For earlier versions of individual files, correctly configured file versioning can be useful. Snapshots, on the other hand, can capture earlier states of shared folders, provided the file system and retention settings support them. Neither replaces a separate backup: the German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) explicitly distinguishes data backups from RAID mirroring. So plan for compatible drives, access permissions and a separate backup destination, then test that you can restore the files you need.
Who is this plan for?
Project teams with multiple versions in progress
If you need to retrieve earlier versions of individual files or previous states of shared project folders, treat file versioning and snapshots as separate features. Synology describes versioning for the DS225+; ASUSTOR and TerraMaster document snapshot features for certain models and configurations.
People responsible for recovery
If you’re responsible for club documents, decide where to keep a copy separate from the NAS and how to restore files when needed. The BSI recommends planning and preparing for recovery.
Teams with different access roles
If everyone shouldn’t be able to view or edit the same documents, separate accounts and suitable folder permissions are important considerations when choosing and setting up your NAS. If you store personal data, you’ll also need to take the applicable data protection requirements into account.
What should you look for when buying?
First, decide whether you need individual file versions or earlier folder states. Either way, plan for a separate backup destination in case the NAS fails.
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who is it important to? |
| Earlier project versions |
Check that versioning is available for the folders you need, or that snapshots are supported by the file system and retention settings. |
If I need an earlier file or project version after making a change, I’ll need to set up the right feature. Around 33% of consumers also prioritise access to earlier project versions. |
| Recovery after a failure |
Plan for a separate backup destination, keep it disconnected after the backup has run, and test restoring files. |
If club documents need to remain available after a NAS failure or an attack, I need a copy that’s stored separately and can be restored. Around 27% of consumers focus on this independent recovery option. |
| Access permissions |
Check that you can set up separate accounts and folder permissions, and define who is responsible for administration and backups. |
If different people use different documents, I want to be able to grant access according to each person’s role. Around 20% of consumers pay particular attention to managing permissions. |
| Usable storage |
Assess your current files and expected growth. Check drive compatibility and what’s included, and allow space for a separate backup. |
If you need room for multiple project versions and new club documents, you’ll want to estimate the usable capacity of your planned set-up. Around 20% of consumers prioritise this capacity planning. |
Common planning mistakes
-
Treating RAID mirroring as a complete backup
With mirroring, changes are applied to the mirrored data at the same time. That’s why the BSI does not count RAID mirroring as a data backup.
You can plan for RAID to protect against the failure of a single drive, but you’ll also need a separate backup for recovery.
-
Relying on snapshots on the same NAS as your only protection against failure
A local snapshot can preserve an earlier version, but it remains on the same NAS and isn’t a separate backup destination.
Combine the project versions you need with a backup stored elsewhere, and test that you can restore it.
-
Comparing only the number of bays or raw capacity
The number of drive bays alone doesn’t tell you how much storage will be available for files, project versions and backups once you’ve chosen a configuration. QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without HDDs.
Check what’s included in the specific offer, whether your drives are compatible and how much usable capacity your planned storage layout will provide.
Relevant brands at a glance
Synology
The DS225+ is a two-bay model for central file storage with documented file versioning.
- Synology describes versioning and roles for delegated tasks on the DS225+.
- Synology also recommends using a backup destination in a different location. Check drive compatibility and plan for this separately.
QNAP
The TS-264 is a two-bay model that lets you choose your own drives and set up an external backup.
- QNAP lists two 2.5 GbE ports for the TS-264. According to QNAP, HBS 3 supports local and remote backup destinations.
- QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without HDDs. Don’t assume a particular snapshot configuration based on these details alone.
ASUSTOR
The LOCKERSTOR 2 Gen2 AS6702T is worth considering if snapshots of shared data are important to you.
- ASUSTOR documents Snapshot Center for Btrfs or iSCSI volumes, and two 2.5 GbE ports for the AS6702T.
- Support depends on the volume and set-up. Local snapshots don’t replace a separate backup, and the AS6702T v2 is a different model.
TerraMaster
The F2-424 is a two-bay model with backup applications listed by the manufacturer.
- TerraMaster lists snapshot and other backup applications for the F2-424.
- According to TerraMaster, its snapshot documentation requires Btrfs and TOS 5.0 or later. The feature list doesn’t show how easy the set-up will be for your club.
NAS options at Joybuy
These models are suited to storing club documents centrally and planning storage for project versions.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS
For clubs that want to store documents centrally while allowing room to expand their storage.
Four drive bays; expandable to up to nine bays, according to the product name.
Two 2.5 GbE ports; M.2 NVMe SSD caching.
Joybuy
No image available
Synology DS225+ 2-Bay NAS
For shared files and earlier versions: Synology describes file versioning for the DS225+. You’ll also need to plan for a separate backup destination.
Two drive bays; Intel Celeron J4125 quad-core processor.
2 GB DDR4 RAM, expandable to 6 GB; 2.5 GbE and Gigabit LAN; USB-A 3.0.
RAID 0/1/JBOD; enclosure supplied without drives, so you’ll need to buy compatible HDDs separately.
Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Do I need file versioning or snapshots?
If you want to retrieve a specific earlier file, check for file versioning. Snapshots may be suitable for restoring an earlier state of a shared folder; check the supported file system, schedule and retention settings. Neither replaces a separate backup.
What should I set up after installing the drives?
Start by creating shared folders and assigning suitable user permissions. Then set up the versioning or snapshots you need, along with a backup task to a separate destination, and test that you can restore your files.
What additional equipment will the club need?
Allow for drives that are compatible with your chosen configuration and a separate backup destination. QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without HDDs, so check what’s included in each specific offer.
Does the GDPR apply to club documents stored on a NAS?
If a club processes personal data, it must take data protection requirements into account. The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Rhineland-Palatinate notes that, in its area of responsibility, this applies to charitable and unregistered clubs too. The measures required for specific documents depend on their content and how they’re processed.
Does a club need a data processing agreement for a local NAS?
Operating a NAS locally doesn’t in itself mean that another organisation is processing personal data on the club’s behalf. If the club uses an external service that processes this data on its behalf, the arrangement should be assessed separately. The German Data Protection Conference describes data processors as organisations that process personal data on behalf of others.