Who is a NAS suitable for?

People with irreplaceable photo files

If you want to back up photos from a shared computer and restore them if something goes wrong, look for a clear backup and recovery process. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security recommends planning for recovery.

Teams that need different levels of access to photos

If several people use the same workstation, check the user accounts and folder permissions. Shared access shouldn’t automatically mean that everyone can edit the same images. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security describes assigning access rights on a need-to-know basis.

People working on large photo projects

If you often move large photo files, check whether your NAS, workstation and network can all use a 2.5GbE connection. Manufacturers’ transfer-rate figures may be based on optimised test conditions and aren’t a guarantee of the speeds you’ll get at your own workstation.

What to look for when buying

First, decide how you’ll back up and restore your photos, then set up shared access. Consider a faster network connection only in the context of the entire connection path.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Photo backups you can restore Automatic backups of the right PC folders, versioning and a tested recovery process. If I want to recover important photos after accidental deletion or a device problem, I need more than a storage location I can access. Around 36% of consumers put recovery first.
Controlled shared access Individual user accounts, folder permissions and how to share a photo library. If several people use photos on the same workstation, I want to be able to decide who can view or edit each folder. Around 29% of consumers prioritise separate access rights.
Speed when working with large files The ports on the NAS and workstation, as well as the rest of the network connection. Don’t treat manufacturers’ test figures as a guarantee of real-world performance. If I often move large photo collections, I don’t want the network connection to slow down my workflow unnecessarily. Around 21% of consumers prioritise fast photo transfers.
Total cost and usable storage Suitable drives, usable capacity rather than raw capacity, and an additional medium for a separate copy. If I’m planning the NAS, storage and an independent copy together, I want to know how much capacity will actually be available in my configuration. Around 14% of consumers base their decision mainly on total cost and usable storage.

Common misconceptions

  • Assuming mirrored drives provide a complete photo backup

    Drive redundancy doesn’t replace a separate, recoverable copy. Accidental deletion or an attack can also affect data on a NAS that’s accessible to others.

    Plan a second copy on a separate medium and test that you can restore individual files.

    You’ll need an additional backup medium for the separate copy, along with a backup routine that you keep up to date.

  • Assuming 2.5GbE guarantees a faster workstation

    A faster NAS connection won’t automatically speed up transfers if your workstation or the rest of the network path is slower. Performance figures published for the ASUSTOR model were measured under optimised laboratory conditions and may differ in practice.

    Check the ports and connections along the entire path before applying manufacturers’ figures to your own workstation.

    Depending on your existing equipment, you may need to upgrade the rest of your network.

  • Assuming raw capacity or two drive bays mean instant usable photo storage

    Usable capacity depends on the drives and the configuration you choose. The number of bays alone won’t tell you how much space you’ll have for photos.

    Compare the usable storage you need and check which drives are compatible with the specific NAS before you buy.

    As well as the NAS drives, you may need another medium for an independent backup.

Key brands at a glance

Synology

The DS223j and DS225+ models focus on shared photo storage and backup features. This applies to these model ranges, not necessarily to every NAS from the brand.

  • Synology lists a shared photo space and PC folder backup for the DS223j. Photo management and 2.5GbE are listed for the DS225+.
  • Synology recommends checking drive compatibility for the DS225+ before buying. The manufacturer’s transfer-rate figures are based on internal tests.

QNAP

QNAP describes the TS-233 as a two-bay model for central photo storage, sharing and synchronisation.

  • QNAP lists user account protection, snapshots and a Gigabit Ethernet port.
  • According to QNAP, it has 2 GB of memory, which can’t be upgraded. Claims about protection and suitability come from the manufacturer and aren’t based on an independent performance assessment.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 AS3302T v2 is an option to consider if you want a 2.5GbE connection for working on photos together.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5GbE, 2 GB DDR4 and Btrfs and iSCSI snapshots for this model.
  • According to ASUSTOR, the published RAID-1 speeds were achieved under optimised laboratory conditions and may differ at your own workstation.

Joybuy products

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does a NAS with two mirrored drives replace an additional backup?

No. Drive redundancy isn’t an independent backup against every type of deletion or attack. Plan a separate copy of important photos and check that you can restore it.

How should I set up backups on a shared workstation?

Identify which photo folders contain the originals, set up regular backups of them to the NAS, and test restoring individual files. Set access rights for shared folders separately from the backup process.

What should I consider when planning storage and additional backup requirements?

Check which drives are compatible with the specific NAS, how much capacity will be usable with your planned configuration, and which additional medium will hold the independent copy. Also set aside time for your backup routine and regular recovery tests.

Are there data protection obligations for photos in a shared workspace in Germany?

This depends on why and in what context the photos are processed. Germany’s Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information explains the exception for processing carried out solely for personal or family activities; the European Commission explains the scope of the GDPR in relation to personal data. If the photos are processed for work, you should take the relevant data protection obligations into account. The specific requirements depend on how the photos are used.