Who should consider a NAS for choir recordings?

People responsible for recording backups

If you need to restore rehearsal recordings and project versions after a failure, plan for a separate backup destination as well as the NAS. The German Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting offline backups from the rest of the IT network once the backup is complete.

People managing a growing choir archive

For large project folders that grow over many rehearsals, the enclosure, compatible drives and actual usable storage capacity all need to work together. For example, a two-bay enclosure limits the number of internal drives you can install at once.

People coordinating shared projects

If several contributors need access to recordings and editing files, suitable sharing settings and access permissions are essential. Decide who can view or edit files, and check how to restore earlier versions.

Key buying considerations

First decide which project versions you need to be able to restore. Then choose drives and network equipment to suit your workflow. Shared folders also require a separate step to set up access permissions.

To protect against ransomware, the German Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting an offline backup from the rest of the IT network once the backup is complete.

Buying consideration What to check before you buy Who it matters most to
Separate backup and restore Check the backup destination, schedule and process for restoring a complete project folder; plan for a copy that’s disconnected after the backup. If I need to recover earlier project versions after a fault or accidental deletion, I plan for a copy that’s separate from the NAS. Around 33% of consumers consider recovery their top buying priority.
Usable space for project folders Estimate the size of your existing folders and expected growth; check which drives are included, compatibility and the usable capacity of your planned setup. For a choir archive that grows over many rehearsals, there needs to be enough space for originals and additional versions. Around 27% of consumers put archive capacity first.
Transferring large files Compare the NAS connection with your computer, switch and the rest of the network path. Manufacturers’ speed claims aren’t a guarantee of performance in your setup. If I regularly transfer large recording folders, the whole network path matters to me, not just the NAS connection. Around 20% of consumers prioritise transferring large files.
Team access and earlier file versions Decide who can read or edit recordings, and test how to restore an earlier file. If several contributors work on shared project folders, I need suitable permissions and a way to undo changes. Around 20% of consumers give the greatest weight to managing team access and earlier file versions.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming a NAS or RAID array is a complete backup

    A copy on the same running system isn’t separate from the rest of the network. To protect against ransomware, the German Federal Office for Information Security recommends an offline backup that’s disconnected once the backup is complete.

    Before comparing enclosures, plan for a separate backup destination and test whether you can restore a project folder from it.

    An additional backup destination takes up space and needs regular attention; restore tests also need to be part of your workflow.

  • Confusing enclosure capacity with usable storage

    The number of bays alone doesn’t tell you how much space will be available for recordings and additional file versions. Some models are sold without drives, so check what’s included and the compatibility of the exact model.

    Plan around your existing project folders and expected growth, and check drive support before settling on a configuration.

    Additional compatible drives and storage set aside for extra versions add to the planning involved.

  • Confusing the NAS connection with the speed of the whole network

    A 2.5GbE connection doesn’t mean your computer, switch and the rest of the network path support the same connection. Manufacturers’ laboratory results also aren’t necessarily representative of performance in your choir’s setup.

    Check your computer and network path alongside the NAS, and assess performance claims only in light of the test conditions stated.

    Depending on your existing equipment, you may need additional compatible networking kit.

  • Confusing mirroring with having several restorable versions

    A single current copy doesn’t automatically let you restore an earlier edit. Synology and TerraMaster document different backup modes for different use cases.

    Choose a mode based on the point in time you want to restore, and test how to recover an earlier file.

    Keeping several file versions requires additional storage space.

Relevant brands at a glance

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay model with a 2.5GbE connection. Synology’s Hyper Backup documentation covers multi-version backups to external destinations.

  • The guide explains how to create backups with multiple versions on external devices.
  • Check drive compatibility and the DSM version for the exact model; Synology still refers users to its compatibility list.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G combines two SATA bays with two 2.5GbE ports. QNAP’s HBS documentation covers external backup destinations.

  • According to QNAP, HBS supports backup, restoration and synchronisation with external or remote destinations.
  • QNAP lists the TS-264-8G without hard drives, so compatible drives and network components need to be budgeted for separately.

UGREEN

UGREEN describes the NASync DXP2800 as a diskless two-bay device with 2.5GbE.

  • The manufacturer’s specifications list two drive bays and a 2.5GbE connection.
  • You’ll need to buy drives separately; check the compatibility list for the exact model before you buy.

TerraMaster

According to TerraMaster, the F2-425 is a two-bay model with 2.5GbE. For TOS 6, the manufacturer documents a USB copy function with different backup modes.

  • The guide distinguishes between incremental, mirrored and multi-version USB copy tasks.
  • For large individual files, check that the USB copy setup is compatible with your chosen file system; the guide notes limitations with FAT32 or exFAT.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 AS3302T v2 is a two-bay option with 2.5GbE; ASUSTOR also lists Btrfs and iSCSI snapshots.

  • Snapshots can be useful for restoring earlier file versions; check the requirements for your chosen storage configuration.
  • ASUSTOR’s throughput figures come from its own optimised laboratory tests and aren’t a guarantee of performance on your network.

Joybuy NAS picks

The Synology NAS models below offer different numbers of bays and network connections for central choir project storage. Choose the required drives and a separate backup destination to suit your workflow.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS

The four bays and stated expansion option may suit growing project folders; actual usable capacity depends on the drive configuration.

The product title lists two 2.5GbE connections and expansion to up to nine bays.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-Bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-Bay NAS

The eight listed bays may appeal if you have a large or growing project archive; work out the usable capacity based on your specific drive configuration.

The product title lists two 2.5GbE connections, optional 10GbE and up to 360 TB.

View at Joybuy
Synology DS225+ 2-Bay NAS

Synology DS225+ 2-Bay NAS

For central storage with shared access, the product description lists user accounts and shared folders; two bays limit the number of internal drives.

The product title lists 2.5GbE, Gigabit LAN and USB-A 3.0. Synology documents multi-version backups to external devices for the DS225+; compatible drives need to be purchased separately.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID enough to back up choir recordings?

No. Plan for an additional separate copy and test the restoration process. To protect against ransomware, the German Federal Office for Information Security recommends an offline backup that’s disconnected from the network once the backup is complete; RAID in the same device doesn’t provide this separation.

How do I back up a project folder to a USB drive?

First, check your NAS guide and choose between a single copy and several restorable versions. Synology documents multi-version backups to external devices for Hyper Backup; TerraMaster describes different USB copy modes for TOS 6. Then test the restoration process.

Can a choir simply store identifiable rehearsal recordings on a NAS and share them with all its members?

There’s no blanket answer. The guidance from the Baden-Württemberg data protection authority includes audio recordings in its advice on information about people. Check the legal basis for your specific purpose and decide who should be allowed to access the recordings.