Which approach is right for you?

Check game support first

You play specific mystery games and mainly want to know whether they support your controller and platform. Valve lists controller support on Steam for individual games and device types.

Keep cables to a minimum

You want to avoid adding another cable alongside your keyboard, mouse or puzzle notes. Check whether your PC has Bluetooth or whether a wireless receiver will take up a spare port. Microsoft and 8BitDo list different connection options for their respective models.

Comfortable controls at a dedicated spot

You mostly play at the same desk and are weighing up grip, buttons and wired or battery power. GameSir, PowerA and Microsoft list features for their respective models; these are not independent assessments of comfort.

What should you look for when buying?

Priority What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Game and platform support Check the information for the specific game and the controller types listed. Make sure they match your platform. If I want to play a particular mystery game with a controller, I first check the game and platform. Around 36% of consumers put support for the specific game first.
Cables and connections Consider the cable route and check for spare USB ports and existing Bluetooth support. Don’t assume the connection type from the word “wireless” alone. If there’s hardly any room on my small desk for another cable, I look at the connection type and available ports. Around 29% of consumers prioritise a clear desk.
Grip and buttons Try the button layout and grip yourself, if possible. Only consider extra buttons if you plan to use them in your games. If I want easy-to-reach buttons and a comfortable grip for longer puzzle sessions, I compare these features carefully. Around 21% of consumers say ease of use is their top priority.
Power and ongoing costs Check the battery type, charging options and included accessories for the specific model. Consider whether you’ll need batteries or a separate rechargeable battery solution. If I want to spend less time changing or charging batteries, I check the power supply before buying. Around 14% of consumers put this first.

Common misconceptions

  • A compatible controller won’t necessarily work in every game

    Knowing that a controller can connect to your PC doesn’t tell you whether your mystery game supports it or which device types the game recognises.

    Before comparing models, check the information for your specific game and platform.

  • “Wireless” doesn’t tell you how it connects to Windows

    For the 8BitDo Ultimate 2C Wireless, the manufacturer lists 2.4 GHz or wired connections for Windows. Bluetooth is listed for Android with this model.

    Check the connection type for the exact model variant and make sure your PC has the port it needs.

    Power supply is part of your choice

    Models vary in whether they use AA batteries, a built-in rechargeable battery or a cable while you play.

    Check the battery type, charging options and what’s included with the specific offer.

    With a model that uses AA batteries, you’ll need batteries or a rechargeable alternative you choose separately. A built-in battery needs charging.

  • Special DualSense features aren’t available in every game

    According to Sony, adaptive triggers and haptic feedback require support from the game itself. On PC, haptic feedback also requires a USB connection.

    Check whether your game supports the features you want and whether the required connection works for you.

A look at the key brands

Microsoft Xbox

An option if you’re looking for a controller for Xbox or a supported Windows PC, with the choice of Bluetooth or a USB connection depending on your setup.

  • Microsoft lists Bluetooth, USB and Xbox Wireless as connection options. Textured grips are another feature of the controller.
  • The right connection depends on your PC. If you use it wirelessly, you’ll also need to plan for batteries or your chosen rechargeable battery solution. These are manufacturer claims, not the result of an independent comfort test.

8BitDo

The Ultimate 2C Wireless is worth considering if you want to use a 2.4 GHz receiver or a wired connection with a Windows PC.

  • For this model, 8BitDo lists Hall Effect joysticks, mappable extra bumpers and a built-in rechargeable battery.
  • For this model, the manufacturer lists Bluetooth for Android, not as a Bluetooth connection for Windows. This doesn’t prove any independent durability or response-time advantage.

GameSir

The G7 SE is a wired option for a dedicated gaming spot with Windows 10/11 or Xbox, provided a USB-C port is within reach.

  • The GameSir manual lists USB-C, Hall Effect joysticks and two lockable rear buttons for the G7 SE.
  • This model is listed as wired. The manufacturer’s claim about stick drift isn’t an independent guarantee of lifespan.

Sony PlayStation

The DualSense is an option for PS5 or for PC games where you’ve checked controller and feature support.

  • Sony documents USB and Bluetooth connections to supported PCs.
  • Adaptive triggers and haptic feedback require support from the game. According to Sony, haptic feedback also requires a USB connection on PC. This doesn’t establish a general advantage for mystery games.

PowerA

The Enhanced Wired Controller for Xbox Series X|S is another wired option for a dedicated Windows or Xbox gaming spot.

  • For this model, PowerA lists two mappable buttons and a detachable 3-m USB cable.
  • Whether the cable is a good fit for your small desk depends on how you can route it. The manufacturer’s ergonomics claim isn’t an independent comparison.

Controllers at Joybuy

This selection includes controllers for PC gaming with wireless or wired connections; one model also lists PS5 compatibility. Remember to check controller support for each specific game.

The G-Lab K-PAD-HELIUM-WL Gaming Controller, Wireless 2.4 GHz, PC, 2 Back Paddles

The G-Lab K-PAD-HELIUM-WL, Wireless 2.4 GHz, PC

A good fit if you want to play on PC without a controller cable and have a spare USB port for the wireless receiver.

The description lists a 2.4 GHz USB receiver, two programmable rear buttons and a rechargeable battery.

View at Joybuy
BIGBIG WON GALE HALL Wireless Controller

BIGBIG WON GALE HALL Wireless Controller

Worth considering if you’re looking for a controller listed for PC that offers both wireless and wired connections.

The product title mentions Hall Effect triggers and four customisable buttons; the description lists Bluetooth 5.0 and a USB-C cable.

View at Joybuy
Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller, Pulse Red, Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S and PC

Microsoft Xbox Wireless Controller, Pulse Red

A good fit if you want to use Bluetooth with a supported Windows PC and have checked that your game supports it.

The description lists a textured grip, a hybrid D-pad and two AA batteries. Check whether you’d prefer to use batteries or another rechargeable battery solution.

View at Joybuy
PlayStation DualSense Wireless Gaming Controller, White

PlayStation DualSense Wireless Gaming Controller, White

A good fit for PS5 or for PC games where you’ve checked controller support.

The description lists Bluetooth and USB-C. According to Sony, haptic feedback requires support from the game and, on PC, a USB connection.

View at Joybuy
GameSir Kaleid Smoke Transparent RGB Wired Game Controller for Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One, Win10/Win11

GameSir Kaleid Smoke Transparent RGB, wired

A good fit for a dedicated Windows or Xbox gaming spot if you can route the cable neatly on your small desk.

The title lists Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One and Windows 10/11; the description lists a detachable 3-m USB-C cable.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is “PC-compatible” enough to make my mystery game work with a controller?

No. Also check the information for the specific game and the controller types it lists. Steam lists Return of the Obra Dinn as having full controller support, specifically naming Xbox controllers, while support for other devices is listed as unknown.

Do I always need Bluetooth for a wireless controller?

No. Microsoft lists Bluetooth as a connection option for the Xbox Wireless Controller on compatible Windows PCs; for the Ultimate 2C Wireless, 8BitDo lists 2.4 GHz or wired connections on Windows. Check the connection type for the exact model and the ports available on your PC.

How do I connect an Xbox controller to a Windows PC with a cable?

Microsoft describes connecting Xbox Series X|S controllers to a PC with a USB-C cable that can transfer data. Older Xbox controller versions may use a different connection.

Do the DualSense’s special effects work in every PC game?

No. According to Sony, adaptive triggers and haptic feedback must be supported by the game itself. Haptic feedback also requires a USB connection on PC.