Which NAS is right for you?

Those responsible for family backups

If you want to back up photos and documents from the family computer regularly and restore them if something goes wrong, look for a clear backup process – not just mirrored drives. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security explains why regular data backups matter.

People who transfer files frequently

If you regularly move large files between your computer and NAS, the ports across your entire network setup can make a difference. Synology and QNAP, for example, list 2.5-GbE ports on certain models. Whether this will make a difference for you also depends on your computer and the rest of your network equipment.

Families with growing archives

If you expect to store more photos, videos and backup versions alongside your current files, compare usable capacity and the number of drive bays. Synology describes the DS225+ as a two-bay model, while COMPUTER BILD lists the UGREEN NASync DXP4800 Plus as a four-bay model.

What should you look for when buying?

First, decide how you want to back up the family computer and restore files. Then you can choose the right amount of storage and the right network ports for how you’ll actually use your NAS.

What matters to you What to look for Who should pay particular attention?
Recoverable backups Check the backup process for your operating system, including schedules and versions, as well as a separate backup destination. Plan to test the recovery process. If I want to avoid losing data and be able to retrieve earlier files, having a recovery process I can test is important to me; around 36% of consumers put recovery first.
File transfer speeds Compare the ports on your NAS, computer and the network equipment in between. Manufacturers’ sequential read and write speeds are not a guarantee of the transfer speeds you’ll get. If I regularly transfer large files, I want to avoid my computer or network slowing down the NAS connection; around 29% of consumers prioritise transfer speeds.
Usable storage Allow for your existing files, planned backups and future growth. Calculate the usable storage for your intended drive configuration rather than comparing raw capacity alone. As my photos, videos and backup versions grow, I need enough usable storage, not just the advertised raw capacity; around 21% of consumers prioritise storage growth.
Ongoing running costs Check whether drives are included, which additional drives you’ll need and what power consumption figures the manufacturer gives for its test conditions. Also factor in software maintenance and updates. When weighing up drive requirements, power consumption and maintenance, I care more about ongoing requirements than extra ports; around 14% of consumers prioritise running costs.

Common misconceptions when buying a NAS

  • Confusing mirrored drives with an independent backup

    Mirroring keeps data on multiple drives in the NAS, but it doesn’t give you a separate copy outside the NAS. A problem that affects the device or its data can therefore still put your files at risk.

    Plan your backups, retention and recovery test together. Only then decide how many drives you need and how much capacity to choose.

  • Assuming a fast NAS port guarantees fast copying

    Your computer, the network equipment in between and the specific files and drive configuration all affect the benefits of faster ports. Manufacturers’ figures may be based on optimised laboratory conditions.

    Check your entire network setup and the types of files you typically transfer. Also compare the full model names: TerraMaster F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are different models.

    You may need additional network equipment to make use of a suitable port.

  • Comparing only the enclosure or advertised raw capacity

    An enclosure sold without drives needs compatible drives, and usable capacity also depends on the drives and configuration you choose. According to QNAP, the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs.

    Compare the complete drive configuration and plan for a separate backup. Check drive compatibility for the model you choose, too.

    For a NAS that runs around the clock, remember to factor in power consumption as well as the drives you need.

NAS brands at a glance

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay model with a 2.5-GbE port and documented backup tools.

  • Synology publishes internally measured sequential performance figures for the DS225+; actual results depend on your setup and configuration.
  • Check the drive compatibility list and the requirements for each backup application. According to Synology, Active Backup for Business requires an x64 NAS with Btrfs.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay model with two 2.5-GbE ports and M.2 slots.

  • QNAP lists these ports and slots in its hardware specifications.
  • The model is supplied without HDDs. COMPUTER BILD describes the TS-264-8G as somewhat power-hungry; this assessment applies to this model, not the brand as a whole.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are separate two-bay models with different specifications.

  • TerraMaster lists 4 GB of memory and one 2.5-GbE port for the F2-425; the F2-425 Plus has two 5-GbE ports.
  • COMPUTER BILD highlights the speed of the F2-425, but also notes its high power consumption. Manufacturer specifications for features and speed are not independent measurements.

ASUSTOR

The NIMBUSTOR 2 Gen2 (AS5402T) is a two-bay model with two 2.5-GbE ports and four M.2 slots.

  • These port and slot specifications come from ASUSTOR.
  • ASUSTOR notes that advertised transfer speeds are measured under optimised laboratory conditions and may not reflect what you’ll get with your family computer.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay alternative for those who need the extra space and room to expand.

  • COMPUTER BILD highlights this model’s speed and number of ports.
  • The review also notes that this model uses more power. This assessment applies to the NASync DXP4800 Plus and is not a statement about all UGREEN NAS devices.

Products to suit you on Joybuy

Similar products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID 1 count as a complete family backup?

No. Mirroring can help if one drive fails, but it doesn’t give you a separate copy outside the NAS to protect against other causes of data loss. Plan an additional backup and test restoring your files. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends regular backups stored externally.

Can I use a NAS to back up a Windows PC or Mac?

It depends on the NAS, the software version and the type of backup you want. Synology documents how Active Backup for Business can back up Windows and Mac computers, but it requires, among other things, an x64 NAS with Btrfs. Check the requirements for your specific model and test the recovery process.

What should I bear in mind when installing drives?

First, check drive compatibility for the exact model and back up any existing data somewhere else. The Synology DS225+ manual warns that a drive containing data will be formatted during installation, which deletes its contents.

What ongoing costs and maintenance should I expect after buying the enclosure?

If you buy an enclosure without drives, you’ll need to budget for compatible HDDs and storage for a separate backup. Power consumption depends on the model and the drives installed. You should also keep the NAS software up to date. Your actual running costs will depend, among other things, on your drive configuration, how long you use the NAS and your electricity tariff.

Can I simply make a web interface available online for remote access?

Not without considering security. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security advises against making your router’s web interface accessible from outside your network, highlights the risks of NAS devices with web access and recommends installing available updates. The right remote access solution depends on your specific system.