Who is this NAS selection for?

Club archive of irreplaceable recordings

If you don’t want anniversary footage stored in the cloud, plan for a separate local copy and check that you can restore files from it. The BSI recommends disconnecting backups from the rest of the IT network once the backup has been made.

Club with a growing video collection

If you’re archiving original files, edited versions and footage from future events, compare your estimated storage needs with the usable capacity of your planned drive configuration.

Volunteer editing and archiving team

If several people work with the original footage, separate accounts and appropriate access permissions are important. The Baden-Württemberg State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information also includes image and audio recordings in its guidance on data protection for clubs.

What should clubs look for when buying a NAS?

Priority What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Restoring files without the cloud Check for a local backup destination and test restoring a file; the BSI recommends disconnecting backups from the rest of the IT network once the backup has been made. If we don’t want the NAS to hold the only copy of our anniversary footage, we’ll plan for a separate backup drive and a restore test. Around 36 % of consumers put the ability to restore files without the cloud first.
Usable storage and room to grow Calculate your existing file storage and expected growth; with RAID 1 and two drives, usable capacity is equal to that of the smaller drive, as Synology explains in its guide to RAID 1. If original footage and future events will use the same storage, we need to plan around usable capacity rather than the headline raw capacity. Around 29 % of consumers prioritise room to grow and usable capacity.
Access permissions and recordings of people Check for separate accounts and read and write permissions for original files; clarify the purpose and retention period for the specific recordings made by the club. If several volunteers are involved or identifiable people appear in the footage, we want to set clear responsibilities and access rules. Around 21 % of consumers put controlled access and the handling of recordings of people first.
Data transfer and running costs Compare the ports on the NAS, computers and other network equipment; estimate power consumption based on the specific model and planned operating time. If we regularly transfer large files or leave the NAS running for long periods, we’ll consider the entire data transfer route and day-to-day running costs. Around 14 % of consumers prioritise data transfer and running costs.

What mistakes should clubs avoid?

  • Relying on RAID mirroring as your only backup

    RAID 1 keeps the same data on two drives. A separate backup protects against other types of data loss, such as files being deleted or damaged.

    Plan for an external backup drive, disconnect it from the rest of the network after backing up, and test restoring a file.

    Remember to include an additional local backup drive and time for restore tests in your plans.

  • Assuming RAID 1 gives you the full raw capacity

    With RAID 1 and two drives, usable capacity is determined by the smaller drive, so it won’t equal the combined raw capacity.

    Take stock of your existing files, allow for expected growth and compare your needs with the usable capacity of the planned configuration.

  • Assuming a fast NAS port means a fast connection from your workstation

    A 2.5GbE, 5GbE or 10GbE port on the NAS won’t speed up transfers on its own if your other network devices and computers aren’t compatible.

    Check the whole data transfer route before investing in additional network equipment or compatible computer ports.

  • Assuming that avoiding the cloud removes data protection concerns

    Recordings stored locally can still include image and audio data that identifies people. Keeping files off the cloud doesn’t automatically clarify how the recordings may be used or how long they may be kept.

    Set out the purpose, access permissions and retention period for the specific recordings, and check separately before publishing them.

Which NAS brands are worth considering?

The details below relate to the specific models and product lines mentioned, not to every device from each brand.

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay option with 2.5GbE and 1GbE ports for local file storage and backups.

  • Synology documents how to use Hyper Backup with local shared folders and connected USB storage; the feature supports backups with multiple versions.
  • Before buying drives, check their compatibility with the specific model and version of DSM you’re using.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay option with two 2.5GbE ports for networks with compatible equipment.

  • QNAP documents local backups to external storage using Hybrid Backup Sync (HBS).
  • QNAP’s specifications state that the product is supplied without drives. In its review, COMPUTER BILD described the TS-264-8G as fast and noted that the tested model used more power than the comparison model.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are two-bay models with different network ports.

  • TerraMaster lists one 2.5GbE port for the F2-425 and two 5GbE ports for the F2-425 Plus. According to TerraMaster, USB Copy supports local backups to USB storage.
  • The benefits of the faster ports depend on your other network equipment. COMPUTER BILD noted high power consumption for both models it tested.

ASUSTOR

The AS5402T is a two-bay option with two 2.5GbE ports and support for external backups.

  • ASUSTOR’s specifications list four M.2 slots; its help pages explain how to back up from the NAS to external drives.
  • The ports and slots listed don’t, by themselves, prove an independent performance advantage for a club video archive.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay option with 10GbE for clubs planning to use more drive bays.

  • UGREEN lists four drive bays and a 10GbE port.
  • A 10GbE port alone doesn’t tell you what transfer speeds your existing club network can achieve. COMPUTER BILD noted slightly higher power consumption for the model it tested.

Joybuy NAS for club videos

This selection features Synology NAS enclosures with four or eight drive bays and 2.5GbE ports. They’re worth considering for growing archives and file transfers if your other network equipment is compatible.

Synology DiskStation DS925+

Synology DiskStation DS925+

For a growing video archive, this model offers four drive bays and the option to expand to up to nine bays; drives must be purchased separately.

Two 2.5GbE ports are listed. To benefit from these when transferring files, you’ll need compatible network equipment and computer ports.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+

Synology DiskStation DS1825+

With eight drive bays, this model is designed for a large or growing archive; drives must be purchased separately.

The listed raw storage capacity is up to 360 TB. It has two integrated 2.5GbE ports; an optional 10GbE upgrade and any transfer speed benefits depend on having compatible equipment.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions about club archives

Is RAID 1 enough to back up a club archive?

No, RAID 1 is no substitute for a separate backup. It keeps the same data on two drives; an additional copy on a separate device and a tested restore process help protect against other types of data loss. The BSI recommends disconnecting backups from the rest of the IT network once the backup has been made.

How can we back up anniversary footage locally without the cloud?

One option is to back up to an external USB drive, provided the chosen NAS and software support this feature. Synology documents Hyper Backup for this purpose, QNAP has HBS and TerraMaster has USB Copy. Disconnect the backup drive from the rest of the network once the backup is complete, and test restoring your files.

Do we need to switch off the internet connection to use a NAS without cloud storage?

No. Cloud storage and internet access during setup are separate requirements. COMPUTER BILD reported that an internet connection was needed to set up the Synology DS225+ it tested. If you also need to be able to set up the NAS offline, check that this is possible with the specific model before choosing it.

What ongoing costs should clubs budget for, apart from the NAS?

Allow for compatible drives, a separate backup device and the electricity needed for the planned operating time. To work out your own electricity costs, you’ll need the power consumption of the specific model and your electricity tariff.

Can a club store or publish identifiable anniversary footage indefinitely?

Whether specific footage can be stored or published depends on its purpose and the legal basis in each case. The Baden-Württemberg State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information includes image and audio recordings in its guidance on data protection for clubs. The Bavarian State Office for Data Protection Supervision points out that not every publication by a club is covered by a media privilege.