Who will print and scan?

Groups with lots of text-based lists

If you regularly print several easy-to-read checklists without colour coding, compare paper capacity, duplex printing and the consumables you’ll need. Brother Germany lists a 250-sheet tray and automatic duplex printing for the DCP-L2620DW.

Groups that use colour coding

If colours indicate statuses or equipment groups, you’ll need a printer that can print in colour. Canon Germany and HP Germany’s model ranges show that features and consumables vary from one printer to another.

Groups that keep paper records

If you copy or digitise completed lists, check the document feeder and the stated scan type. Canon Germany lists a 35-sheet A4 feeder for the MAXIFY GX4050; Epson describes the ET-3950 as having an automatic two-sided document feeder.

What should you look for?

Mono laser multifunction printer

A good fit if: your checklists are clear without colour coding and you regularly print text.

Bear in mind: The Brother DCP-L2620DW prints in black and white only; toner and drum are separate consumables.

Colour multifunction printer with cartridges

A good fit if: you need colour coding, but only some of your checklists need to be in colour.

Bear in mind: Features and the cartridges required vary by model.

Colour multifunction printer with an ink tank

A good fit if: you regularly print colour-coded lists and are happy to use refillable ink.

Bear in mind: Your print mix, usage and maintenance parts all affect which consumables you’ll need.

What matters What to look for Who should consider it?
Regular text printing Check the paper tray, automatic duplex printing and whether the connection options suit your group. If we regularly print easy-to-read text lists and want to avoid changing the paper too often, a suitable feeder is particularly important. Around 40% of consumers put reliable text printing first.
Consumables Find out which toner, drums, cartridges or ink the specific model needs, as well as any maintenance parts. When we compare printers for our planned print mix, we want to know which parts will need replacing or servicing. Around 30% of consumers prioritise consumables and maintenance parts.
Digitising paper lists Check the ADF capacity, supported original sizes and whether duplex scanning is explicitly listed. If we copy or scan completed lists in batches, a suitable document feeder is essential. Around 20% of consumers focus on handling paper lists.
Colour coding Check whether the list remains clear in greyscale; if not, consider colour printing and the consumables it requires. If colours identify statuses or equipment, we need to preserve that distinction on the printout. Around 10% of consumers prioritise colour coding.

Common mistakes

  • Confusing duplex printing with duplex scanning

    A printer can automatically print on both sides of the paper without scanning double-sided originals in a single pass. Canon Germany lists duplex printing separately from simplex scanning for the MAXIFY GX4050.

    If you want to scan double-sided lists in batches, check specifically whether the model supports duplex scanning.

    Without duplex scanning, you’ll need to turn over double-sided lists by hand before capturing them.

  • Considering only one type of consumable

    Depending on the model, you may need parts in addition to ink or toner. Brother lists separate toner and drum units for the DCP-L2620DW, while Canon lists a replaceable maintenance cartridge for the GX4050.

    For every printer you compare, use the same print mix and period of use, and account for all the relevant consumables and maintenance parts.

  • Choosing a mono printer before checking your colour codes

    The Brother DCP-L2620DW prints in black and white. If colours convey information on your checklists, this model won’t be able to reproduce it.

    Try a typical list in greyscale. If categories or statuses are no longer clear, compare colour printers.

    If colour becomes essential later, you may need to replace the printer or find another way to print in colour.

Relevant brands and model ranges

Brother

The DCP-L2620DW is an example of a mono laser multifunction printer with Wi-Fi and automatic duplex printing.

  • Brother Germany lists a 250-sheet tray for this model.
  • It doesn’t print in colour; toner and drum are separate consumables.

Canon

The MAXIFY GX4050 is an example of a refillable A4 colour printer with LAN, Wi-Fi and a document feeder.

  • Canon Germany lists a 35-sheet A4 document feeder and automatic duplex printing.
  • Scanning is listed as simplex; duplex printing doesn’t mean it can scan both sides. A replaceable maintenance cartridge is also specified.

HP

The Smart Tank ranges offer different combinations of refillable colour printing and scanning features.

  • HP Germany lists automatic duplex printing and a 35-sheet document feeder for the Smart Tank 7600 series.
  • For the Smart Tank 5100 series, HP lists manual duplex printing and a flatbed scanner; features vary by series.

Epson

The EcoTank ET-3950 is an example of an A4 ink tank multifunction printer with an automatic two-sided document feeder.

  • Epson describes this model as having refillable tanks and a two-sided document feeder.
  • Manufacturer claims about potential ink savings don’t tell you which consumables you’ll need for your own print mix.

Joybuy printers for checklists

These Joybuy printers offer colour or monochrome laser printing for shared checklists.

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3302sdwg

A good choice for shared colour checklists when you need automatic two-sided printing and a range of connection options.

Colour laser multifunction printer with automatic two-sided printing, Wi-Fi, Ethernet and USB. The product title also mentions a touchscreen.

View at Joybuy
PANTUM BM2300NW A4 mono laser multifunction printer

PANTUM BM2300NW A4 Mono Laser Multifunction Printer

A good choice for text-based checklists if black-and-white printing is enough and Wi-Fi or Ethernet suits your group network.

A4 mono laser multifunction printer with Wi-Fi and Ethernet. Duplex printing is manual, so you’ll need to turn the paper over to print on both sides.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Do we need colour printing for our checklists?

Only if the information on the printout relies on colour. If statuses and categories are still clear in greyscale, a mono printer such as the Brother DCP-L2620DW could be suitable. Otherwise, consider a colour model and the consumables it requires.

Can a printer with duplex printing automatically scan completed lists on both sides?

No. Duplex printing alone doesn’t mean a printer can scan both sides. Canon Germany lists automatic duplex printing separately from the scan specifications for the MAXIFY GX4050. If you need to scan double-sided originals, check specifically whether the model supports duplex scanning.

What matters for a shared network printer?

Check that Wi-Fi or Ethernet suits your group’s network, and decide who will manage printing and scanning. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security outlines information and internal IT risks associated with printers and multifunction devices. Its IT baseline protection guidance is a set of security recommendations, not a general legal requirement for clubs to buy a particular printer.

How should we account for consumables and maintenance parts?

Compare the models over the same period of use and print mix, and list the toner, ink or cartridges each one needs, along with any drum and maintenance parts. Brother Germany and Canon Germany specify these components for individual models; what your group will need depends on the printer and your print profile.