Who is this choice relevant to?

Anyone responsible for recoverable family backups

If you want to retrieve files or restore a computer after a fault, plan what to back up and how you’ll recover it. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) lists external hard drives as one possible backup medium.

Anyone managing shared group files

If several authorised people need to use the files, separate accounts and clear responsibilities are important. The safeguards required for personal data depend on how it is actually processed, as noted by the Rhineland-Palatinate Data Protection Authority and the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information.

Anyone planning an expanding archive

If you also want to store family photos and group documents, consider how much data you already have, how quickly it’s likely to grow and how much space you’ll need for separate backup copies.

What should you consider when buying?

External hard drive

A good fit if: you mainly need occasional backups of a single computer and don’t need regular shared access to files.

Bear in mind: you’ll need to start backups regularly and store the drive separately.

NAS

A good fit if: you need regular computer backups as well as shared file access for selected group members.

Bear in mind: you’ll need to plan for setup, access permissions and an additional backup stored separately. Mirroring won’t protect you from deletions or malware affecting both drives at the same time.

What matters What to check before buying Who it matters most to
Recoverability Support for your operating system and the backup scope you need; test how recovery works. If I need to retrieve files or restore my computer after a fault, a suitable backup method matters most to me; around 36% of consumers put recoverability first.
Controlled group access Check user and folder permissions, as well as how much effort they take to manage. If I share group files but don’t want to give everyone access to private family folders, I need separate accounts; around 29% of consumers prioritise controlled access.
Usable storage space Compare the amount of data you have and expect to add with the usable capacity of your chosen drive configuration. If I’m planning to store photos, computer files and group documents together, the space that’s actually available matters most to me; around 21% of consumers put storage planning first.
Setup effort and what’s included Check whether drives are included and what additional medium you’ll need for a separate copy. If I want to keep setup and ongoing management straightforward, I check what’s included and how the backup process works in advance; around 14% of consumers prioritise ease of use.

Common buying and backup mistakes

  • Counting mirrored drives as two independent backups

    With mirroring, changes are copied to both drives. That’s why the BSI does not consider RAID mirroring an independent backup; damage at the location where the drives are kept could also affect both.

    Plan an additional copy stored separately, and check that you can restore the data you need from it.

    This requires another backup medium or an additional backup location.

  • Assuming a NAS enclosure comes with a ready-to-use backup solution

    QNAP states that the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. With other models, too, usable capacity depends on the specific drive configuration.

    Check what’s included with the listing, which drives are compatible and where you’ll keep a separate backup.

    You may need to budget for additional drives and a separate backup medium.

  • Keeping family and group files under one shared account

    If group files contain personal data, shared accounts could give people broader access than necessary. The data protection requirements that apply depend on how the data is actually processed and who is responsible.

    If personal data is involved, clarify who manages it and set up accounts with only the permissions people need.

NAS brands at a glance

Synology

The DS223j is worth considering for planned PC folder backups and shared files; the DS225+ is part of a different product range.

  • Synology describes scheduled or continuous PC folder backups with Synology Drive for the DS223j.
  • This folder backup does not provide a complete system backup with this application, and it doesn’t replace a separate backup destination.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay device for home use; the TS-264-8G adds more ports and slots to the range.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5-GbE ports and two M.2 slots for the TS-264-8G. HDP PC Agent supports Windows file and system backups.
  • The TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives. HDP PC Agent requires the specified NAS software version, so check the setup requirements for your particular model.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is another two-bay option for backup and file-sharing plans.

  • The manufacturer lists RAID 1, file sharing and a 2.5-GbE port.
  • The memory in this model cannot be upgraded. A faster NAS port alone does not guarantee a corresponding speed boost across the rest of your network.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP2800 is a two-bay option for buyers looking beyond backups to consider other hardware features.

  • The manufacturer lists 2.5-GbE, two SATA slots and two M.2 slots.
  • Hard drives are not included with the listing described here. The manufacturer’s speed claims are not an independently measured figure for a family computer.

NAS models at Joybuy

This selection features Synology NAS enclosures with multiple drive bays, suited to larger or growing storage and backup plans.

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS, Dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE, up to 360TB, metal, black

Could suit a plan that includes other devices or shared files alongside the family computer.

The product name lists eight drive bays, Dual 2.5GbE and optional 10GbE. Usable capacity depends on the drive configuration.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS, Dual 2.5GbE, expandable to up to 9 bays, M.2 NVMe SSD caching, black

Could be worth considering if you’re looking for a NAS for your backup plan and may want to expand it later.

The product name lists four drive bays, expansion to up to nine bays, Dual 2.5GbE and M.2 NVMe SSD caching. Usable capacity depends on the drive configuration.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough for a backup?

No. According to the implementation guidance from the German Federal Office for Information Security, changes are copied to both drives at the same time when they’re mirrored. This means mirroring won’t protect you from accidental overwrites or malware. An additional backup and a tested recovery method are still important.

How do I set up a computer backup?

First decide whether you need to be able to restore individual folders or the entire system. Synology describes PC folder backups with Synology Drive for the DS223j; QNAP describes Windows file and system backups with HDP PC Agent, subject to the relevant software requirements. Then test whether you can restore the data you need.

What should I check about what’s included and backup media?

Check the specific listing to see whether drives are included, which drives you need for your configuration and what additional medium you’ll use to store a separate backup. Allow time for setup and a recovery test, too.

Does the GDPR apply to a community group?

The Rhineland-Palatinate Data Protection Authority explicitly confirms that the GDPR applies to an association that processes personal data, including charitable or unregistered associations. The requirements that apply to the group in question depend on how it actually processes data and who is responsible. Where personal data is involved, you’ll need to establish a lawful basis and put appropriate safeguards in place. This does not mean there is a blanket requirement to buy a particular NAS.