A NAS is a good choice for a digital journal in a shared studio if you can keep private and shared folders separate and set access permissions for individual accounts. You should also check that there’s a verifiable backup process for your writing devices, that you can restore older versions, and that you have an additional copy stored separately. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) points out that RAID mirroring alone is no substitute for a backup.
Who would benefit from a journal NAS?
Journal writers in a shared studio
You want to back up your entries without automatically giving other people in the studio access to your private folders. The BSI describes access permissions based on the need-to-know principle as an advantage of centralised network drives.
Writers using multiple devices
You add to your journal on more than one device and want to be able to track the backup and recovery process. Check that your devices are compatible and set up backups for the folders you actually use.
Writers who revise their work frequently
You want to be able to restore an earlier version after accidentally deleting or overwriting an entry. Synology and TerraMaster describe versioning or snapshot features for certain models and system requirements.
What should you look for when buying?
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Private access permissions |
Check that individual accounts and folder permissions are available; test access using an account without permission. |
If I keep a journal in the studio, other members shouldn’t be able to read or change my private entries. Around 33% of consumers prioritise protecting private folders. |
| Restorable backups |
Check the backup process from your writing device; plan for an additional, separate copy and a restore test. |
If I want to rely on a backup, I need to know that it includes the right files and that they can be restored. Around 27% of consumers prioritise restoring from a separate, tested copy. |
| Earlier journal versions |
Check the model, software version and file system requirements for versioning or snapshots; test restoring an older version. |
If I revise my entries, I want to be able to restore an earlier version after accidentally overwriting or deleting one. Around 20% of consumers prioritise access to older versions. |
| Manageable costs and effort |
Check what’s included and which drives you’ll need; plan for usable capacity and an additional backup destination. |
If I mainly back up text files, I want to keep the cost, set-up and regular maintenance manageable. Around 20% of consumers focus primarily on keeping the overall effort reasonable. |
Common NAS backup mistakes
-
Mistaking mirroring for two independent backups
With mirroring, unwanted changes can be applied to both drives at the same time. The BSI explicitly distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup.
Whatever your RAID configuration, plan for a separate copy and test that you can restore your journal data.
You’ll need to set up and maintain both the versioning rules and the additional backup.
-
Assuming shared network access means journal permissions are set up correctly
Whether other people can read or edit your journal files depends on the user and folder permissions you’ve set up.
Keep private folders separate from shared ones and test access using an account that doesn’t have permission to view the private area.
NAS brands worth considering
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a specific NAS with two drive bays. For this model, Synology describes features including PC folder backups with Synology Drive and Btrfs functions from DSM 7.2.
- Scheduled backups and earlier file versions may be useful for journal folders, provided you set up the relevant features.
- Synology also recommends backing up to another destination; the available features are no substitute for set-up or a restore test.
QNAP
QNAP describes the TS-233 as a model with two drive bays and features for file storage, snapshots and account protection.
- Account protection features may be useful for managing access in a shared studio, provided you set them up.
- According to QNAP’s specifications, the 2 GB of memory is built in and cannot be upgraded.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a specific model with two drive bays; ASUSTOR lists Btrfs snapshots as a supported feature.
- Snapshots may be useful for restoring earlier journal versions, provided the model is set up appropriately.
- For this model, ASUSTOR lists 1 GB of memory and Gigabit Ethernet. You should still plan an additional backup to a separate destination.
TerraMaster
According to TerraMaster, the F2-223 offers two 2.5-GbE ports and is also designed for small office environments.
- The ports may be useful if you have compatible network equipment and need to transfer larger files.
- TerraMaster requires TOS version 5.0 or later and Btrfs for its documented snapshots. The network ports alone don’t offer a proven advantage when backing up small journal entries.
Recommended products at Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Is RAID 1 enough to back up my journal?
No. The BSI explicitly distinguishes data mirroring from data backup, because changes are mirrored too. Keep a separate copy and test that you can restore it.
How do I set up the NAS in a shared studio?
Decide who can read or edit private and shared folders, then test the permissions using the relevant user accounts. Next, set up the backup process from your writing device and try restoring an entry.
Do I need to set anything up to use snapshots?
Yes. Check the requirements for your specific model and set up the feature. Synology lists Btrfs features for the DS223j from DSM 7.2; TerraMaster’s documentation requires TOS version 5.0 or later and Btrfs for the snapshots described.
What should I consider when my journal contains other people’s personal data?
First, establish who is responsible for processing the data and which safeguards are appropriate in your particular situation. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information notes that suitable technical and organisational measures are relevant when data controllers or processors handle personal data.