Which approach is right for you?

Protecting irreplaceable original films

If you want to recover digitised source files after they’ve been lost or damaged, plan for a separate backup and check that you can restore files from it. The Federal Office for Information Security stresses that you also need to be able to restore your data.

Working with multiple edits

If you regularly make changes to your projects, look for a way to select earlier file versions when you need them. Synology and QNAP describe features for versioned backups; check the available settings and requirements for the specific model and software you use.

Building a growing video archive

If you’re continually adding raw files and finished edits, work out your usable storage based on your drives and chosen RAID configuration. If you often transfer large files, you should also consider the NAS connections and the rest of your network setup.

What should you look for when buying?

First, decide which files and earlier versions you want to be able to restore. Then you can assess the storage and network setup you need for the way you use your NAS.

Buying priority What to look for Who is it important to?
Restoring original films Plan for a separate backup destination and test restoring a sample file. If the originals can’t be digitised again, I want to be able to recover them even if the NAS fails. Around 36 % of consumers put restoring original films first.
Recovering earlier project versions Check versioning or supported snapshots, retention settings and whether individual files can be restored. If I overwrite or delete an edit, I want to be able to return to an earlier version. Around 29 % of consumers prioritise finding older project versions.
Planning usable storage Compare current and expected file sizes with usable capacity after taking the drive and RAID configuration into account. As my film archive continues to grow, I need enough usable space for originals and edits. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise capacity for a growing archive.
Transferring large files Check the connections on your NAS and computer, as well as your switch and cabling, as part of the whole transfer route. If I often transfer large video projects, I want to identify any avoidable bottlenecks in my network setup. Around 14 % of consumers put transfer speed first.

Common planning mistakes

  • Relying on mirrored drives as your only backup

    Mirroring drives within a NAS doesn’t give you a separate copy. If the whole device is damaged, it can’t replace a backup of your originals.

    Plan for a separate backup destination and test whether you can restore a file from it.

    You’ll need to set up an additional backup drive or another storage location and check it regularly.

  • Confusing raw capacity with usable storage

    The amount of space actually available depends on the drives you use and your RAID configuration. Raw files, project versions and backups all take up storage too.

    Plan according to your file sizes and check drive compatibility for the specific model.

    Depending on how much space you need, you may require larger or additional compatible drives.

  • Assuming the NAS connection determines transfer speed

    A faster connection on the NAS alone won’t determine how quickly files transfer. Your computer, switch, cabling and configuration all play a part too.

    Compare the supported connections across your entire network setup and consider how often you transfer large projects.

    You may need a suitable network adapter or switch if your existing equipment doesn’t support the connection you’ve chosen.

Brands and model ranges to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS225+ is a two-bay option for centralised file storage. Synology describes Hyper Backup as a way to save versioned backups to destinations including a USB drive or another NAS.

  • According to Synology, the DS225+ has built-in 2.5-GbE.
  • Usable storage depends on your drives and RAID configuration; check drive compatibility for the specific model.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the TS-264-8G combines two drive bays with two 2.5-GbE ports. Hybrid Backup Sync supports backups to external and remote destinations.

  • QNAP documents versioning rules in HBS; intelligent versioning requires HBS 3 version 24.0 or later.
  • The TS-264-8G is supplied without an HDD, so remember to include drives when putting your setup together.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 is a two-bay option for storing family media in one place. TerraMaster lists 2.5-GbE and TFSS snapshots for this model.

  • The network and snapshot features mentioned are stated by the manufacturer.
  • Check the features for the specific model variant: the F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are different models.

ASUSTOR

The LOCKERSTOR Gen2 range is another option if you want to compare Btrfs snapshots and network connections across specific models.

  • ASUSTOR lists Snapshot Center for selected model ranges.
  • The model, configured file system and separate backup destination all need to fit your recovery plan.

Joybuy products

Similar products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my digitised family films?

No. RAID 1 isn’t a separate backup from your NAS. Set up another destination and check that you can restore files from it; the Federal Office for Information Security recommends taking data restoration into account.

How can I check whether I can restore earlier project versions?

Set up the versioning you need in the specific backup job and test restoring a sample file. For QNAP, the documented intelligent HBS versioning requires HBS 3 version 24.0 or later.

How should I plan storage for originals and multiple project versions?

Check the size of your existing files and think about which versions you want to keep. Compare your plan with the usable capacity of your chosen drives and RAID configuration, rather than just adding up their raw capacity.

Do all NAS devices come with hard drives?

No, it depends on the specific model and offer. QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without an HDD, so check which drives are included before buying and decide which separate destination to use for backups.

Does a 2.5-GbE connection always make a difference with large video files?

Not automatically: your computer and the rest of your network setup need to support it too. Check your NAS, computer, switch and cabling together, and consider how often you transfer large projects.