Who a NAS-based choir archive is for

Choir archive managers

If you want to recover rehearsal recordings after accidental deletion or device failure, you should set up a separate backup and restore process as well as storing the files. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) recommends regular backups and points out that mirroring alone does not count as a backup.

Choir leaders who need to share access

If selected people need to access recordings on the local network, shared folders and individually assigned permissions are important. Guidance from the State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information Baden-Württemberg treats audio recordings as potential personal data.

People using different recording devices

If you transfer recordings after every rehearsal from USB devices or different computers, check the import process on the specific NAS. QNAP documents a USB copy button and backups to external drives on the TS-233; Synology also describes local backup destinations via USB.

What to look for when choosing

For a NAS used to store choir rehearsal recordings without cloud storage, the main priorities are recovery, controlled access, a practical import process and the cost of the complete setup.

Consideration What to check before buying Who it matters to
Independent backup and recovery External backup destination, retention plan, keeping the backup device separate and testing a restore. The BSI explicitly distinguishes an independent backup from data mirroring. If I need to retrieve deleted or older rehearsal recordings, I need a tested way to restore them. Around 36% of consumers say recovery is their top priority.
Local access and permissions Local shared folders, separate user accounts and appropriate read and write permissions; check separately for any cloud or remote access features you don’t need. If several choir members use the recordings, I want to limit access to the people who need it without setting up cloud storage as the destination. Around 29% of consumers put controlled local access first.
Easy imports after rehearsal For USB devices, check the port, supported file system, copy direction and destination folder. For a computer, test transferring files through a local network share. If I regularly transfer recordings from a recorder or computer, the process should work with my existing device and preferred setup. Around 21% of consumers prioritise straightforward file transfers.
Total cost and capacity Plan for recording volumes and future growth, usable rather than raw capacity, suitable drives and a separate backup device. If I’m putting together a complete choir archive, I want to budget for drives and a second backup as well as the NAS enclosure. Around 14% of consumers see the cost of the complete setup as their top priority.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Assuming two mirrored hard drives provide a complete backup

    Mirroring also copies unwanted changes. The BSI therefore does not regard it as an independent data backup.

    When buying a NAS, plan for a separate local backup destination and test whether you can restore a recording from it.

    A separate backup device and time for regular restore tests are part of the practical overhead.

  • Comparing enclosures or raw capacity alone

    Usable capacity depends, among other things, on the drives installed and the RAID configuration you choose.

    Before buying, put together a specific configuration that includes the drives, usable capacity and an independent backup. Also check drive compatibility for the model in question.

    Drives and an additional backup device will take up part of your budget on top of the NAS enclosure.

  • Assuming a USB copy button guarantees the right process

    A button alone doesn’t confirm that the NAS will copy recordings in the right direction or to the right folder. The process may also depend on whether the device is recognised.

    Set up a local backup destination and test importing a sample recording and restoring it with the USB device you actually use.

NAS brands at a glance

Synology

The DS223j is an example of a two-bay NAS for central file storage. The DS225+ adds features including a 2.5 GbE port. Synology documents local backups to external devices using Hyper Backup.

  • The manufacturer’s documentation describes sharing and backup features for the DS223j.
  • Throughput figures for the DS225+ come from the manufacturer’s own tests and don’t prove a specific benefit for backing up choir recordings. Check drive compatibility for the specific model and DSM version you’re using.

QNAP

The TS-233 combines local file storage with USB ports and a USB copy button. QNAP documents backups to external drives using Hybrid Backup Sync.

  • According to the official specifications, the TS-233 has one USB 3.2 Gen 1 port and two USB 2.0 ports.
  • The TS-233’s 2 GB of memory can’t be expanded, according to the manufacturer. Check whether the copy button performs the import or backup task you need.

ASUSTOR

The ADM help guide describes scheduled external backups between a NAS and a drive in either direction.

  • A scheduled local backup process is one documented way to include external storage.
  • The guide doesn’t confirm that every model’s ports or every external drive will work with your recording device. Check the process for the exact NAS model.

TerraMaster

The TOS 7 help guide describes USB Copy as a local way to transfer and back up files.

  • According to TerraMaster, recognised USB and SD devices with supported file systems can be used for backups.
  • The USB Copy process requires a file system the NAS can recognise. Check your device’s compatibility before buying and setting it up.

NAS picks at Joybuy

These NAS enclosures may suit choir archives where, alongside local storage, you need to run several tasks at once or use additional management features. Check that the features and number of drive bays match your choir’s needs.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ with four drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS

Could suit you if you need to handle several storage or management tasks alongside your choir archive; check whether the extra features are necessary for your setup.

Four drive bays, two 2.5 GbE ports and expansion to up to nine bays. M.2 NVMe SSD caching is specified in the product name.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ with eight drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-Bay NAS

Could suit a shared archive that needs to handle several tasks at once; check first whether eight drive bays are right for the size and management needs of your choir archive.

Eight drive bays and two 2.5 GbE ports. A 10 GbE upgrade is listed as an optional extra.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up choir recordings?

No. According to the BSI, mirroring isn’t a data backup because changes are copied to both drives at the same time. Set up a separate copy and test whether you can restore recordings from it.

Do I need to disconnect from the internet to use a NAS without cloud storage?

Not for that reason alone. Here, ‘without cloud storage’ means keeping the backup on a local destination such as an external USB drive; manufacturers document these local backup options alongside optional cloud features. When setting up the NAS, check separately which online features you want to enable.

How can I make sure my NAS backup is usable when I need it?

Set up a regular backup schedule, keep a physical backup device separate from the original device and occasionally check that you can read or restore the files. The BSI recommends checking that a backup can be read; no particular NAS guarantees this automatically.

How should I budget for a NAS-based choir archive?

Factor in the enclosure, the compatible drives you need and a separate backup device. Usable capacity depends, among other things, on the drives and RAID configuration you choose, so compare the complete setup rather than just the enclosure or raw capacity.

Can a choir store and share rehearsal recordings simply because they’re kept on its own NAS?

No. The storage location alone doesn’t settle the matter. The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information Baden-Württemberg lists audio recordings as potential personal data. Under certain conditions, Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers the unauthorised recording of privately spoken words, as well as the use or sharing of a recording made in this way. Whether this applies to a particular rehearsal can’t be determined simply by choosing a device.