Who needs a NAS switch for their studio

Studios working with large shared files

If you transfer large files between a NAS and workstations, check the Ethernet speed at both ends. The specifications from TP-Link Germany and QNAP show which port options are available, not the actual speed of your file transfers.

Growing shared studios

Count your NAS, workstations and uplink before choosing the number of ports. For example, the TP-Link TL-SG105-M2 and TL-SG108-M2 have five and eight 2.5GbE ports respectively.

Studios with separate user groups

If you want to keep user groups separate, VLAN support on the specific switch is important. The rest of your network equipment must also be configured accordingly. Zyxel Networks lists VLAN as a configurable feature on one of its switch models.

What to look for when buying

Consideration What to check before buying Who should prioritise it
Suitable speed Check the RJ45 speeds of your NAS, workstations and the switch ports in use: 1GbE, 2.5GbE or 10GbE. If you transfer large files between a NAS and workstations, the connections along that route should be compatible. Around 36 % of consumers put suitable transfer speeds first.
Enough ports Count your NAS, workstations and uplink, then decide how many ports you need. If several workstations need a wired connection to the NAS and network at the same time, you’ll need to account for all the connections. Around 29 % of consumers prioritise having enough ports.
Network separation and management Check whether the specific model supports VLANs and whether the rest of your network equipment can be configured accordingly. If user groups or devices need separate networks, the right VLAN configuration matters more than simple plug-and-play setup. Around 21 % of consumers prioritise targeted network separation.
Quiet, straightforward operation Check the model’s fan specifications, mounting options and management type. If the switch will sit in your workspace and needs to run without complicated setup, noise and management requirements are important factors. Around 14 % of consumers prioritise quiet, straightforward operation.

An unmanaged model may be enough for simple connections, but it won’t replace a targeted VLAN configuration. According to the Synology Knowledge Center, LACP must be enabled on the switch for dynamic 802.3ad link aggregation. Also check the bond mode on your specific NAS.

Common mistakes when choosing a NAS switch

  • Comparing the switch speed alone

    A 2.5 or 10 Gbit/s port won’t make a slower NAS or workstation connection any faster. Check the speeds of your NAS, key workstations and the switch ports in use together.

    Depending on your existing setup, you may need compatible network adapters or updated cabling.

  • Forgetting the uplink when counting ports

    Your NAS, workstations and uplink each need a port. Count all the connections you’ll need at the same time, and only allow for extra ports if you’re planning to expand.

    Choosing a model with too few ports could mean replacing the switch or adding another network connection later.

  • Confusing unmanaged switches with configurable network separation

    Unmanaged models such as the NETGEAR MS305 are designed for simple connections. Planned VLANs require suitable configurable features and settings across the rest of your network.

    If you only realise later that you need network separation, you may have to replace the switch with a configurable model.

Key brands to consider

TP-Link

TP-Link Germany offers basic Gigabit models as well as desktop switches with five or eight 2.5GbE ports.

  • The TL-SG105 has five Gigabit ports. According to TP-Link Germany, the TL-SG105-M2 and TL-SG108-M2 have five and eight 2.5GbE ports respectively.
  • Port specifications alone don’t guarantee any particular NAS file transfer speed or VLAN management. Check the features of the specific model.

NETGEAR

NETGEAR describes the MS305 as an unmanaged desktop switch with five 2.5GbE RJ45 ports.

  • NETGEAR lists plug-and-play setup, a fanless design and mounting options for the MS305.
  • This is an unmanaged model, so don’t choose it on port speed alone if you want to set up VLANs.

QNAP

According to QNAP, the QNAP QSW-2104-2T-R2 supports different connection speeds.

  • QNAP lists four 2.5GbE and two 10GbE RJ45 ports, plus a fanless plug-and-play design.
  • This is an unmanaged model. Check whether your NAS or uplink can actually use the 10GbE port, and whether you need VLAN management.

Joybuy products for NAS and studio use

The models below range from Gigabit switches to manageable options for VLANs. Compare port speeds with your devices’ connections and, where needed, check PoE, SFP and power supply requirements.

