Who is a NAS suitable for?

Owners of irreplaceable film archives

If you want to recover family footage after a hardware failure, accidental deletion or damage at home, plan a separate backup method alongside your NAS and check that you can restore the files. The BSI stresses that it must be possible to restore backed-up data.

Families with a growing video collection

If you want to access your films from several devices on your home network, compare the storage you need with the usable capacity of the planned drives and configuration. QNAP, for example, says the TS-216G is designed for home users and small offices.

People who want to store files locally

If you want to manage your private recordings without cloud storage, check how the specific model is set up and which online services you actually plan to use before buying. Storing files locally does not automatically answer whether an internet connection is needed for the initial setup.

What should you look for?

First decide which files you need to be able to restore. Then plan your capacity, local access and ongoing backup routine.

NAS with two or more drive bays

A good fit if: you regularly access films from several devices on your home network and want to set up a recurring backup routine.

Bear in mind: plan the enclosure, drives and a separate backup together. Mirroring is not a substitute for an independent backup.

NAS with more than two drive bays

A good fit if: you expect your film archive to grow significantly or plan to add more drives for your preferred storage configuration.

Bear in mind: more bays do not automatically mean more usable storage or an independent backup.

External hard drive without a NAS

A good fit if: you mainly back up one computer, do not need constant access from several devices on your home network and can store the drive separately.

Bear in mind: you will need to make backups manually on a regular basis. Also test that you can actually restore a file.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this especially important to?
Ability to restore files Separate backup destination, schedule, separate storage and a test restore. If my family footage is irreplaceable, I want to have a readable copy even after accidental deletion or damage where it is stored. Around 33 % of consumers put the ability to restore files first.
Usable archive capacity Compare the size of your existing archive and planned growth with the usable capacity of the specific drives and configuration. If I have lots of films or plan to digitise more, I need enough usable space for my archive. Around 27 % of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Local control Check the initial setup and the cloud and remote access services for the specific model. If I do not want my family films stored in the cloud, I want to choose how I access them locally and which services I use. Around 20 % of consumers prioritise local control.
Ease of use and maintenance Compare what is included, the drives you need, an additional backup device, and the effort involved in regular backups and restoring files. If I want a straightforward system without taking on extra work for additional features I rarely use, the overall practicality matters to me. Around 20 % of consumers pay particular attention to ease of use and the effort involved.

Common mistakes when choosing

  • Counting two mirrored hard drives as two independent backups

    Mirroring also copies unwanted changes to files. That is why the BSI does not count it as an independent data backup.

    Set up an additional copy outside the mirrored drives and test that you can restore a film file.

    A separate backup device needs its own storage space and must be kept separately.

  • Confusing the enclosure or raw capacity with ready-to-use storage

    Drives may be sold separately, and usable space also depends on the storage configuration you choose.

    Check what is included and compare the space required for your existing and planned films with the usable capacity of the drives you intend to use.

    Depending on what is included, you may need to buy compatible drives and, where necessary, another backup device.

  • Assuming that cloud-free storage means setup is possible without the internet

    Local storage and the requirements for initial setup are two different things.

    If you also want to set it up without an internet connection, check the process for the specific model before you decide.

Brands to consider

Synology

DiskStation models such as the DS225+ and DS224+ are worth considering for centralised file storage and backups.

  • For the DS225+, Synology says DSM 7.3 offers greater flexibility with third-party drives.
  • Check compatibility for the specific drive: support may be limited for drives that are not on the list.

QNAP

QNAP says the TS-216G is designed for home users and small offices. The TS-264 is a two-bay option with additional ports and features.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5GbE ports and USB ports for backing up to external devices on the TS-264.
  • According to QNAP, hard drives and SSDs are sold separately for the TS-264. A faster network port alone does not guarantee higher transfer speeds on your home network.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are separate variants of two-bay NAS enclosures.

  • Both variants are listed as models for file storage and backups.
  • Check the full model name: details for the F2-425 Plus cannot necessarily be applied to the F2-425.

UGREEN

The NASync range also includes four-bay models, giving you more configuration options for a growing archive.

  • A four-bay model gives you another configuration option for using multiple drives.
  • More bays alone do not confirm the usable capacity or prove that you have an additional independent backup.

ASUSTOR

DRIVESTOR 2 Lite (AS1102TL) is a product line that includes a model to consider when choosing a local NAS.

  • ASUSTOR provides technical specifications and downloads for the model.
  • Before buying, check drive compatibility for the specific model and the configuration you want.

Joybuy products for larger film archives

The following Joybuy products are suited to film archives where multiple drive bays and extra configuration options matter.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS with four drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS with 4 drive bays, Dual 2.5GbE, expandable to up to 9 bays

For a growing film archive where you need multiple drives and extra configuration options.

Four drive bays; according to the product name, expandable to up to nine bays. Dual 2.5GbE and M.2 NVMe SSD caching.

The product description lists only Synology-branded drives as compatible. Check drive compatibility for your planned configuration.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS with eight drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS with 8 drive bays, Dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE

For a larger film archive where you want to include several devices in your backup routine.

Eight drive bays and a stated expansion option. Dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE and advertised capacity of up to 360TB.

The stated capacity is not necessarily the usable storage space. Check the drives and your planned storage configuration.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID 1 replace a backup of my family films?

No. The BSI explicitly distinguishes data mirroring from data backup, because changes made to mirrored data do not protect against accidental overwriting or malware. Keep an independent copy and test that you can restore it.

Does a NAS without cloud storage also need to be set up without an internet connection?

No, these are separate requirements. If you also need to set it up without an internet connection, check the process for the specific model. Needing an internet connection during setup does not automatically mean your film files have to be stored in the cloud.

How can I check that my backup is working?

Set up a recurring backup routine on a separate device and test that you can restore a film file. The BSI highlights both keeping backups separately and making sure they can be restored.

What other purchases should I budget for?

First check whether drives are included, and budget for a separate device for an independent backup. QNAP notes that hard drives and SSDs are sold separately for the TS-264; for other offers, check what is included with each one.

Does the GDPR apply to family films stored for private use?

For processing carried out solely for personal or family activities, Baden-Württemberg’s data protection authority describes a household exemption. It distinguishes this from making content publicly available to an unrestricted audience. Whether a specific disclosure still counts as private depends on the circumstances; storing files locally alone does not answer whether sharing them later would be considered publication.