Who can benefit from a NAS for RAW files?

RAW file archivists

If you collect large original files, work out how much storage you need and how much will actually be usable before choosing your drives. This depends on the drives and configuration, as Synology explains in its product specifications.

Project teams

If several people or devices need access to a photo library, shared folders and suitable access permissions are important. If people can be identified in photos, the Rhineland-Palatinate Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information points out that the images contain personal data.

Backup-conscious users

If you want to recover original files after accidental deletion or a fault, you need a separate backup. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) does not consider RAID mirroring alone to be a data backup.

What matters when buying a NAS for a school project?

NAS with Gigabit LAN

A good fit if: you want to store and share project files centrally, and your network supports Gigabit speeds. QNAP lists a Gigabit Ethernet port for the TS-233.

The trade-off: It has a different type of connection from 2.5GbE models, and you’ll still need a separate backup.

NAS with 2.5GbE

A good fit if: you regularly transfer large RAW libraries and your NAS, computer and network connection all support 2.5GbE. Synology lists this connection for the DS225+, and ASUSTOR for the AS1202T.

The trade-off: The connection alone doesn’t guarantee a particular transfer speed. Synology also advises checking drive compatibility for the DS225+.

External hard drive

A good fit if: you occasionally copy project files from a single computer and don’t need a shared network folder.

The trade-off: You’ll need to organise copying, separate storage and recovery reliably yourself.

What you need What to check before buying Who is it important to?
Recoverable backup Plan for a separate backup destination and test that you can restore files. If I need to recover original files after a fault or accidental deletion, a separate, tested copy matters to me. Around 34% of consumers put a recoverable backup first.
Usable capacity Check your existing project folders and expected growth; match the drives and configuration to the usable capacity you need. For consumers with large RAW archives, it’s essential to have room for future photos too. Around 33% prioritise usable capacity for existing and new files.
Shared access Decide who can view or edit files, then set up sharing permissions accordingly. If we’re working with the same files as a project team, I need a shared folder with clearly defined permissions. Around 20% of consumers prioritise team access and manageable sharing permissions.
Transferring large files Check that the network connections on your NAS, computer and the rest of your network are compatible. When I regularly transfer large RAW files, I make sure the whole connection works for my workflow. Around 13% of consumers prioritise transfer speeds.

Common pitfalls with NAS devices and RAW files

  • Mistaking RAID mirroring for a backup

    Mirrored data can be changed on both drives at once. So mirroring alone can’t undo an accidental change or deletion, as the BSI points out.

    Make a separate copy of your RAW files and test that you can restore them before the project ends.

    A separate backup requires an additional destination and a regular routine.

  • Assuming the NAS enclosure is all the storage you need

    Synology says that drives for the DS225+ are sold separately. The manufacturer also recommends checking its compatibility list.

    Check the complete set-up: NAS, compatible drives and a separate backup destination.

    You’ll need suitable drives and possibly another backup device.

  • Assuming 2.5GbE guarantees a particular copy speed

    Manufacturers’ throughput figures come from tests carried out under specific conditions. Actual transfer speeds also depend on the drives, computer and network.

    Check the entire transfer path, and don’t base your choice solely on a stated MB/s figure.

    A faster connection may mean upgrading other parts of your network.

  • Assuming a private NAS means you can share photos of people freely

    When people can be identified, data protection concerns go beyond where the files are stored. The Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority classifies these photos as personal data.

    For photos featuring people, check the purpose, permissions and any school requirements before sharing files with your team or publishing them.

NAS brands to consider

Synology

Synology says the DS225+ combines two drive bays, file and photo management, and 1GbE and 2.5GbE connections. It may suit central project folders if your network infrastructure supports it.

  • The manufacturer’s data sheet lists backup features.
  • Drives are sold separately. Synology says full functionality, reliability and performance depend on using compatible drives, so check the compatibility list for the specific model.

QNAP

QNAP describes the TS-233 as a two-bay model for central file and photo storage. Its USB copy button may be useful for a suitable import workflow.

  • The hardware specifications list a Gigabit Ethernet port.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-233 has 2 GB of non-expandable memory and no 2.5GbE connection.

ASUSTOR

ASUSTOR describes the Drivestor 2 Gen2 AS1202T as a NAS for centralised home storage. According to the manufacturer, the model offers 2.5GbE and three USB ports.

  • ASUSTOR lists USB features for external backups.
  • The manufacturer specifies 1 GB of memory. Published transfer speeds are based on its own lab tests and aren’t a guarantee for your particular project set-up.

TerraMaster

TerraMaster describes the F2-212 as a two-bay NAS for personal file and photo storage.

  • The manufacturer lists tool-free drive installation as a feature of this model.
  • Claims about easy set-up don’t replace checking your drive and backup configuration. The noise figure only applies under the stated test conditions.

Joybuy products

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions about NAS devices and RAW files

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my RAW originals?

No, RAID 1 doesn’t replace a separate data backup. The BSI points out that mirrored data can change at the same time, so plan for a separate backup destination and test that you can restore your files.

Do I need a NAS for a school project, or will an external hard drive do?

A NAS could be a good fit if several devices or project members need regular access to the same files. For occasional copies from a single computer, an external hard drive is the simpler option. You’ll still need to arrange a separate backup and make sure you can restore your files.

How much storage do I need for RAW files?

Work out what you need based on the size of your existing project folders and the photos you plan to take. Then compare your drives and configuration with the NAS’s usable capacity, rather than assuming that raw capacity is the same as the storage space available to you.

Does 2.5GbE always make RAW file transfers faster?

Not automatically: your computer, network connection and drives also need to support it. A 2.5GbE port alone can’t predict the copy speed you’ll get with your set-up.

Can I store identifiable photos of classmates on my private NAS or publish project photos?

There’s no general answer without knowing how the photos were taken, their purpose, who is responsible and what the school’s requirements are. The Rhineland-Palatinate Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information points out that photos of identifiable people contain personal data. Check the requirements for taking the photos and any planned publication separately.