Who is a NAS suitable for?

Families with photos on multiple devices

If you want to bring photos from phones and computers together in one place, check the import method for each device and test whether you can restore photos later. Synology’s product information describes photo management and PC folder backups for the DS223j. The right set-up still depends on your devices and folders.

People with irreplaceable photo archives

If you want to recover older photos after accidental deletion or device failure, you’ll need an additional copy and should test that you can restore it. The BSI recommends checking from time to time that a backup contains your data and that it can be read.

People with limited desk space

If your NAS will sit near your workspace, compare the dimensions of its enclosure and allow extra room for plugs, cables and airflow. Manufacturers’ noise figures are based on the specified test conditions, so they’re not a reliable indication of how loud the device will be on your desk with your drives installed.

What to look for when buying

Consideration What to check before buying Who should consider this?
Restoring files and keeping a separate backup Check for a separate backup destination, a backup plan and a restore test. If I want to recover photos after accidental deletion or device failure, I need a separate copy that I can actually restore. Around 37% of consumers put recoverability first.
Importing photos from multiple devices Check support for the phones and computers you actually use, as well as the folders you want to back up. If photos from several family devices are to be brought together in one place, reliable importing with as little ongoing manual work as possible matters. Around 27% of consumers prioritise photo importing.
Desk space Allow for the enclosure dimensions, port locations, and extra room for cables and airflow. If my workspace has little free space, the enclosure and its connections need to fit in practice. Around 18% of consumers put space requirements first.
Usable capacity and ongoing costs Check your photo library and expected growth, storage mode, drive compatibility and what’s included. If I want to store my photo collection long term, I need to plan for usable storage and any additional drives. Around 18% of consumers prioritise capacity and cost planning.

With mirroring, usable capacity is lower than the combined raw capacity of the drives. The BSI also points out that disk mirroring doesn’t replace a data backup, as unwanted changes can be copied across too.

Common buying and planning mistakes

  • Assuming two mirrored drives provide a complete photo backup

    With mirroring, accidental deletion and other unwanted changes can be copied to both drives too. The BSI explicitly distinguishes disk mirroring from data backup.

    As well as RAID, if you use it, plan for a separate copy and test that you can restore a photo file from it.

    You’ll also need to set up and maintain an additional backup medium or another separate backup destination.

  • Checking only the enclosure width against the available space

    The enclosure’s depth, rear ports, cables and airflow also need room. What’s more, manufacturers’ noise figures are based on specific test conditions and may not reflect the noise level at your own workspace.

    Measure the available space and check that the NAS, cables and connections will all fit in the intended spot.

  • Counting the capacity of both drives as usable storage when mirroring

    With mirroring, some drive capacity is used for the redundant copy, so it isn’t available for additional, independent photo files.

    Plan according to your chosen storage mode, your current photo library and how much you expect it to grow.

    If you underestimate the capacity you need, you may have to replace a drive later.

Key brands at a glance

Synology

According to Synology’s product information, the DiskStation DS223j combines two drive bays with Synology Photos and features for scheduled or ongoing PC folder backups.

  • The photo and backup features described may be useful for a properly configured family photo backup.
  • The DS223j manual doesn’t list hard drives as included. You’ll need to plan for drives and a separate backup as well.

QNAP

According to QNAP’s German hardware specifications, the TS-233 is a two-bay model with Gigabit Ethernet and a USB copy button.

  • QNAP lists enclosure dimensions of 186 × 91,7 × 157,6 mm.
  • You’ll need to allow extra room for plugs and cables. The copy button alone doesn’t confirm that your chosen import process will create a complete backup.

ASUSTOR

According to ASUSTOR, the Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model with Gigabit Ethernet and RAID 1 support.

  • ASUSTOR lists dimensions of 165 × 102 × 218 mm and a noise level of 18,6 dB with the hard drives idle.
  • This is a manufacturer’s figure under specific conditions, not an independent comparison of noise levels in a workspace. According to the specifications, the only supported internal drives are 3.5-inch SATA HDDs.

TerraMaster

TerraMaster describes the F2-212 as a two-bay model for local photo storage and importing photos from mobile devices.

  • TerraMaster lists 19 dB(A) with two SATA drives in standby, measured from a distance of one metre with background noise of 17,3 dB(A).
  • This figure doesn’t prove that the device is quieter than others when backing up photos.

UGREEN

According to UGREEN, the NASync DXP2800 range may be suitable for photo backups when used with additional applications or suitable network equipment.

  • UGREEN’s German website lists features of the DXP2800 including 2,5GbE, 8 GB RAM and HDMI.
  • These features don’t provide additional backup protection. The DXP2800 and DXP2800 GT are different model names and shouldn’t be treated as the same product.

Joybuy products

Related products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my family photos?

No, RAID 1 doesn’t replace a separate data backup. The German Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes disk mirroring from backup, as unwanted changes can be mirrored too. Plan an additional copy and test that you can restore a file from it.

What should I check before setting up a NAS on my desk?

Measure the available space, including room for cables and airflow. Then check photo importing for every phone and computer you use, and test it with a new file.

Are hard drives included with the NAS enclosure, and what ongoing costs should I expect?

The Synology DS223j manual doesn’t list hard drives as included. Check the specific offer to see which drives are included and whether they’re compatible with the model. You should also factor in an additional backup medium and the power requirements of your planned set-up.

Does the GDPR apply to a family photo archive managed solely for private use?

According to the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection, the GDPR doesn’t apply when individuals process personal data solely for personal or family activities. This exemption can end, for example, if photos of other people are published online. Storing photos privately on a NAS and sharing them later aren’t therefore the same thing.

What legal requirements apply to an electrical NAS sold in Germany?

In a notice dated 6 February 2025, the German Federal Network Agency stated that devices with shortcomings such as a missing mandatory CE mark or missing information about the responsible economic operator in the EU must not be offered for sale in Germany. This statement about market requirements doesn’t confirm that a specific offer complies with them.