Who is a NAS suitable for?

Students with a growing video archive

If you want to build up a local collection of recordings over several semesters and find them on your home network, plan for the storage space you need and regular backups.

Students with irreplaceable recordings

If the files would be difficult to get again, it’s important to have a separate copy that you can restore. Mirroring alone won’t protect you against every cause of data loss.

Lecturers with large video files

If you often transfer large files across your home network, check that the NAS network port is compatible with the rest of your network equipment.

What should you look for when buying?

The BSI recommends considering how you’ll restore data as part of your backup plan. A mirrored NAS configuration is no substitute for a separate backup copy.

Buying priority What to check before buying Who is this important to?
Local storage Check local file access and user management, and review the cloud sync and remote access settings. If I want my recordings to stay on my home network rather than being stored with a public cloud service, I look for local storage and controlled access; around 36% of consumers put these priorities first.
Restoring files Plan for a separate copy and a practical way to test restoring files from it. I want to be able to restore recordings after a device fault or accidental overwrite; around 29% of consumers prioritise being able to recover their files.
Space for a growing archive Estimate your existing files and future needs on the same basis, and check drive compatibility. If I want to keep recordings from more semesters and transfer large files, I plan for suitable capacity and a suitable network port; around 21% of consumers put their archive’s storage needs first.
Setup and ongoing effort Check what’s included and which drives you’ll need. If you want to use the NAS offline, check the setup requirements for the specific model. I want to set up and manage a straightforward archive without unnecessary extras; around 14% of consumers put setup and running costs first.

Common buying and planning mistakes

  • Assuming mirroring gives you two independent backups

    With mirroring, unwanted changes can be copied to both drives at the same time. That’s why the BSI does not count RAID mirroring as a standalone data backup.

    Plan for an additional, separate copy and regularly check that you can restore files from it.

    You’ll need an additional backup medium and time for regular restore tests.

  • Assuming “no cloud storage” means “no internet required”

    Local storage doesn’t tell you whether the specific model needs an internet connection for initial setup. COMPUTER BILD notes that an internet connection is required to set up the Synology DS225+ and DS224+.

    If you also need to be able to set it up offline, check the requirements for the exact model you intend to buy.

  • Assuming the NAS network port guarantees a particular speed

    A 2.5GbE port describes the type of connection, not the transfer speed you’ll actually achieve. ASUSTOR identifies its own transfer rates as lab measurements taken under optimised conditions.

    Only make a faster port a buying priority if the other devices and connections on your network can support it too.

    You may need additional network equipment.

NAS brands at a glance

Synology

The DS223j is a two-bay option for storing files locally and accessing them on your home network.

  • According to Synology, it offers 1GbE and two USB 3.2 Gen 1 ports.
  • The specifications state that a separately purchased holder is needed for 2.5-inch drives. Optional syncing with public cloud services is separate from local storage.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay alternative for local files and media.

  • QNAP lists a Gigabit Ethernet port, one USB 3.2 Gen 1 port and two USB 2.0 ports.
  • The advertised internet access through myQNAPcloud is an additional feature. It doesn’t mean your recordings have to be stored publicly.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Pro Gen2 AS3302T v2 may be worth considering if you regularly transfer large files over a suitably equipped local network.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet and 2 GB RAM for this model.
  • ASUSTOR says its transfer figures are based on its own tests under optimised conditions, so they aren’t independent measurements of day-to-day archiving performance.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 is another two-bay option, with a 2.5GbE port listed by the manufacturer.

  • TerraMaster lists 4 GB RAM and local management features.
  • Cloud sync is also advertised, but it’s optional. The manufacturer’s claims about speed and convenience aren’t based on independent comparative tests.

NAS option on Joybuy

This NAS option is suited to a large, growing local archive where multiple drive bays and network access may be important.

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS, Dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE, up to 360TB, metal, black

The 8-bay version could suit a substantial archive. Check that its storage capacity matches your actual needs.

The product description lists Dual 2.5GbE, an optional 10GbE upgrade and up to 360TB. Check the exact drive configuration and what’s included before buying.

View on Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID 1 already back up my recordings?

No. The German Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes drive mirroring from data backup because mirrored data can be overwritten at the same time or changed by malware. Plan for a separate copy and check that you can restore files from it.

Does a NAS have to store my files with a cloud service?

No. The term “private cloud” doesn’t automatically mean that files are stored with a public cloud service. Synology describes both local file access and a separate feature for syncing with public services. Check the settings on the specific model.

How can I back up recordings without public cloud storage?

One option is to regularly make a copy on an external storage device and keep it separately. The BSI recommends thinking about restoring files as well as backing them up. The right frequency and storage capacity depend on your archive.

What additional purchases should I plan for?

Check whether drives are included, which drives and any holders you’ll need, and how you’ll make a separate backup. For the DS223j, Synology lists a separately purchased holder for 2.5-inch drives. Ongoing effort will depend, among other things, on the configuration you choose.

Can I record a lecture myself and archive it on my NAS?

There’s no blanket yes or no. Section 53(7) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) requires the rights holder’s consent to record public lectures of a work on video or audio. You should also consider the type of teaching session, whether other people are involved and the rules of the relevant university. Heidelberg University generally advises against recording students. Storing a recording locally doesn’t replace any permission you may need. If a recording has already been provided, check the specific terms of use.