Who is a NAS for club backups intended for?

People responsible for data backups

If you look after membership lists, minutes or other hard-to-replace records, you need a clear way to restore them after deletion, malware or device failure. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends disconnecting backup copies from the rest of the network after backing them up.

Committee members handling confidential membership data

A shared storage location can be practical, but not everyone who helps out needs access to all membership or subscription files. The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Rhineland-Palatinate points out that data protection obligations also apply to clubs that process personal data.

Volunteers with changing responsibilities

When responsibilities change within a club, the backup and recovery process should be clearly documented so the next person in charge can understand and continue it. The local backup options available depend on the NAS model and its software.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First, consider how you would restore club files after an incident. Then look at suitable access permissions, a process you can maintain over time and enough usable storage.

This information is intended for consumers in Germany choosing a NAS for club records without cloud storage.

Buying consideration What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Recovery without the cloud Check for a local external backup destination, available versions and the ability to restore the folders you need. If I want to recover club files from a separate copy after accidental deletion or a malware incident, recoverability is my top priority. Around 36% of consumers would make the same choice.
Confidentiality and access permissions Check for individual user accounts and read and write permissions for the folders people actually need. For membership or subscription data, I want to restrict access according to each person’s responsibilities. Around 29% of consumers would make controllable access permissions their top buying priority.
A process that’s easy to hand over Try setting up local backup tasks and checking their status using the computers and file types you have. When volunteer responsibilities change, I need a process the next person can understand and continue. Around 21% of consumers would prioritise a backup process that’s easy to hand over.
Usable storage and features Check your current data and expected growth, drive compatibility, RAID configuration and space for backup versions. If you need to work out which drives and separate backup device will provide the capacity you need, it’s worth paying close attention to the overall specification. Around 14% of consumers would put storage needs and features first.

Which mistakes should clubs avoid?

  • Counting mirrored drives as two independent backups

    With mirroring, changes are copied to both drives. This does not reliably protect you against accidental overwriting or malware.

    Use RAID to help protect against a possible failure of an internal drive, and also set up a separate backup.

    A separate backup device needs to be bought, stored and looked after.

  • Treating a permanently connected USB drive as an offline backup

    A copy remains connected to the NAS or network for as long as the device is plugged in. The Federal Office for Information Security describes disconnecting it after the backup as part of an offline backup.

    Decide who will disconnect and store the device, and practise restoring files.

    The removable device needs to be disconnected after each backup and reconnected for the next one.

  • Assuming an empty enclosure is ready to back up your files

    A NAS enclosure may be supplied without internal drives. The drives you install and your RAID configuration will also affect the usable capacity.

    Check what’s included, drive compatibility and how much storage you need before choosing a model.

    As well as internal drives, you may need an additional device to store your backup separately.

  • Assuming that avoiding the cloud guarantees data protection

    Storing data locally does not automatically control who can access personal club data or what safeguards are needed.

    Set up accounts, permissions and backup devices to suit the data you store. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information describes appropriate technical and organisational measures as the responsibility of those in charge.

Which NAS brands are worth considering?

Synology

The DS223 is a documented option with two drive bays. Synology also describes multi-version backups to a connected USB device for compatible DSM systems.

  • Multiple backup versions can be useful if you need to restore an earlier version of a file.
  • In single-version mode, older backup data is overwritten, and backups are not encrypted. Also check drive compatibility for the specific model.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-233 combines two drive bays with Gigabit LAN and a USB copy button. QNAP documents local external backup destinations through HBS.

  • The documented options include external backup destinations over USB or a network.
  • According to the manufacturer, the TS-233’s 2 GB of RAM cannot be upgraded. Information about this model’s ports and performance headroom does not automatically apply to other QNAP devices.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 AS3302T v2 is a two-bay option with 2.5-Gigabit Ethernet and Btrfs snapshots listed by the manufacturer.

  • Snapshots may be useful if you need to access earlier versions of files.
  • Snapshots are not a separate backup. The AS3302T v2 should not be assumed to be the same as the older AS3302T. Check the features and specification for the full model.

TerraMaster

According to the manufacturer, the F2-424 has two drive bays, two 2.5-Gigabit ports and local backup applications.

  • The ports and applications listed are the manufacturer’s specifications for the F2-424.
  • These specifications do not prove that the model offers the right level of performance for every club. The F2-424 should also not be confused with the F2-425.

UGREEN

UGREEN’s German download centre provides documentation on NAS clients, firmware and multi-user permissions. The NASync DH2300 is another two-bay option.

  • Information about firmware and user permissions can help you choose the right model.
  • Check the firmware and features for the specific model. General information about UGOS does not automatically apply to every NASync device.

NAS models at Joybuy

The Synology NAS models below offer four or eight drive bays and dual 2.5GbE. Check that these features suit your data and network equipment.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS with dual 2.5GbE

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS, dual 2.5GbE, expandable to 9 bays, M.2 NVMe SSD caching, black

A good fit if you’re looking for a NAS with four drive bays to store club records centrally and locally.

Four drive bays; dual 2.5GbE; expandable to 9 bays according to the product name.

According to the product information, Synology drives are intended for the drive bays. Check drive compatibility before choosing.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS with dual 2.5GbE

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS, dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE, up to 360TB, metal, black

A good fit if you need a NAS with eight drive bays to manage club records locally.

Eight drive bays; dual 2.5GbE; optional 10GbE upgrade. The product information states a capacity of up to 360TB.

Compatible drives need to be installed separately in the eight drive bays.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID 1 replace a backup of club records?

No. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that changes to mirrored data are applied to both drives at the same time. RAID can help protect against a single drive failure, but it is no substitute for a separate backup that you can restore.

When does a USB backup count as an offline backup?

When you disconnect the backup device from the NAS or network after the backup is complete. You should also plan a recovery test. A USB drive that stays connected does not meet this disconnection requirement.

Can I back up locally with Synology without setting up cloud storage?

Yes. Synology documents a local USB destination in Hyper Backup for DSM 6.0 and later. Check that your specific device supports it, and decide in advance whether you want multiple versions or a single version. In single-version mode, older backup data is overwritten and backups are not encrypted.

Is a locally operated NAS automatically GDPR-compliant for members’ data?

No. The State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Rhineland-Palatinate makes it clear that the GDPR also applies to clubs that process personal data. The appropriate technical and organisational measures depend on the data you actually process and the associated risks.

What should a club plan for in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Check whether internal drives are included, which drives are compatible with the model and which separate device you’ll use to store backups. Managing account access, organising the backup process and testing recovery are also ongoing responsibilities.