Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Researchers with multiple project versions

If you edit family trees or transcriptions, you may want to retrieve an earlier version. Synology says version control is available in Drive, but must be enabled for team folders; QNAP lists snapshot protection for the TS-233.

Keepers of a hard-to-replace family archive

For scanned certificates and sources that would be difficult to obtain or digitise again, you need a separate, restorable backup. The BSI recommends checking that backups are readable and can be restored.

Families sharing an archive

If several people need to view sources but only some should be able to edit project files, separate accounts and suitable folder permissions are important. UGREEN describes read and write permissions for shared folders.

What to look for when buying

First, check how you can restore earlier files. Then plan for a separate backup and the access permissions your family needs.

What you need What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Earlier project versions Set up version control or snapshots for the folders you actually use, then test restoring an older file. Synology Drive requires version control to be enabled for the relevant team folder. If I regularly edit family tree files, I want to be able to retrieve an earlier version. Around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to find previous project versions.
Restoring files after data loss Choose a separate backup destination and test whether you can restore the files you need from it. The BSI does not consider RAID mirroring to be a backup. I want to keep a copy of rare scans and sources in case the NAS fails or files are deleted. Around 27% of consumers prioritise a separate, restorable backup.
Shared family access Set up accounts and read or write permissions for the required folders, then check them using a second account. UGREEN describes different permissions for shared folders. If relatives need to view sources but should not be able to edit every project file, I need separate access permissions. Around 20% of consumers prioritise controlled family access.
Usable storage and included equipment Check drive compatibility and the usable capacity of your chosen setup; raw capacity and usable storage may differ. Hard drives are not included with the UGREEN NASync DXP2800. If I want to store scans, project versions and a backup, the equipment needs to suit the size of my archive. Around 20% of consumers prioritise a predictable setup with suitable capacity.

Common misconceptions

  • Treating RAID 1 or local snapshots as a complete backup

    Mirroring also copies unwanted changes, while local snapshots stay on the affected device. The BSI explicitly distinguishes drive mirroring from a backup.

    Plan to keep a separate copy, and test restoring a project file along with the version you need.

    Allow for an additional backup drive and time to test file restoration.

  • Confusing synchronisation with independent archiving

    With two-way synchronisation, changes and deletions can appear in both locations. UGREEN points out that synchronisation is not a substitute for an independent backup.

    Decide which folders to synchronise and which to back up independently, and check how long versions are kept.

  • Assuming raw capacity or an empty enclosure is a complete archive

    Usable capacity depends on the drives installed and the RAID configuration. Hard drives are not included with the UGREEN NASync DXP2800.

    Before choosing a NAS, check drive compatibility for that specific model and calculate the usable space for your setup.

    With the UGREEN NASync DXP2800, you’ll need to budget for compatible drives separately; an independent backup also needs its own storage device.

NAS brands to consider

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay NAS. Synology Drive can keep a version history for individual files, provided you set it up correctly.

  • Synology explains how to restore earlier versions of files in Drive.
  • According to Synology, a package-only backup does not include Drive file versions. Check drive compatibility with the DS225+ before buying.

QNAP

QNAP describes the TS-233 as a two-bay model for home users, with file sharing and snapshot functionality.

  • QNAP lists snapshot protection for the TS-233.
  • According to QNAP, the model has 2 GB of non-expandable memory and a Gigabit Ethernet port. Snapshots are not a substitute for a separate backup.

UGREEN

The UGREEN NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay, diskless enclosure with 2.5GbE. UGREEN describes synchronisation and version-retention options in its NAS software.

  • UGREEN documents separate family accounts and different folder permissions.
  • UGREEN explicitly distinguishes synchronisation from an independent backup. Check the software version and retention settings for the version history you need.

Suitable products on Joybuy

NAS options to consider: Synology DiskStation DS225+; QNAP TS-233; UGREEN NASync DXP2800 (diskless enclosure).

Frequently asked questions

How do I restore an earlier version of my family tree file?

In Synology Drive, enable version control for the relevant team folder, then choose an earlier version from the version history to restore it or save it as a separate copy. On other systems, you’ll need to set up and test the relevant snapshot or version history process.

Are two mirrored hard drives enough for a backup?

No. The BSI points out that changes are also applied to mirrored data. Keep a separate backup and check that you can restore the files you need from it.

What should I set up for several family members?

Create separate accounts and only grant write access to folders where changes are needed. UGREEN describes personal folders and shared folders with different read and write permissions.

What additional purchases should I check before buying?

Check whether drives are included with the enclosure, which hard drives are compatible and what separate device you’ll use for your backup. Synology notes that the usable capacity of the DS225+ varies depending on the drives and RAID configuration; hard drives are not included with the UGREEN NASync DXP2800.

Does the GDPR apply to a private family archive in Germany?

The GDPR excludes processing by individuals as part of purely personal or household activities. The European Commission classifies information about identifiable living people as personal data. If you use the archive beyond a personal or household context, the specific circumstances must be assessed separately.