Who is a NAS suitable for?

Restore earlier project versions

You want to be able to recover recordings and edited versions right up until the hand-in date. The BSI points out that RAID mirroring is no substitute for a backup, so make sure you have a separate copy.

Share files with your project group

Several authorised people or computers need access to the same set of files. Synology describes Drive as a way to share and synchronise files; also agree who can edit a project at any given time.

Open projects on another computer

If you switch computers or hand over a project, the audio files used and the required software need to be available on the destination computer. Ableton’s guidance on collecting project files applies to Live; plug-ins are not copied automatically.

What should you look for when buying?

NAS as shared storage

A good fit if: several authorised devices regularly exchange project files.

Consider: access permissions, maintenance and an additional backup all need to be organised.

External drive

A good fit if: one person does most of the work on one computer and only needs an occasional project copy.

Consider: it does not provide a shared network folder for several devices; Ableton recommends a separate drive as a place to store backup copies of Live projects.

What you need What to check before buying Who it matters to
Restore earlier project versions Plan for a separate copy and check that you can restore a test file. If I need to recover earlier project versions before the hand-in date, a separate, tested copy matters. Around 36% of consumers prioritise recovery for this requirement.
Share files with specific people Check the user and folder permissions on the specific model; agree how to manage changes to the same project. A shared, controlled set of files matters to a project group. Around 29% of consumers put group sharing first.
Transfer a complete project Work out how much space full project folders need and test a copy on the destination computer. Don’t assume Ableton’s steps apply to other music software. When switching computers, I want to be able to open the project with all the files it needs. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a complete transfer.
Keep setup simple Check what’s included and which drives you’ll need; consider whether an external backup drive is enough for your workflow. If I mainly work on one computer, I want storage that’s easy to use without unnecessary management. Around 14% of consumers prioritise the simplest solution possible.

Avoid common mistakes

  • Assuming two mirrored drives provide a complete backup

    Accidentally deleted or changed files can also end up on the second drive when the drives are mirrored. That’s why the BSI distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup.

    Plan for a separate copy and regularly check that you can restore files from it.

  • Transferring only the music software’s project file

    A project may refer to audio files that aren’t included in the project file itself. With Ableton Live, plug-ins are not automatically included in the project folder either.

    Transfer the entire project folder and test it on the destination computer. Check plug-ins and licences separately; other software has its own export guidance.

    Searching for missing audio files or plug-ins later can take up extra time before the hand-in date.

  • Confusing shared storage with simultaneous editing

    Ableton recommends opening a synchronised Live project on only one system at a time, to prevent uncoordinated changes from clashing.

    Agree on a handover and version-control process before several people work on the same editable project.

NAS brands to consider

Synology

The DiskStation DS223j is one possible NAS storage option for small groups that want to access files across multiple devices.

  • Synology describes Drive as a way to share and synchronise files. The manufacturer lists Btrfs snapshots, provided you’re running DSM 7.2.
  • Snapshots are no substitute for a separate backup. The features listed do not prove that music projects can be edited directly over a network without problems.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay NAS for centralised file storage.

  • QNAP lists two drive bays, a Gigabit Ethernet port and a USB copy button among its features.
  • These details describe the features, not the speeds you’ll actually achieve or how well it will work with specific music software on a school network.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 Lite AS1102TL is another option for a small shared collection of files.

  • ASUSTOR lists Gigabit Ethernet and Btrfs and iSCSI snapshots for this model.
  • The transfer speeds quoted by the manufacturer are based on optimised laboratory tests and should not be assumed to reflect speeds on a school network.

Suitable products on Joybuy

Suitable products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Can I use a NAS as the working drive for my music software?

A NAS’s sharing features alone don’t guarantee that specific music software can edit active projects on a network drive without problems. Test a copy with your software and network, and have a fully transferred project folder ready for the hand-in.

How can I avoid missing samples when switching computers?

For Ableton Live, the manufacturer recommends using “Collect All and Save” to copy the audio files you’ve used into the project folder. This does not copy plug-ins, so also check the software, plug-ins and licences on the second computer. Other music software has its own export instructions.

Is RAID 1 enough to back up my work for the hand-in?

No. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security distinguishes RAID mirroring from a data backup because changes can be copied to the mirrored drive at the same time. Store an additional copy separately and check that you can restore a file from it.

Can I simply share recordings of my classmates on my NAS?

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. If voices are recognisable or the data is managed by the school, how it can be collected and shared depends on the specific purpose, who is responsible and whether there is an appropriate legal basis. Germany’s Data Protection Conference explains the requirements for consent; its guidance on school learning platforms applies to that specific context and not automatically to a personal NAS. Check the school’s rules before sharing and limit access to authorised people.