Choose a NAS based on who needs access to which recordings, how files will be copied and where you’ll keep a separate backup. A two-bay device may suit a modest collection, while a growing archive may benefit from the extra capacity of a four-bay model. A fast NAS connection alone won’t guarantee quicker transfers, and RAID is no substitute for a separate backup.
Who is a studio NAS for?
Studios with changing contributors
When several people upload, edit or access files, user accounts and folder permissions should reflect the way you work. You should also consider data protection when recordings feature identifiable people. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains how the GDPR applies to the processing of personal data.
Teams that regularly record concerts
If you often copy large files, check the whole route from the source media through the computer and network to the NAS. Manufacturers’ transfer figures don’t automatically reflect the performance of your studio setup.
Studios with a growing archive
For a growing collection, consider usable capacity, possible drive configurations and a separate backup. Usable capacity can vary depending on the drives and RAID configuration.
What should you consider when choosing one?
Start by sorting out access permissions and your backup process. Then check the full transfer route, and size the NAS according to your current collection and expected growth.
| Consideration |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Access and file control |
Check user accounts and folder permissions; manage originals and working copies according to each person’s role. |
When several contributors upload, edit or share recordings, I want to restrict access according to their tasks and consider data protection too. Around 31% of consumers rank controlled shared access as their top priority. |
| Transfer route and time |
Check the source media connection and import function, as well as the connections between the computer, switch and NAS. |
When importing large concert files regularly, I want to know which part of the transfer route affects the process most. Around 25% of consumers say transfer time is their top concern. |
| Recoverable backup |
Plan for a separate backup destination and test recovery; don’t treat RAID as a backup. |
If recordings need to be available after accidental overwriting or another kind of loss, I’ll plan for a separate backup. Around 25% of consumers put recoverability first; Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security also does not consider RAID mirroring to be data backup. |
| Usable capacity and equipment |
Estimate your current collection and future growth, check drive compatibility and confirm what’s included with the specific model. |
If the archive is set to grow, I want to plan for usable rather than just raw capacity, and know which drives I’ll actually need. Around 19% of consumers put archive capacity first. |
Common mistakes when choosing a NAS
-
Mistaking RAID mirroring for a full backup
Mirroring won’t protect against every cause of data loss. According to guidance from Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security, RAID mirroring does not count as data backup, because changes can be applied to the mirrored data at the same time.
As well as the NAS, plan for a separate backup destination and check regularly that you can restore files from it.
A separate backup destination requires additional storage and a well-maintained recovery process.
-
Budgeting for the NAS enclosure alone
An empty enclosure doesn’t necessarily include hard drives. QNAP explicitly states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs; with the Synology DS225+, usable capacity and drive choice depend on the configuration.
Check what’s included with the specific offer, whether the drives are compatible and what usable capacity you’re planning for. Synology recommends checking its drive compatibility list before you buy.
Depending on your setup, you may need compatible drives or additional network equipment.
-
Assuming port speed equals transfer speed
A fast NAS port alone doesn’t determine how quickly files transfer in your studio. Synology labels the DS225+ performance figures as internal test results and notes that they may vary depending on the environment.
Check the source media, client, switch and NAS connection before choosing a model just because it has a faster port.
NAS brands worth considering
Synology
The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model for sharing files and managing backups in the studio.
- Synology lists integrated 2.5GbE for the DS225+.
- The manufacturer refers buyers to its drive compatibility list. Usable capacity and performance depend on the configuration and operating environment; the performance figures quoted come from internal tests.
QNAP
The TS-264-8G is a two-bay option if multiple network connections or importing via USB on the device are important to you.
- QNAP lists two 2.5 GbE ports, two USB 3.2 Gen 2 ports and a USB copy button for this model.
- QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs. Extra ports are no substitute for compatible drives or checking the entire transfer route.
TerraMaster
The F4-424 Pro offers a four-bay configuration that studios with growing archives may want to consider.
- TerraMaster lists four bays, two 2.5GbE ports and two USB 3.2 Gen 2 ports for the F4-424 Pro.
- These manufacturer specifications aren’t an independent measure of transfer performance in a studio. You’ll also need to plan for a separate backup.
ASUSTOR
The LOCKERSTOR 2 Gen2 and NIMBUSTOR 2 Gen2 are two-bay models you can compare when choosing a specific device.
- ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports for the LOCKERSTOR 2 Gen2.
- This specification doesn’t demonstrate the speed of a particular studio setup or the suitability of other models from the brand. Check the import process and backup features for the model you choose.
Suitable products on Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 enough to back up concert recordings?
No. RAID 1 is no substitute for a separate backup. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security does not consider RAID mirroring to be data backup, because changes can be applied to the mirrored data at the same time. Plan for a separate backup and check that you can restore files from it.
Do you need to buy hard drives separately for an empty NAS enclosure?
It depends on what’s included with the specific model. QNAP explicitly states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs. Before buying drives for the Synology DS225+, check the compatibility list.
Can a shared studio simply copy and share concert recordings?
No, you can’t assume that blanket permission applies. Under §§ 77 and 85 of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), performers and phonogram producers have rights relating to recording and reproduction. The private copying exception under § 53 UrhG is subject to conditions, including that the copying is not for commercial purposes; it is not general permission for a studio workflow. Check the rights for the specific recording, use and distribution before sharing copies.
What should you consider when storing recordings featuring identifiable people on a shared NAS?
If personal data is being processed, you need to consider the GDPR. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains how it applies to the processing of personal data by private companies and other organisations. Clarify responsibilities and access permissions for your specific process; the NAS model alone won’t tell you whether a particular recording contains personal data.