring routes and multiple headphone users.
- PreSonus documents three stereo speaker pairs and four headphone outputs, each with individual level control and Main/Cue selection.
- This set-up isn’t the same as discrete 5.1 routing.
Audient
Audient lists Nero as offering several stereo, subwoofer and headphone routes; the ASP510 is a separate solution for discrete surround monitoring.
- For Nero, Audient lists three stereo speaker routes, subwoofer assignment and four headphone outputs. For the ASP510, the manufacturer documents surround support up to 5.1 and six speaker outputs.
- The ASP510 is a rack-mounted unit with a desktop remote, and is more involved to set up for a straightforward stereo mixing desk.
Suitable products at Joybuy
Related products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Does a passive monitor controller replace my audio interface?
No. A passive monitor controller doesn’t automatically handle tasks such as recording audio. Mackie describes Big Knob Passive as a device for controlling and switching between existing monitoring signals; the model comparison doesn’t list USB audio I/O for this version. Check which functions your interface already provides.
How do I set up a quiet headphone station?
Use a dedicated headphone output on your interface or a controller with a headphone amplifier. ESI explicitly rules out connecting headphones directly to MoCo. Start at a low volume: Germany’s Federal Environment Agency warns that listening too loudly can damage your hearing.
What are your rights if an online purchase is faulty in Germany?
As the consumer advice centre explains, your statutory rights when buying as a consumer are separate from a manufacturer’s voluntary guarantee. Where a statutory right to cancel applies to the distance contract in question, the period is generally 14 days. For a standard purchase of goods, it generally starts when you receive them. The German Civil Code sets out this period in section 355 and the start date for goods in section 356.
Does every monitor controller sold in Germany need a CE mark?
Not simply because of the product name. The European Commission says that CE marking is required for products covered by harmonised EU rules that call for it. The requirements that apply to a particular device must be checked on a product-by-product basis; this general rule doesn’t confirm that any specific model complies.