Families with irreplaceable photo archives
If you want to recover photos after losing a device, making a mistake or suffering damage at the NAS’s location, plan for a separate backup as well as the NAS.
For family photos with several edited versions, a NAS is only suitable if you set up versioning or appropriate snapshots and test the restore process. You’ll also need a separate copy in case the NAS is lost: Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security does not consider RAID mirroring to be a backup, while Synology describes Hyper Backup as a way to keep multiple backup versions on compatible systems.
If you want to recover photos after losing a device, making a mistake or suffering damage at the NAS’s location, plan for a separate backup as well as the NAS.
If you make multiple changes to albums or image files, check whether you can restore specific older versions.
If family members take photos on different devices, look for a straightforward import process and check that all the files you expect have transferred successfully.
| Buying consideration | What to check | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Restorability | Check for a separate backup destination, a backup plan and a test restore. | If I want to recover family photos after the NAS fails or its location is damaged, I need an additional copy. Around 36% of consumers rank restorability as their most important buying consideration. |
| Project versions | Check for versioned backups or model-dependent snapshots, retention settings and the ability to restore individual files. | If I accidentally overwrite an image project, I want to be able to choose an older version. Around 29% of consumers put multiple project versions first. |
| Photo imports | Check which devices are supported, how user spaces work and whether you can import selected albums. | If family photos are on several phones, I want to bring them together in one place and check the import. Around 21% of consumers prioritise importing photos from different devices. |
| Capacity and total cost | Allow for the size of your archive, expected growth, drive compatibility and space for versions and additional copies. | As my photo archive grows, I want to plan for usable storage, saved versions and a separate backup. Around 14% of consumers rank capacity and total cost as their most important buying consideration. |
With mirroring, changes are copied to both drives. This doesn’t automatically preserve an older version of a project.
Plan for versioning and a separate copy, and test that you can restore files from it.
Remember to include an additional backup medium or an external destination in your plans.
An organised photo library doesn’t prove that earlier versions of edited projects are being saved.
Check which feature creates versions for the specific NAS and folder you want to use, and how to restore a single older file.
Usable capacity depends on the drives and the storage configuration you choose. Synology highlights this for the DS225+.
Before buying, consider the size of your archive, expected growth, compatible drives, and the space needed for versions and an additional copy.
Drives and a separate backup destination are additional parts of the plan, on top of the NAS enclosure.
The DS225+ is one NAS enclosure we looked at. Synology describes Hyper Backup as a feature for keeping multiple backup versions across different destinations.
QNAP describes the TS-233 as a model for central photo storage and lists snapshots as a protection feature.
ASUSTOR lists Btrfs snapshots for the DRIVESTOR 2 Pro Gen2 (AS3302T v2).
UGREEN describes mobile photo imports and library organisation in its NAS Photos app.
The Joybuy products below are Synology NAS enclosures for managing photos and backing up data in one place. Before buying, check that the drive requirements and capacity suit your archive. Make sure you set up versioning and a separate backup destination to suit your needs.
No image available
May be suitable as a central home for your family photo archive. You’ll also need a suitable separate backup plan to manage multiple project versions and protect against losing the NAS.
Four drive bays; expandable to up to nine bays; dual 2.5GbE ports. The product description specifies Synology drives as a requirement; check which drives are suitable for this specific model.
No image available
May be suitable as a central home for your family photo archive. Set up versioning and an additional copy on a separate destination to meet your restore requirements.
Eight drive bays; dual 2.5GbE ports; optional 10GbE upgrade; stated capacity of up to 360 TB.
No. Mirroring alone isn’t a backup. Changes are copied to both drives, so make sure you have a separate copy and test that you can restore files from it. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security does not consider RAID mirroring to be a backup.
Set up a versioning feature or supported snapshots on your specific NAS, with suitable retention settings. Then check that you can restore a specific older file. Snapshots on the same device aren’t a substitute for a separate copy.
Import a few photos and project files, run a versioned backup and then test restoring an older file. Also check that all the files you expect have transferred from your phone, in the versions you need.
Allow for compatible drives and another medium or service for a separate backup. Also consider the size of your archive, expected growth and the additional space needed for saved versions.
There’s no one answer for every situation. If people can be recognised in the photos, they may contain personal data; storing and publishing them are different types of data processing. Check the specific requirements if you’re sharing photos publicly or publishing them. The Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority explains the right to one’s own image.