Ubiquiti UniFi Flex 2.5G PoE, 8-port managed switch

Ubiquiti UniFi Flex 2.5G PoE, 8-port managed switch, PoE++, 10GbE uplink, white

A good fit if your NAS and workstations have compatible 2.5GbE connections and you want to set up VLANs.

Specifications include eight 2.5GbE RJ45 ports, VLAN support and a 10GbE SFP+ uplink.

A power adapter is not included. A 10GbE RJ45 PoE+++ input is listed as an alternative power supply; available PoE power depends on the power source.

View at Joybuy
D-Link DGS-1005P/E, 5-port Gigabit switch with PoE+

D-Link DGS-1005P/E, 5-port Gigabit switch with 4 PoE+ ports

An option if your NAS and other devices use Gigabit Ethernet and you need additional PoE+ ports.

This unmanaged model has five Gigabit ports, four of which are PoE+ ports with a total power budget of 60 W, and a fanless metal casing.

This model is not listed as supporting targeted VLAN configuration.

View at Joybuy
D-Link DGS-1210-10/E, smart managed Gigabit switch

D-Link DGS-1210-10/E, smart managed Gigabit switch

A good fit if you want to connect several Gigabit devices and need VLAN management or a compatible LACP configuration.

Specifications include eight Gigabit RJ45 ports and two SFP slots, as well as VLAN and LACP features. It also has a fanless design.

For dynamic 802.3ad link aggregation, the NAS mode and switch configuration must be compatible. The Synology Knowledge Center states that LACP must be enabled on the switch for this mode.

View at Joybuy
TP-Link TL-SG105PE, 5-port Gigabit smart switch with PoE+

TP-Link TL-SG105PE, 5-port Gigabit smart switch with 4 PoE+ ports

A good option if your devices use Gigabit Ethernet and you need VLAN features or PoE+ ports.

The switch has five Gigabit ports, four PoE+ ports with a total power budget of 65 W, and VLAN support. A fanless design and desktop and wall mounting are also listed.

The Ethernet ports are Gigabit ports, so check that this speed is sufficient for your NAS and workstations.

View at Joybuy
D-Link DGS-1100-08PV2, 8-port Gigabit smart switch with PoE

D-Link DGS-1100-08PV2, 8-port Gigabit smart switch with PoE

Suitable for several Gigabit devices if you also need VLAN configuration or PoE for connected devices.

The product specifications list eight Gigabit ports, VLAN support and a total PoE budget of 64 W. Fanless operation and web management are also described.

The combined power consumption of your PoE devices must stay within the stated 64 W budget.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does my router also need to support 2.5GbE?

Not for every connection between a NAS and workstation: what matters is the connections along the relevant route through the switch. Check the router uplink separately if that traffic needs to pass through the router. A 2.5GbE port on the switch doesn’t guarantee the same speed across every network route.

Do I have to use link aggregation with a NAS?

No, link aggregation isn’t necessary for every NAS connection. If you want to use it, check the LAN ports and bond mode on your specific NAS. According to the Synology Knowledge Center, dynamic 802.3ad mode requires LACP to be enabled on the switch. Adaptive Load Balancing doesn’t require this switch support.

What should I check about placement and running costs?

Check whether the specific model has a fan, what power supply is included and which mounting options are available. Manufacturers list fanless models; to compare annual electricity costs, you’ll need comparable power consumption figures.

What does the CE mark tell me about a switch?

The CE mark is a conformity marking for which the manufacturer is responsible; it isn’t an independent assessment of network performance. When monitoring the market for affected products, the Bundesnetzagentur checks, among other things, that the CE marking is correct, the product can be identified and the manufacturer’s information is accurate.

How should I dispose of an old switch?

In Germany, waste electrical equipment must be collected separately. The Umweltbundesamt lists local collection points that generally accept old devices free of charge. If your studio equipment is used for business, check the terms of the specific return route.