Archivists with irreplaceable recordings
If you can’t simply recreate your original recordings, it’s important to have a restore process that you check regularly. The BSI recommends checking that backups are complete and readable.
A NAS is a good choice if you want to store large project folders in one central place or access them from several computers. For backing up a single computer, an external hard drive may be simpler. In either case, plan a separate backup that you can check: the German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) points out that mirroring drives is no substitute for a backup. If people can be identified in your recordings, you should also plan suitable access permissions and security measures that reflect the risks.
If you can’t simply recreate your original recordings, it’s important to have a restore process that you check regularly. The BSI recommends checking that backups are complete and readable.
Central storage can be a good fit if several computers need access to recording and editing files. Synology describes the DS223j as suitable for sharing and synchronising data in small teams.
If voices could identify people, you should plan permissions and access carefully. The European Data Protection Board points out that audio recordings can contain personal data.
| Priority | What to look for | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Restoring recordings | Check schedules, versions, a separate backup destination and a test restore. | If I want to protect irreplaceable recordings from accidental deletion or changes, I need a restore process I can check; around 33% of consumers would put this priority first. |
| Storing project folders | Estimate your current storage needs and expected growth; compare usable capacity, drive compatibility and what’s included. | Anyone planning for growing recording and editing folders should allow space for existing files and previous versions. Around 27% of consumers would prioritise planning for capacity. |
| Transferring large folders | Include your computer, adapters, switch and NAS in your comparison; figures in the spec sheet aren’t guaranteed project transfer speeds. | If I regularly copy large files, the whole connection matters, not just the NAS port; around 20% of consumers would put transfer speeds first. |
| Protecting confidential recordings | If people can be identified, plan permissions and technical and organisational measures that reflect the risks. | Anyone who needs to store voice recordings confidentially should restrict access to both the main storage and backup copies. Around 20% of consumers would prioritise protecting recordings that could identify people. |
With mirroring, changes are applied to both drives at the same time. That means accidental overwriting or malware can affect both mirrored copies of your data.
Plan an additional, separate backup destination and test whether you can restore files from it.
Keeping another copy separately requires extra storage and regular maintenance.
Usable capacity depends on the drives you install and the configuration you choose. QNAP says the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives.
Allow for your existing project files, expected growth and space for versions. Also check which drives are included and compatible with the model.
Remember to include the cost of any additional compatible drives and storage for separate copies in your plans.
Transfer speeds also depend on your computer, network components and configuration. Manufacturers may measure performance under optimised laboratory conditions.
Check the entire connection and don’t treat figures in the spec sheet as guaranteed speeds for your projects.
Depending on your existing network, you may need to upgrade other components.
The DS223j and DS225+ offer different features for file storage and network connectivity, so the specifications of each model matter.
The TS-264-8G is a two-bay model for buyers comparing features such as network ports and USB connectivity.
The AS5402T is a two-bay model with network and USB ports.
According to UGREEN, the NASync range includes models for home use as well as options for more demanding applications.
These models are designed to provide central NAS storage for growing project folders and backups. Compare your drive requirements with the amount of usable storage you need.
No image available
A central storage option if you’re planning for large project libraries and backups across several devices.
8 drive bays; Dual 2.5GbE; optional 10GbE; up to 360 TB raw storage.
No image available
An option for growing project libraries if you’re planning central file storage and data backups.
4 drive bays; Dual 2.5GbE; expandable to up to 9 drive bays; M.2 NVMe SSD caching.
The user guide lists only Synology drives as compatible. Check your choice of drives before buying.
Try restoring a file from your backup. Also check that all the folders and file types you need have been included and can be read; simply mirroring your drives isn’t a substitute for this test.
It depends on the model and the offer. QNAP specifically states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without an HDD. For the version you’re considering, check what’s included, drive compatibility and the capacity available with your chosen configuration.
What matters is whether a recording relates to an identified or identifiable person. The European Data Protection Board notes that audio recordings containing people’s voices may be personal data. Assess the content and whether people can be identified in the specific recording.