Who is a NAS suitable for?

Bands sharing project folders

When several members need to share music projects, a central storage location and clearly defined access permissions make things easier. Ableton recommends gathering all the required files with a Live Set when handing it over, while Synology outlines tools for sharing and backups.

Bands with a growing recording archive

If you want to keep recordings and older project versions, plan for usable storage and possible future drive expansion together. Synology points out that usable capacity depends on the drives and RAID configuration.

People responsible for irreplaceable recordings

If you manage the projects, plan for a separate backup and a tested recovery process. The BSI stresses that preparing to restore data is part of having a backup.

What should you look for when buying?

First, work out how much usable storage you need for projects and older versions, and plan for a separate backup. Then check how members will hand over projects and whether your existing network equipment can make use of faster connections.

Consideration What to look for Important for
Projects you can restore Plan for a separate backup destination and test the restore process in practice. If I need important project versions to be available again after they’ve been deleted or overwritten, I’ll plan for a separate backup and test the restore process. Around 33% of consumers put recovery first.
Room for archives and versions Check your current project library and expected growth; confirm usable capacity, drive compatibility and what’s included. If our recording library is growing, I want to allow for the storage needed for older versions rather than looking only at raw capacity. Around 27% of consumers prioritise archive storage.
Complete project handover Check your DAW’s requirements and set read and write permissions for active and archived folders. If several members work on projects, I need complete project folders and clearly defined write permissions. Around 27% of consumers prioritise secure handovers within the team.
Transferring large folders Check the connections on the NAS, work computers and other network equipment. If we often transfer large project folders, I want to know whether every part of the network supports the right connection. Around 13% of consumers prioritise these transfers.

Common buying pitfalls

  • Counting mirrored drives as two independent backups

    Mirroring also copies unwanted changes. That’s why the BSI distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup.

    Plan a backup that’s independent of your live NAS, and test restoring a project folder.

    A separate backup destination requires extra storage, time and someone to take responsibility for it.

  • Sharing only the Live Set instead of the complete project

    An Ableton Live Set may refer to audio files that aren’t available on the other computer.

    When handing over a project, use “Collect All and Save” if needed, then transfer the complete project folder. Also check that the other computer has the required plug-ins.

  • Assuming raw capacity is the same as usable storage

    Usable capacity depends on the drives and the configuration you choose; some NAS enclosures are sold without drives.

    Work out your archive needs and expected growth before checking the capacity, drive compatibility and what’s included with the specific model.

    Depending on the model, you may also need to budget for compatible drives and separate backup media.

  • Assuming a fast NAS port means the same speed at your workstation

    A fast connection on the NAS alone doesn’t tell you how quickly files will transfer across the whole connection.

    Compare the connections on your workstations and other network equipment with those on the NAS before deciding whether a faster interface will be useful.

    You may need extra network components to support the right connection.

Brands to consider

Synology

The DS224+ and DS225+ are two-bay models designed for centralised file storage. Synology describes DSM sharing and backup tools for the DS225+.

  • Synology lists 2.5 GbE, file sharing and backup features for the DS225+.
  • Synology recommends checking the compatibility list for your exact model before buying drives. Manufacturer throughput figures depend on the configuration.

QNAP

The TS-264-8G is a two-bay model for central project files, suited to groups that choose their own drives and have a compatible network connection.

  • QNAP lists two 2.5 GbE ports and two M.2 slots for this model.
  • According to QNAP, the TS-264-8G is supplied without drives, so you’ll need to budget for drives and a separate backup.

TerraMaster

The F2-425 is a two-bay model for shared storage with a synchronisation feature.

  • TerraMaster lists 4 GB RAM, 2.5 GbE and synchronisation for PCs and Macs.
  • Performance and noise figures are provided by the manufacturer, not based on independent tests in a music studio.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay model for groups planning to add more internal drives and use a compatible network connection.

  • UGREEN lists four SATA bays, along with one 10 GbE port and one 2.5 GbE port.
  • According to the German product page, hard drives are not included. Transfer speeds also depend on the rest of your network equipment.

NAS enclosures at Joybuy

This selection at Joybuy includes NAS enclosures with four or eight drive bays, for shared project archives and extra room to plan for more storage.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS

A good fit for a group planning a shared archive with four internal drive bays.

Four drive bays and two 2.5 GbE ports.

The product description limits drive installation to Synology drives.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS

A good fit for a group planning eight internal drive bays for a shared archive.

Eight drive bays and two built-in 2.5 GbE ports; 10 GbE is optional.

The product description mentions shared folders and team access.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID 1 replace a backup of our recordings?

No. The BSI distinguishes drive mirroring from data backup, because deletions, for example, also affect mirrored data. Plan a separate backup and test restoring your files.

How do we hand an Ableton Live project over to another member?

In Ableton Live, a Set may simply refer to the files it uses. When handing it over, use “Collect All and Save” if needed, transfer the complete project folder and separately check that the other computer has the required plug-ins.

What else should we budget for when buying a NAS enclosure?

Check what’s included and whether the drives are compatible with the specific model. QNAP and UGREEN state that the TS-264-8G and NASync DXP4800 Plus respectively are supplied without hard drives. You’ll also need a separate backup destination for an independent backup.

Do data protection rules apply if we store rehearsal recordings or members’ files on the NAS?

Yes, if the group processes personal data. According to the European Data Protection Board, audio recordings may count as personal data if they identify individuals. The Rhineland-Palatinate data protection authority also points out that the GDPR applies to associations processing such data. The group must determine the appropriate legal basis and safeguards for its specific use, based on the level of risk. Buying a NAS does not, in itself, mean that consent is required for every music file.