When choosing a NAS for interview recordings, start with how you’ll import files, then consider how you’ll create a separate backup and test that you can restore it. As Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security explains, RAID mirroring is not a substitute for a backup. Next, consider the enclosure, including room for cables and airflow, noise levels, the capacity you need and access controls. If your recordings identify individuals, the protection required will depend on how you use them.
Who is a NAS suitable for?
Anyone with irreplaceable interviews
If you can’t repeat a conversation, plan for a separate backup as well as your NAS, and test whether you can restore a recording. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security does not consider data mirroring to be a backup.
People working at a small desk
Check the enclosure dimensions against the space available, and allow room for cables and airflow. Noise figures apply only under the stated test conditions, so they may not reflect how loud the NAS will be during an import or backup.
Anyone with confidential interview files
If you’re sharing interviews with selected team members or they identify individuals, appropriate access permissions and safeguards are important. The measures you need will depend on how you use the files.
What should you look for when buying?
First, check how you’ll import and restore files, then consider the space available and access controls. Once these requirements are covered, you can choose capacity, drives and network connections to suit your workflow.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Restoring files |
A separate backup destination and a restore process you can test; RAID mirroring is no substitute for a backup. |
If a recording can’t be repeated, I want a separate copy that I’ve tested restoring. Around 31 % of consumers put recovery first. |
| Space and noise |
Enclosure dimensions, including room for cables and ventilation; the test conditions behind any noise figures. |
At a small desk, the enclosure needs to fit with its connections, and noise during my own workflow matters too. Around 25 % of consumers prioritise desk-friendliness. |
| Confidential access |
User accounts, sharing permissions, updates and safeguards appropriate for how you’ll use the NAS. |
If I’m sharing interview files with my team or recording identifiable people, I want to control access carefully. Around 25 % of consumers put controlled access first. |
| Drives and importing |
Recording requirements and how long you want to keep files; drive compatibility, what’s included and a suitable import method. |
When I use different recording media, I want file imports to fit easily into my workflow and to know which drives I’ll need. Around 19 % of consumers prioritise importing and drive planning. |
Common buying mistakes
-
Thinking two mirrored drives count as a backup
Mirroring can copy changes such as accidental overwrites or malware damage to both drives. That’s why Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security does not consider RAID mirroring to be a backup.
Create a separate backup and regularly test whether you can restore a recording from it.
As well as the NAS, budget for suitable drives and space for a separate backup destination.
-
Comparing idle noise figures with noise levels during use
Manufacturers’ figures are based on specific test conditions. Drives, fans and vibrations can also contribute to noise, so an idle figure won’t necessarily tell you how the NAS will sound during an import or backup.
Check the test conditions for the model you’re considering. If you’re working in a noise-sensitive space, consider placing the NAS elsewhere.
-
Planning only for raw capacity and the NAS enclosure
Usable capacity depends on drive sizes and your storage configuration. You’ll also need a separate destination for your backup.
Work out what you need based on recording sizes and how long you’ll keep them. Check the specific listing to see whether drives are included and whether they’re compatible with the model.
Brands worth considering
Synology
The DS225+ is a two-bay model for central file storage, USB imports and backups to a separate destination.
- Synology documents USB Copy support for the DS225+ and lists the model as compatible with Hyper Backup.
- The 19,6 dB(A) noise figure is based on an idle test with specific hard drives. It doesn’t indicate how loud the device will be at every desk or during a backup.
- Synology recommends checking its drive compatibility list. The more flexible installation of third-party drives under DSM 7.3 does not guarantee full support for every drive.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a slim, two-bay model with a USB Copy button and Gigabit Ethernet for importing files locally.
- QNAP lists the TS-233 as 91,7 mm wide and says it has a USB Copy button.
- A slim enclosure doesn’t mean the device will be quiet in use. Remember to allow space for connections and airflow too.
ASUSTOR
The AS3302T v2 combines two drive bays with a 2,5-GbE connection, plus documented sharing and file system features.
- ASUSTOR lists a 2,5-GbE port, Btrfs and SMB shares for this model.
- The faster network connection is useful only if your connected devices and network infrastructure can support it too.
- The manufacturer’s 18,6 dB figure is based on hard drives at idle. It isn’t an independent comparison of noise levels against other models in use.
NAS models at Joybuy
These NAS enclosures are designed to store interview recordings centrally. When comparing them, consider the number of drive bays, the space available and how you can set up a separate backup.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS, Dual 2.5GbE
An option if you want to store interview files centrally in an enclosure with four drive bays.
Four drive bays; Dual 2.5GbE; expandable to up to 9 Bays; M.2 NVMe SSD Caching.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DS225+ 2-Bay NAS, Diskless Desktop Enclosure
This two-bay enclosure is an option for storing interview files centrally when desk space is limited and you’re planning to buy drives separately.
Two drive bays; dimensions 23,22 × 10,80 × 16,50 cm; USB-A 3.0; RAID 0/1/JBOD. Listed as diskless: drives must be installed separately. RAID mirroring is no substitute for a separate backup.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 enough to back up my interview files?
No. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security does not consider mirroring to be a backup, because changes affect both drives. Create a separate copy and check that you can restore your files from it.
How much desk space should I leave free?
Check the dimensions of the specific enclosure against the space you have, and allow extra room for connections and airflow. QNAP notes that the TS-233’s dimensions do not include any optional feet. An idle noise figure won’t necessarily reflect how loud the NAS will be during a backup.
Can I record or share a private conversation without permission?
Section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers recording another person’s non-public spoken words without authorisation, as well as using or making such a recording available to others. Make sure you have permission before recording; buying a NAS does not give you that permission. For telephone recordings, the Data Protection Conference notes that, as a rule, the consent of the other person on the call is also required under data protection law. The legal basis and safeguards that apply will depend on the circumstances.