A NAS could be a good fit if photos are regularly uploaded from several devices to one shared location, or if authorised users need access. For occasional copies from a single computer, an external hard drive is often simpler. Choose based on how you’ll transfer and restore your files, and plan for an additional, separate backup regardless of whether you mirror the drives. If the photos show identifiable people, access permissions and the specific school or publication-related purpose should also factor into your decision.
Who is a NAS suitable for?
Consumers backing up project photos
If you want to recover photos after losing a device or accidentally deleting files, plan for an additional, separate copy as well as the NAS. The Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) points out that backed-up data must also be restorable.
Smartphone photographers
If most of your project photos are taken on a smartphone, it’s important to have a reliable, regular way to transfer them. Synology describes automatic photo and video uploads for the DS223j via Synology Photos or Synology Drive. Check the features of the model you’re considering and make sure it’s compatible with your devices.
Project groups sharing photos
If several people need selected photos, you should be able to restrict access to the intended users and folders. If the photos show identifiable people, you should also establish the specific purpose and requirements for their intended use.
What should you look for when buying?
NAS
Suitable if: Several authorised devices need access to project photos, or regular uploads are important.
Bear in mind: Mirroring drives requires an additional drive and doesn’t replace a separate backup.
External USB hard drive
Suitable if: You occasionally copy photos from a single device and don’t need a shared network folder or automatic uploads.
Bear in mind: You’ll need to organise and regularly check the copying, storage and restoration process yourself.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who is this important to? |
| Restorable backup |
Check for a separate backup destination and test restoring files. |
If I want to restore photos after losing a device, I need a copy that can actually be restored; around 33% of consumers put restorability first when backing up school project photos. |
| Regular photo imports |
Check the transfer method for each device and verify the files have transferred. |
If I take most of my photos on a smartphone or computer, a reliable import process matters to me; around 27% of consumers prioritise regular photo imports. |
| Controlled access |
Check that you can share with selected users and folders. |
If several people need selected project photos, I want to restrict access to the right people; around 20% of consumers prioritise controlled collaboration. |
| Storage and what’s included |
Estimate the size of your photo folders and how much they’re likely to grow; check which drives are included and how much usable capacity you’ll have. |
If my storage budget is limited, I want to know in advance which drives are included and how much space I can actually use; around 20% of consumers focus on these questions. |
NAS and backup buying pitfalls
-
Mistaking mirrored drives for a complete backup
Two drives in the same NAS aren’t an independently stored copy of your project photos.
Plan for a second storage location and check that you can restore files from it.
Remember to budget for separate backup storage and time to test restoring your files.
-
Assuming an empty NAS enclosure is a complete package
The number of drive bays doesn’t tell you whether drives are included.
Check what’s included in the specific offer and whether the drives you plan to use are compatible.
Depending on the offer, you may need to buy suitable hard drives separately.
-
Assuming shared access means unrestricted sharing
Photos of identifiable people may contain personal data. Storing them locally doesn’t automatically determine who can view or share them.
Limit access to the intended group and, before sharing, establish the specific purpose and appropriate legal basis.
Brands to consider
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is one example of a two-bay NAS with photo management and mobile photo uploads. It’s worth considering if you regularly import photos or need shared project folders.
- Synology lists Synology Photos, Synology Drive and shared media spaces among the DS223j’s features.
- According to Synology, the Btrfs features mentioned require DSM 7.2; this information doesn’t automatically apply to other DiskStation models.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS described as suitable for home use. Its dedicated USB copy button may also be useful for importing files.
- QNAP lists two 3.5-inch SATA bays, a Gigabit Ethernet port and a USB copy button for the TS-233.
- According to QNAP, this model has 2 GB of memory, which isn’t expandable. Check the import process and supported storage devices before buying.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is another two-bay option for local file storage.
- ASUSTOR describes the model as supporting Btrfs snapshots. Its specifications list two bays for 3.5-inch SATA drives, Gigabit Ethernet and 1 GB of memory.
- Snapshots aren’t a separate backup. ASUSTOR’s performance figures are manufacturer claims, not independent measurements for a school project.
TerraMaster
TerraMaster describes the F2-212 as suitable for managing personal files, photos and backups. You can also compare the model once you’ve considered setup and drive installation.
- TerraMaster highlights the tool-free drive installation and its TOS operating system.
- The manufacturer’s claims about particularly easy operation don’t prove that it’s better than other systems.
Related products on Joybuy
Similar products will be available soon.
Frequently asked questions
Are two mirrored hard drives enough as my only backup?
No. For important project photos, plan for an additional, separate copy that you can restore. Mirroring applies to the drives in the same NAS; whether you can recover older or deleted photos depends on your other backup.
Do I need to buy two hard drives for a NAS with two bays?
You can’t tell from the number of bays alone: check what’s included in the specific offer. You’ll need two suitable drives for mirroring, and the usable capacity won’t simply be the total of both drives’ capacities.
How can I check that my photos have really been backed up?
Choose your copying or upload method, check the files at the destination after they’ve transferred, and try restoring a few photos. The Federal Office for Information Security points out that restoring files needs to work too.
What additional costs should I budget for with a NAS?
Check whether the offer includes drives and, if needed, budget for suitable additional drives and separate backup storage. You can also check the warranty terms and how to replace a faulty drive for the specific model.
Can I share photos of my classmates just because they’re stored on my local NAS?
No. The storage location alone doesn’t determine whether a particular use is allowed. The data protection authority of Rhineland-Palatinate treats photos of identifiable people as personal data; the BfDI lists consent or a legal basis as possible requirements for processing. If the photos are being used as part of a school-organised activity, check the purpose and the relevant school rules. This doesn’t mean every school project is automatically permitted.