Who should consider this purchase?

Archive managers with lots of recordings

If you need to store numerous or large video files until handover, work out the archive’s size and the usable storage in your NAS configuration before buying a drive.

Project teams that need to restore files

If losing files before sign-off is not an option, plan a separate backup alongside your NAS and check that you can restore the files you need from it.

Teams handing over confidential material

If recordings could identify individuals, access permissions and suitable protection for the material should be part of your handover planning.

What should you look for when choosing?

For a lecture archive, drive capacity is just one consideration. You also need a backup you can restore, protection for the material and support from your existing NAS.

Consideration What to look for when buying Who should pay particular attention?
Usable archive storage Compare the archive’s size and planned additions with the usable storage in your NAS configuration; allow for formatting and differences in units of measurement. If I want to store the recordings and planned additions on the NAS, I check the usable space rather than just the stated capacity; around 36% of consumers put sufficient archive storage first.
Ability to restore files Keep a separate copy and test restoring it; don’t treat RAID mirroring as a backup, as the BSI explains. If I can’t afford to lose recordings before sign-off, I plan a separate copy and test that I can restore it; around 29% of consumers prioritise the ability to restore files.
Confidentiality at handover Clarify who is authorised to access the files and how they will be handed over; for content containing personal data, check the legal basis and appropriate safeguards for the level of risk, as explained by Germany’s Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI). If people can be recognised in the image or heard in the audio, I want to clarify access permissions and the basis for sharing the files before handover; around 21% of consumers put confidentiality first.
Integration with your NAS Check full model compatibility, form factor and interface; some management features may be tied to a specific NAS system. If I want to keep using an existing NAS, I check the model, form factor and interface rather than assuming that a NAS label guarantees compatibility; around 14% of consumers prioritise the right fit.

Avoid common misconceptions

  • Relying on RAID as a complete backup

    Mirroring can help if a single drive fails, but it won’t reliably protect you from accidental overwriting or malware. The BSI does not consider RAID mirroring a data backup, because changes can be applied to the mirrored data at the same time.

    Keep a separate copy before handover and test that you can restore important files from it.

  • Assuming stated capacity is the same as available archive space

    The drive’s stated capacity does not automatically tell you how much space will be available for files after formatting and in your planned NAS configuration.

    First work out the size of your archive, then compare it with the storage you can actually use.

  • Expecting a NAS hard drive to provide a complete handover solution

    An internal hard drive doesn’t provide network access on its own. For recordings containing personal data, you also need appropriate measures to protect against unauthorised access; the BfDI explains these obligations for controllers and processors.

    Check that the full drive model is compatible with your NAS, and clarify the handover process and access permissions.

Key NAS hard drive brands at a glance

Western Digital

Western Digital describes WD Red Plus as a drive range for NAS devices in small to medium-sized environments. The WD40EFPX is a specific 4-TB variant.

  • Western Digital lists the WD40EFPX at 5,400 rpm and for use in RAID-optimised NAS devices with up to eight bays.
  • These manufacturer specifications don’t confirm compatibility with every NAS; check the specific model.

Seagate

Seagate’s IronWolf range comprises NAS hard drives for systems with multiple bays. The ST4000VN006 is listed in a Seagate guide from 2022.

  • Seagate describes the IronWolf range as using CMR recording and being designed for NAS use.
  • Check the full model number and the specifications of the specific variant on offer.

Toshiba

Toshiba positions its N300 range for NAS devices and multimedia servers. The current EMEA product overview includes the 4-TB variant HDWG740EZSTC, among others.

  • Toshiba lists the N300 range at 7,200 rpm.
  • Without comparable testing in the NAS you plan to use, this alone isn’t enough to claim a general advantage for archiving.

Synology

The Plus series is relevant if you’re buying a compatible Synology NAS; the HAT3300-4T is a documented 4-TB variant.

  • Synology specifies CMR recording and firmware updates directly through DSM.
  • Management integration requires a suitable Synology system; a stated drive data rate is not a guaranteed network speed.

Joybuy products for Synology NAS

The following Joybuy picks are internal hard drives for Synology NAS devices. Before buying, check that the specific drive model is compatible with your NAS and offers the archive capacity you need.

Synology HAT3310-12T, 12 TB NAS hard drive

Synology HAT3310-12T, 12 TB NAS hard drive

Worth considering if the planned archive fits the stated capacity and your Synology NAS supports this model.

12 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA III; CMR; 7,200 rpm; 512 MB cache; helium.

Joybuy
Synology HAT3310-16T, 16 TB NAS hard drive

Synology HAT3310-16T, 16 TB NAS hard drive

An option if the planned archive fits the stated capacity and your Synology NAS supports this specific model.

16 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR; 7,200 rpm.

Joybuy
Synology HAT3300-6T, 6 TB NAS hard drive

Synology HAT3300-6T, 6 TB NAS hard drive

Worth considering if 6 TB of stated capacity is right for your archive and your Synology NAS supports the drive.

6 TB; 3.5 inches; SATA 6 Gb/s; CMR; 5,400 rpm.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Are two mirrored NAS hard drives enough of a backup before handing files over to a client?

No. The BSI does not consider RAID mirroring a data backup, because changes or malware damage can affect both mirrored copies. Keep a separate copy and check that you can restore the files you need from it.

Can I use a NAS hard drive on its own as network storage, without any other equipment?

No, an internal NAS hard drive is not itself a network device. Before installing it, check the form factor, interface and whether your NAS supports the full drive model; depending on the offer, you may need to buy the enclosure separately.

Which warranty details should I check before buying?

Check the terms for the specific variant. Western Digital lists a three-year limited manufacturer’s warranty for the WD40EFPX; Synology also lists three years for the HAT3300-4T. A warranty is no substitute for a data backup.

Can I hand over recordings featuring identifiable people to the client without checking anything else?

You can’t assume that this is automatically permitted. Processing personal data requires an appropriate legal basis; controllers and processors must put suitable technical and organisational safeguards in place. The legal basis for a specific disclosure and the measures required depend, among other things, on the content and the roles of everyone involved, as the BfDI explains.