Who is a NAS for model railway project photos suitable for?

People working together on a photo archive

If several people use the same project folders, separate read and write permissions can help you manage access according to each person’s role. QNAP documents these folder permissions for QTS.

People responsible for irreplaceable photos

If you want to keep original photos and earlier versions of projects, plan for a separate backup and a way to restore files from it. The BSI specifically distinguishes data backups from RAID mirroring.

People looking after a growing archive

If you’re continually adding new photos, you’ll need enough usable storage space, with room for backup copies too. If you often transfer large files, the entire network connection may also be a factor.

What should you look for when choosing a NAS?

First, decide who should be able to view or edit project folders. Then plan for recovery and the usable capacity you need. Consider a faster network port only if you regularly transfer large files and the rest of your network connection can support it.

What you need What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Shared access with the right permissions Separate accounts and read and write permissions; access from the workstation you actually use. If several of us access photos from the same workstation, I want to decide who can edit the originals. Around 33% of consumers prioritise managed shared access.
Photos and project versions you can restore A separate backup destination, backup schedule and a practical way to restore files. If photos are accidentally deleted or overwritten, I want to be able to recover earlier project versions. Around 27% of consumers put recovery first.
Usable archive capacity Work out how much storage is already in use and how quickly it is likely to grow; check the drive configuration and storage arrangement against the usable capacity you need. For a growing photo archive, I want to allow space for new photos and versions I’m keeping. Around 20% of consumers prioritise archive capacity.
Speed when transferring large photo files Compare the ports on the NAS, workstation and the rest of your network; don’t take manufacturers’ figures as a guaranteed speed for your own files. If I often transfer large project folders, the time taken to copy them matters to me. Around 20% of consumers prioritise fast transfers.

Common mistakes when choosing a NAS for a photo archive

  • Treating RAID 1 or snapshots as a complete backup

    Mirroring also copies unwanted changes. Local versions won’t protect you if you lose the entire NAS either. The BSI does not consider RAID mirroring to be a data backup.

    Plan for a separate copy and test whether you can restore a project folder from it.

  • Comparing only the NAS enclosure or raw capacity

    The capacity you can actually use depends on the drives and configuration. QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs.

    Check which drives you need for your configuration and how much storage will then be available for photos and versions you want to keep.

  • Assuming 2.5 GbE on the NAS guarantees faster copying

    A faster port on the NAS alone doesn’t mean that transfers will be quicker at your workstation. The rest of your network connection and how you use it also matter.

    Check the ports on the NAS, workstation and devices in between. Depending on your setup, you may need to upgrade your workstation or network.

NAS brands worth considering

Synology

The DS223j is one option for sharing photos and files; the two-bay DS225+ adds a 2.5 GbE port.

  • Synology lists Synology Photos and Drive for the DS223j, and a 2.5 GbE port for the DS225+.
  • For Plus models from 2025 onwards, drive compatibility depends on the model and DSM version. Synology says DSM 7.3 offers more flexibility for certain third-party drives, but still recommends checking its compatibility list.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay option with two 2.5 GbE ports and sharing features in QTS.

  • QNAP documents adjustable folder permissions and snapshot features for QTS.
  • QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs. You’ll therefore need to factor in drives and a separate backup destination.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 is a two-bay option for storing files and photo folders centrally.

  • TerraMaster lists 4 GB of memory, a 2.5 GbE port and separate accounts for this model.
  • These specifications apply to the F2-425; on their own, they don’t tell you what transfer speeds you’ll get at your workstation.

NAS products at Joybuy

Similar products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions about NAS devices for model railway project photos

Are two mirrored hard drives enough to back up my project photos?

No. Mirroring doesn’t replace a separate backup. The BSI does not consider RAID mirroring to be a data backup, because changes can be copied to the mirrored data too. Plan for a separate copy and check that you can restore the folders you need from it.

How do I set up a project folder for a shared workspace?

Set up a shared project folder and suitable user accounts, then assign read or write permissions according to each person’s role. QNAP documents these folder permissions for QTS; check what’s available on the NAS you choose and test access from your workstation.

What else should I budget for besides the NAS enclosure?

Check whether drives are included and what additional, separate backup option you’ll need. QNAP specifically states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without HDDs. The right configuration depends on your archive and backup plan.

What are the rules in Germany for photos of other people in a shared archive?

Whether data protection obligations apply depends on who is processing the photos and for what purpose. According to the German Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information (BfDI), the GDPR does not apply to processing carried out solely for personal or family purposes; associations generally fall within its scope. The BfDI also notes that the personal-use exemption no longer applies if photos of other people are published online. The fact that a workspace is shared does not, by itself, determine whether a particular archive is lawful.