Who can benefit from a NAS?

A team sharing a recipe folder

If you regularly read or edit recipes on several devices, a central folder can help you avoid scattered copies of files. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) describes how access permissions for network drives can be tailored to users’ needs.

People responsible for restoring recipes

If you need to retrieve older versions or documents deleted by mistake, plan for a separate backup and a recovery process in addition to NAS storage. The BSI points out that RAID mirroring is no substitute for a backup.

A studio with different access permissions

If some team members should only be able to read recipes while others need to edit them, separate accounts and appropriately assigned permissions can help. Where personal data is involved, you should consider technical and organisational measures suited to the level of risk, as described by the Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information.

What should you look for when choosing one?

First, work out whether several people regularly need to use a shared folder. Then compare recovery options, access permissions, and the effort involved in setup and backup.

What matters What to look for when buying Who will find this particularly important?
Shared access Check shared folders, supported devices and how recipe files are actually edited in practice. When several of us edit recipes on different devices, I want one shared folder instead of scattered copies. Around 33% of consumers put shared access first.
Recovery Check for support for previous file versions, a separate backup destination and a tested recovery process. If we might need an older recipe version after accidentally overwriting it, a separate, tested backup matters to me. Around 27% of consumers prioritise recovery.
Access permissions Check account management and folder permissions; find out whether the documents contain personal data. In a studio where people have different roles, some should only be able to read recipes; I want to assign write access selectively. Around 27% of consumers prioritise controlled access.
Effort and equipment Check what’s included, which drives are compatible, usable capacity, the backup destination and the network ports available separately. If the storage is mainly for recipe documents, I want to keep an eye on setup time and any extra equipment needed. Around 13% of consumers prioritise keeping day-to-day running simple.

Common mistakes when choosing a NAS

  • Assuming mirroring is a complete backup

    With RAID mirroring, changes are made to the mirrored drives at the same time. That’s why the BSI does not consider mirroring a data backup.

    Plan a separate copy and test that you can restore recipe files from it.

  • Giving every studio member write access to every archive

    Unnecessary write permissions can make it easier for recipes to be changed by mistake. The BSI recommends permissions based on actual needs, which can be adjusted later.

    Keep active working folders separate from archives, and assign read and write permissions according to each person’s role.

  • Assuming the number of bays tells you the usable storage capacity

    A NAS enclosure and the storage media it needs should be checked separately. You’ll also need to plan for an additional backup destination.

    Check exactly what’s included, which drives are compatible, and the usable capacity rather than just the advertised capacity.

NAS manufacturers to consider

Synology

The manufacturer describes the DS223j as suitable for file sharing and collaboration in small teams.

  • Synology lists Drive and, from DSM 7.2, Btrfs snapshots for the DS223j.
  • Manufacturer claims are no substitute for independent performance testing; snapshots are also no substitute for a separate backup.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model whose ports and features can be checked against your existing workflow.

  • QNAP lists a Gigabit Ethernet port, USB and two drive bays.
  • It has 2 GB of memory, which cannot be upgraded. The specifications alone don’t tell you whether it’s suitable for a particular number of people working at the same time.

ASUSTOR

The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay alternative, provided its network port suits your existing network and the volume of file traffic.

  • ASUSTOR lists 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet and 1 GB of memory for the AS1102T.
  • According to ASUSTOR, the stated transfer rates are based on optimised laboratory tests and aren’t measurements taken in a studio.

TerraMaster

The F2-212 is described in the manufacturer’s datasheet as suitable, among other things, for backing up documents.

  • The datasheet lists a two-bay device with 1 GB of memory.
  • Manufacturer claims about protection against data loss are no substitute for a tested backup plan.

Joybuy products

Similar products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

Does a NAS with two mirrored hard drives replace a recipe backup?

No. According to the German Federal Office for Information Security, changes are applied simultaneously with RAID mirroring, so it won’t protect you from accidental overwriting or malware. Plan a separate backup and check that you can restore files from it.

How do I set up a shared recipe folder effectively?

Decide who can read files and who can edit them, and make sure the recipes you want to back up are actually stored in the shared folder. The German Federal Office for Information Security describes adjustable, needs-based permissions for network drives.

What else should I plan for besides the NAS enclosure?

Check whether compatible drives are included, which storage media work with the model, and how you’ll set up and manage a separate backup.

What ongoing maintenance does a shared NAS need?

Decide who will manage access permissions, updates, backups and recovery. QNAP lists a standard two-year warranty for the TS-233; check the terms of the specific offer separately.

Does the GDPR apply to recipe documents in a German studio?

If the documents contain personal data, data protection requirements apply, including technical and organisational measures appropriate to the level of risk. The Federal Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information describes these requirements. The recipe content alone does not provide a blanket answer for every NAS.