Photographers with multiple edits
If you keep originals alongside repeatedly edited files for a costume project, the right versioning features can help you find earlier versions when you need them.
For a carnival archive with multiple edited versions, a NAS is a good choice if its versioning or snapshot feature supports the folders you use and the file system you’ve chosen. Alongside your originals and project files, allow for enough usable storage and a separate backup: the Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping backups separate, and Synology points out that RAID is no substitute for a backup. Faster network connections are most relevant when your other devices and workflow can make use of them too.
If you keep originals alongside repeatedly edited files for a costume project, the right versioning features can help you find earlier versions when you need them.
If you need to be able to recover project folders after accidental deletion or a security incident, plan for a backup separate from your NAS and test that you can restore your files.
If several people need to search for or share photos, suitable sharing options and access permissions matter. If people are identifiable in the images, you should also consider how the photos will be used and shared.
| Your needs | What to check before buying | Who should pay particular attention |
|---|---|---|
| Older project versions | Check whether versioning or snapshots cover the folders you need and work with your file system, and find out how long older versions are kept. QNAP describes restoring individual files; ASUSTOR lists Btrfs as a requirement for volume snapshots. | If I want to retrieve an earlier edit of a costume series, I need the right versions for those specific project folders. Around 33% of consumers put access to older versions first. |
| Recovery after data loss | Plan a separate backup destination and check that you can restore an entire project folder. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backups from the rest of the network’s systems once the backup process is complete. | If the photos can’t be taken again, I want to be able to restore them even if the NAS itself fails. Around 27% of consumers prioritise separate backups and recovery. |
| Usable storage | Allow for originals, edited versions and the space needed to store previous versions. According to QNAP, with RAID 1 the smaller drive determines the usable capacity. | If my archive grows with new costume projects, what matters is the space actually available, not just the drives’ raw capacity. Around 20% of consumers pay particular attention to storage for a growing archive. |
| Team access and networking | Check sharing and user permissions, as well as the entire network setup. A 2,5-GbE connection is most relevant when your connected devices and switch support it too. | If several people need to choose photos together, I want to control access appropriately and make it easy for the team to find files. Around 20% of consumers prioritise choosing photos together and controlled sharing. |
Snapshots and RAID don’t do the same job as a separate backup. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping backup copies separate, and Synology specifically points out that RAID is no substitute for a backup.
Plan a separate backup destination and test whether you can restore an entire project folder from it.
Original photos, edited versions and stored versions all take up space. According to QNAP, with RAID 1 the smaller drive determines the usable capacity.
Calculate the available storage based on your planned drive configuration, and allow for keeping older versions.
Transfer speeds quoted by manufacturers depend on the test environment and configuration. They don’t automatically tell you what speeds your own network setup will achieve.
Check your client device, switch and cabling together, and choose additional network connections only if your workflow can make use of them.
According to Synology, the DiskStation DS225+ combines NAS file management with photo management and file versioning for project archives.
According to QNAP, the TS-264 has two drive bays and two 2,5-GbE ports; QTS documentation explains how snapshots can be used to restore individual files.
According to ASUSTOR, the NIMBUSTOR 2 Gen2 AS5402T is aimed at buyers looking for M.2 slots and multiple network connections.
No, RAID 1 isn’t a separate backup. Synology points out that RAID is no substitute for a backup. Keep another copy and test whether you can restore an entire project folder from it.
Set up a supported versioning or snapshot feature for the relevant folders, and choose a schedule and retention period. Test restoring an individual file; for volume snapshots on ASUSTOR, the manufacturer’s help documentation lists a Btrfs volume as a requirement.
It depends on what’s included with the particular model; QNAP explicitly states that the TS-264 is supplied without an HDD. Check the details for the model you’re considering, make sure the drives are compatible and find out whether you’ll need to arrange a separate backup destination.
Choosing a NAS doesn’t determine whether a particular photo or publication is permitted. The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Rhineland-Palatinate points out that photos in which living people are identifiable may contain personal data, and that clubs must take the GDPR into account when processing personal data. Check which legal basis applies in each case; consent is one option, but not the only one. Private use, club-related use and publication must be considered separately.