Who this buying guide is for

Growing video libraries

If your video files and project folders are growing, plan for the usable storage of your entire NAS setup – not just the capacity stated on the drive.

Project backups you can restore

If you want to recover earlier, readable versions of your projects, plan for a separate backup in addition to your NAS. The BSI notes that RAID mirroring copies changes at the same time, so it doesn’t replace a standalone backup.

Teams that regularly transfer large files

If you back up frequently or have several people accessing the system, the workload rating of the specific drive and its suitability for your NAS are important points to compare. Manufacturer specifications describe the drive range, not the performance of your entire system.

What to look for when buying

First, plan the usable storage you need and check compatibility with your NAS. Then choose a drive class that suits the expected workload. A separate backup is an additional consideration, alongside your choice of internal HDD.

Priority What to check before buying Who values it
Usable storage and room to grow Calculate your existing data, planned growth, backup versions and the usable capacity of your NAS setup separately; check the TB capacity for the exact model number. As my video library grows, I need room for complete project folders and earlier versions. Around 36% of consumers put usable capacity and room to grow first.
Recoverability Check where versioned backups are saved and whether you can test restoring a complete project folder. If a project is accidentally overwritten, I want to be able to recover an earlier version. Around 29% of consumers prioritise recoverability over extra capacity or a higher drive rating.
Continuous workloads and large file transfers Compare your expected annual read and write volumes with the workload rating for the exact model; take simultaneous access into account. For frequent large transfers or several people accessing the system, the drive’s intended continuous workload is crucial. Around 21% of consumers put this need first.
NAS compatibility and total cost Match the exact NAS and HDD model numbers to the intended drive bay; factor in additional backup destinations and warranty terms. If I’m using an existing or planned NAS, the specific drive needs to fit and work with my backup plan. Around 14% of consumers prioritise compatibility and the total cost of the solution.

Common buying mistakes

  • Assuming RAID mirroring is a complete backup

    Mirroring copies changes at the same time. That doesn’t necessarily let you recover deleted or damaged files from an earlier version.

    Plan for a separate backup destination and test whether you can restore a project folder from it.

    Depending on your plan, you may need more drives or an additional backup destination.

  • Choosing a Pro HDD solely for its higher workload rating

    The workload rating describes how the drive is designed to be used; it doesn’t guarantee a particular backup speed or the lifespan of an individual drive.

    Estimate your annual read and write workload, then compare standard and Pro models alongside the rest of your NAS setup.

NAS hard drive brands to consider

Western Digital

WD Red Plus is a range of NAS HDDs for small to medium-sized setups. Western Digital says WD Red Pro is designed for more intensive multi-user use.

  • The WD Red Plus datasheet specifies CMR, support for up to eight bays, a workload rating of 180 TB/year and a three-year limited warranty.
  • These specifications don’t replace checking the exact model number against your NAS. A workload rating isn’t an independent long-term test.

Seagate

IronWolf is a range of NAS HDDs for smaller systems; Seagate says IronWolf Pro is designed for larger multi-user RAID setups.

  • Seagate specifies CMR and up to 180 TB/year for IronWolf. For IronWolf Pro, the manufacturer specifies up to 550 TB/year and a five-year limited warranty.
  • The Pro range’s rating doesn’t automatically mean faster backups on your own network. Check the model, NAS compatibility and the terms for warranty or service benefits.

Toshiba

Toshiba positions the N300 range for uses including multimedia storage and backups.

  • For the listed models, Toshiba’s datasheet specifies CMR, 3.5 inches, 7200 rpm and up to 180 TB/year.
  • Capacity and form factor vary by model. Check the model number and NAS approval for the specific drive.

Synology

Synology says its Plus Series includes NAS hard drives for Synology systems.

  • Synology specifies CMR, firmware updates through DSM and a three-year limited warranty for the Plus Series.
  • Before buying, check the compatibility list for your exact NAS model. Manufacturer comparisons only apply under the test conditions stated.

Joybuy products for Synology NAS

This selection includes internal Synology hard drives for compatible NAS systems, with nominal capacities of 6 TB, 12 TB or 16 TB. The same stated capacity doesn’t necessarily mean the same amount of usable storage in your NAS setup.

Synology HAT3310-12T with 12 TB

Synology HAT3310-12T, 12 TB

A 12 TB option for regular NAS write workloads, provided your Synology NAS is compatible with this model.

CMR; workload rating: 180 TB/year; SATA III, 3.5 inches; 7200 rpm; 512 MB cache.

Joybuy
Synology HAT3310-16T with 16 TB

Synology HAT3310-16T, 16 TB

A 16 TB option for larger video libraries, provided your Synology NAS is compatible with this model.

CMR; workload rating: 180 TB/year; SATA 6 Gb/s, 3.5 inches; 7200 rpm; 512 MB cache. The stated data rate of 281 MB/s isn’t a guarantee of the performance of your entire NAS.

Joybuy
Synology HAT3300-6T with 6 TB

Synology HAT3300-6T, 6 TB

A 6 TB option for a smaller planned storage setup, provided your Synology NAS is compatible with this model.

CMR; workload rating: 180 TB/year; SATA 6 Gb/s, 3.5 inches; 5400 rpm; 256 MB cache. The stated read speed is up to 202 MB/s.

Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID replace a separate backup of my video projects?

No. The BSI distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup because mirrored changes are copied at the same time. To keep earlier project versions, plan for a separate backup and test whether you can restore the files you need from it.

What should I check before installing a hard drive?

Check the form factor, connection and exact model number for your NAS and the intended drive bay. Synology recommends using its compatibility list for each model. A general NAS hard drive label doesn’t confirm that a drive will fit every device.

How can I check that my backup is recoverable?

Test restoring a complete project folder and check that the files you need are readable. The BSI notes that backup software must be able to handle the data formats in use.

Are a manufacturer’s warranty and statutory consumer rights the same thing?

No. In Germany, your statutory rights against the seller are set out by law; a manufacturer’s warranty is an additional voluntary benefit subject to its own terms. So check the terms for the specific hard drive and seller.