Who is a NAS right for?

Model makers with irreplaceable build photos

If you want to look back at your progress later, plan for a separate backup alongside your NAS and make sure you have a tested way to restore your photos. The Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes between data mirroring and data backup.

Model makers with photos on several devices

If you photograph your layout on your smartphone and view or edit the images on your computer, you’ll need a suitable way to import them and a shared archive.

Model makers who want to avoid public cloud storage

If you want to store your photos on a device of your own, check which features work locally and whether optional syncing with public cloud services can be switched off.

What should you look for when buying?

What you need What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Store photos locally Check that you can store photos on the NAS and that cloud syncing is optional. If I want to store my project photos without public cloud storage, I look for local storage and services I can control. Around 29% of consumers put control over their local data first.
Back up project photos Plan a separate backup and test that you can restore your photos; RAID 1 is no substitute for a backup. If I can’t simply retake photos of my build, I want to set up a way to restore them as well as using a NAS. Around 29% of consumers prioritise protection against losing photos.
Import and find photos Check how you’ll import photos from your devices, as well as the photo app, folders and indexing. If I photograph my progress on a smartphone, I want to transfer the images easily and find them by project later. Around 24% of consumers put this photo workflow first.
Keep the effort manageable Factor in the drives you’ll need, a separate backup device and set-up; compare what you need with an external hard drive. If I mainly work from one computer, I want to weigh the extra equipment and upkeep against the benefits of an archive I can access from multiple devices. Around 18% of consumers prioritise effort and total cost.

Common buying and set-up mistakes

  • Assuming two mirrored hard drives provide a complete backup

    Mirroring can help if a drive fails, but it also copies unwanted changes and won’t protect you against every cause of data loss. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that RAID mirroring is no substitute for a backup.

    Use RAID 1 to protect against the specific risk of a drive failure. Add a separate backup and check that you can restore your photos.

    A separate backup device and regular upkeep are part of your backup plan.

  • Confusing a “private cloud” with a required public cloud storage service

    The name alone doesn’t tell you where your photos will be stored once everything is set up. Some NAS devices also offer optional syncing with public cloud services.

    For the model you’re considering, check where photos are stored and which syncing features are enabled.

  • Expecting a photo app to work straight away without any set-up

    Depending on the system, you may first need to set up photo folders, sources and indexing. Smartphone uploads may also require you to grant the right permissions on your mobile device.

    Before buying, check your preferred way to import photos and the app instructions for the specific model.

    Allow time to set up folders, access permissions, app permissions and indexing.

  • Overlooking drives and a separate backup when planning

    A NAS enclosure on its own doesn’t give you a complete storage and backup plan. Mirroring needs two drives and doesn’t replace a separate backup device.

    Decide how many drives you need and where you’ll keep a separate backup. Compare the overall effort with using an external hard drive.

    Depending on your storage plan, you’ll also need the required drives and a separate backup device.

NAS brands at a glance

Synology

The DiskStation DS223j is a specific two-bay model for storing photos locally with Synology Photos.

  • Synology describes how to upload photos to your own NAS using the DS223j.
  • Optional syncing with public cloud services is a separate feature; check that it’s configured as you want.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a specific two-bay model with the QuMagie photo gallery.

  • QNAP describes how to upload photos using QuMagie on the TS-233.
  • According to QNAP’s specifications, the TS-233 has 2 GB of built-in, non-expandable memory.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is a two-bay model with Photo Gallery and AiFoto, both relevant apps for managing your photo workflow.

  • The datasheet lists two drive bays and Gigabit Ethernet.
  • ASUSTOR notes that iOS apps have limited ability to upload photos automatically in the background; check the app and your settings.

TerraMaster

The F2-212 is one option for managing photos locally with TerraMaster Photos and a personal photo folder.

  • TerraMaster describes how to import smartphone photos into your personal folder on the TNAS.
  • You’ll need to set up photo sources and media indexing for the gallery. Also check the TOS version and app availability for the specific model.

NAS options at Joybuy

This selection of NAS devices is for storing model railway photos on a local network. Check which photo apps and import options are available for your devices with the specific model you’re considering.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS with four drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS

Could suit a local NAS photo archive if you need four drive bays and the network connections listed.

Four drive bays; two 2.5GbE ports; expandable to up to nine bays, according to the product name.

According to the product description, this model is only compatible with Synology drives; check this restriction when choosing your drives.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS with eight drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-Bay NAS

Could be worth considering if your storage plan calls for a NAS with eight drive bays and the networking options listed in the product name.

Eight drive bays; two built-in 2.5GbE ports; optional 10GbE; up to 360TB, according to the product name.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my model railway photos?

No. The Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes between mirroring and data backup: RAID 1 can protect you against a single drive failure, but not accidental overwriting or malware. Keep a separate copy as well and check that you can restore it.

Do I need to enable public cloud storage to upload photos from my smartphone?

Not necessarily: Synology describes uploading to your own NAS with the DS223j, QNAP describes uploading to the NAS with the TS-233, and TerraMaster offers a personal photo folder on the TNAS. Check how the app is configured for the specific model and only grant the permissions your mobile device needs.

Why don’t newly transferred photos appear in the gallery straight away?

With TerraMaster Photos, you need to set up media indexing and photo sources. ASUSTOR also notes that images need to be indexed and thumbnails created before they appear, so check your folders, permissions and indexing first.

How can I keep a NAS secure on my home network?

Secure your router and other devices on your home network carefully too, as recommended by the Federal Office for Information Security. Remote access isn’t essential for a photo archive you only use at home; only enable it if you actually need it.

Could an external hard drive be enough instead of a NAS?

Yes, if you mainly store your photos on one computer and don’t need to access them across several devices or use a NAS photo gallery. Even with an external hard drive, you’ll need a separate backup for irreplaceable photos of your build.