Who is a NAS suitable for?

A video library that needs space

If you’re backing up a large or growing video collection, plan your usable capacity based on the drives and storage configuration. Synology, QNAP and UGREEN all point out that drive configuration and compatibility are important when choosing a NAS.

A video team working together

If several people access videos from a shared workstation or shared folders, it’s important to set up the right shares and access permissions. Synology describes shared access via SMB and the management of permissions, among other features.

An archive you may need to restore

If you need to be able to recover deleted or damaged videos, plan for a separate backup as well as the NAS, and test the recovery process. The Federal Office for Information Security recommends keeping backups away from your own premises, while Synology describes backing up to remote destinations.

What to consider when buying

First decide whether the NAS will only be used as a backup destination or whether you’ll access files directly from it. You can then work out the right capacity, network setup, access permissions and equipment for your needs.

Consideration What to check before buying Who should pay particular attention
Separate backup and recovery A separate or remote backup destination, versioning, a schedule and the option to test a restore. If I need to recover deleted or damaged videos, I’ll plan a copy that’s separate from the NAS. Around 25 % of consumers put recovery and separate backups first.
Usable capacity and room to grow Compare the size of your library, expected growth, number of bays, drive compatibility and usable space with your planned configuration. If my archive is growing, I’ll work out the available storage based on the drives installed and the storage configuration. Around 25 % of consumers prioritise capacity and room to grow.
Shared access and permissions Check the workstation’s file-sharing protocol, user accounts, folder permissions and intended workflow. If several people use the same folders, I’ll want to assign the right permissions for reading, editing and deleting files. Around 20 % of consumers prioritise controlled team access.
Transfer speeds at your workstation Consider the connections on both the NAS and workstation, as well as the entire network path between them. Don’t assume manufacturers’ figures guarantee the speed you’ll get with your own setup. If I often work with large files directly on the NAS, the entire network path to my workstation needs to be up to the task. Around 15 % of consumers prioritise fast video transfers.
What’s included and the equipment you need Check whether drives are included and whether you need any additional equipment for the planned network connection. If I want to account for all the components I’ll need, I’ll check whether drives and, if necessary, networking equipment are included. Around 15 % of consumers prioritise what’s in the box and the equipment they need.

Avoiding common buying mistakes

  • Treating RAID or snapshots as a complete backup plan

    RAID on a NAS and snapshots within a storage pool are not an independent, separate copy. If the NAS or storage pool is damaged, a backup on the same system could be affected too.

    Before buying the enclosure, decide where you’ll save a separate copy and how you’ll test that you can restore it.

    A separate backup destination needs its own storage space and must be included in your backup routine.

  • Assuming advertised raw capacity is the same as usable space

    The space available after configuring your drives and storage may differ from the advertised raw capacity. Synology points out that usable capacity depends on the drives installed and the RAID configuration.

    Calculate capacity based on the specific drives and storage configuration you plan to use, and allow for the expected growth of your video library.

    If you run out of space later, you may need to expand your setup with additional or larger compatible drives.

  • Assuming a fast NAS port means fast performance at your video-editing workstation

    A fast port on the NAS alone doesn’t guarantee the same throughput at your workstation. Its connection and the rest of the network path need to support it too. QNAP lists integrated 2,5-GbE ports on the TS-464; 10GbE is an optional upgrade for this model.

    Check the NAS, workstation and network path together, and consider whether you’ll edit files directly or mainly run backups in the background.

  • Assuming similarly named models or an enclosure-only product are identical complete packages

    COMPUTER BILD’s comparison lists the TerraMaster F2-425 and F2-425 Plus as separate models. QNAP describes the TS-464 as coming without drives, so a NAS enclosure won’t necessarily include the drives you need for your setup.

    Check the full model name, ports, number of bays and what’s included in the specific offer.

Key brands at a glance

Synology

The DS225+ is a two-bay option, while the DS925+ has four drive bays. Synology lists integrated 2,5-GbE and backup features for both models.

  • Synology describes shared file access via SMB, permission management and backups to external or remote destinations.
  • Check that the drives are compatible with the specific model. The manufacturer’s transfer figures don’t guarantee the throughput you’ll get at your workstation.

QNAP

The TS-464 is a four-bay NAS with two integrated 2,5-GbE ports, according to QNAP’s hardware specifications.

  • QNAP lists four SATA drive bays and an optional PCIe network upgrade.
  • The TS-464 is sold without HDDs, and 10GbE isn’t integrated. QNAP says snapshots depend on the storage pool in use.

TerraMaster

According to TerraMaster, the F2-425 is a two-bay option for centralised backups and file sharing, with a 2,5-GbE port.

  • The manufacturer lists several storage configurations for the F2-425.
  • The F2-425 and F2-425 Plus are separate models, so don’t assume they’re the same just because their names are similar.

UGREEN

The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay option. UGREEN lists one integrated 10-GbE port and one 2,5-GbE port.

  • These ports may be useful when planning large transfers, provided your workstation and network path can support them too.
  • Drives are sold separately. The manufacturer’s network specifications don’t guarantee the throughput you’ll get at a particular workstation.

Joybuy products

The NAS models below are suited to planning a growing video library with shared file access. Remember to factor in your planned drive configuration, network connection and a separate backup.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-bay NAS with dual 2.5GbE

Synology DiskStation DS925+ – 4-bay NAS, dual 2.5GbE

The four bays may be useful when planning for a growing video library. Check how much usable storage you’ll get with your chosen drive configuration.

The product name lists two 2.5-GbE ports and the option to expand to nine bays. Check that the drives you choose are compatible with this model.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-bay NAS with dual 2.5GbE and optional 10GbE

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ – 8-bay NAS, dual 2.5GbE, optional 10GbE

Eight drive bays give you more flexibility when planning your drive setup. The amount of storage available for videos depends on the drives you choose and how storage is configured.

The product name lists two 2.5-GbE ports and an optional 10GbE upgrade. Check that your workstation and the rest of your network path can support the connection you have in mind.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Does RAID replace a backup of your video library?

No. Depending on the configuration, RAID can improve availability if a drive fails, but it isn’t an independent backup. Keep a separate copy of the originals stored on your NAS and test that you can restore them.

Are snapshots enough to recover accidentally deleted videos?

Snapshots can give you access to an earlier state, but they don’t replace an independent copy outside the storage pool. QNAP points out that snapshots depend on the storage pool in use.

How do you set up backups after buying?

Decide which folders contain the working copies and where the NAS will back them up independently. Synology’s Hyper Backup supports backing up shared folders to remote Synology systems or C2 Storage. Then test an actual restore; the steps will depend on the system you choose.

What additional equipment should you plan for?

Check whether hard drives are included in the specific offer. QNAP describes the TS-464 as coming without HDDs, while drives for the UGREEN NASync DXP4800 Plus are sold separately. Depending on the network connection you want, you may also need additional networking equipment.

What about third-party films or personal data used at work?

Having a shared storage location doesn’t automatically give you the right to use any third-party films. Section 53(1) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows natural persons, subject to certain conditions, to make individual copies for private use, provided they are not for commercial purposes and the source is not obviously unlawful. Under subsection 6, such copies must not be distributed or used for public performances. Appropriate technical and organisational measures may be needed for personal data used at work; the BfDI describes safeguards against unauthorised access and accidental loss, for example. What applies in a particular case depends on the rights, the data and how they are used.