Who is a NAS archive suitable for?

Volunteer archive managers

If you organise irreplaceable scans locally, you should plan a backup and recovery process as well as how to store them. RAID mirroring alone will not protect you from accidental deletion or changes.

History societies working together

If several contributors need to use files, a clear folder structure and appropriate access permissions can help. If records contain information about living people, responsibilities and access need to be considered separately.

A growing scanning project

If you expect to add more photographs and documents, plan your drives, usable capacity and separate backup together. The capacity actually available also depends on the drives and RAID configuration.

What should you consider when choosing one?

First, decide who needs access to the scans, then work out your storage needs and separate backup arrangements. Next, check which features the specific model offers to support these tasks.

Priority What to check before buying Who is this especially important for?
Local access Local file sharing, user permissions and whether the services you need work without cloud storage. If I want to keep the archive available locally on the society’s network and set access according to people’s roles, access control is my main priority. Around 36% of consumers share this main concern.
Recovery A separate local backup, a suitable backup medium and a tested restore process. With irreplaceable scans, I want to be able to access the files again after a device problem or accidental deletion. Around 29% of consumers focus on making scans recoverable.
Collaboration User accounts, shared folders and, where relevant, model-specific requirements for snapshots. If several society members add or edit files, I need a shared filing system that’s easy to follow. Around 21% of consumers prioritise organised collaboration.
Capacity and future needs Existing data, expected growth, RAID setup, suitable drives and additional backup storage. If you expect to add more batches of scans, you’ll want to plan the storage you need and any future expansion together. Around 14% of consumers prioritise growth and keeping costs under control.

Common planning mistakes

  • Treating mirrored drives as two independent archives

    With RAID mirroring, changes are applied to both drives at the same time. The BSI explicitly distinguishes RAID from data backup.

    Use mirroring to help manage a drive failure, and keep a separate local copy for recovery. Test that you can restore files from it.

    A separate backup medium and regular restore tests require extra resources and time.

  • Counting raw capacity as usable archive space

    With mirroring, the combined capacity of the drives is not automatically available as usable storage. The drives and RAID configuration affect how much space is available.

    Plan based on the specific drives and RAID settings, and allow for expected growth before deciding on capacity.

    You’ll also need to choose suitable drives and, if necessary, plan for ways to expand capacity later.

  • Assuming cloud storage and an internet connection are the same thing

    Choosing not to use cloud storage doesn’t automatically mean that setup or individual sharing features won’t require internet access.

    Check the setup process and requirements for the features you want to use on the specific model.

Key NAS brands at a glance

Synology

The DS223 and DS225+ offer different points of comparison for local file storage and backup tasks; the features listed here apply to these models.

  • Synology lists Btrfs and snapshots for the DS223.
  • Synology lists 2.5GbE for the DS225+.
  • For the DS225+, Synology advises checking its compatibility list before buying drives. Check the features and drive options for the specific model.

QNAP

The TS-233 is a two-bay model with the connections and storage specifications listed by the manufacturer.

  • The manufacturer lists two SATA drive bays and one Gigabit Ethernet port.
  • The TS-233 is also listed with one USB 3.2 Gen 1 port and 2 GB of non-expandable memory.
  • These specifications apply to the TS-233; they do not confirm the features or performance of other QNAP models.

ASUSTOR

The LOCKERSTOR 2 Gen2 (AS6702T) is another two-bay model to compare if your workstations have more advanced networking.

  • ASUSTOR lists two 2.5GbE ports for this model.
  • Whether this is an advantage on your society’s network, and which local backup options are available, depends on your network and setup.

NAS enclosures at Joybuy

The following Joybuy listings include NAS enclosures with two, four and eight drive bays for local file storage and archives. Compare your actual storage needs with the features of each model, and remember to plan for a separate backup.

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS with four drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS925+ NAS, 4-Bay, Dual 2.5GbE

The four drive bays may be useful for a growing archive; check drive compatibility for this specific model before buying.

The listing states that it can be expanded to up to nine bays and has two 2.5GbE ports. According to the listing description, only Synology-brand drives are compatible.

View at Joybuy
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS with eight drive bays

Synology DiskStation DS1825+ NAS, 8-Bay, Dual 2.5GbE

This model may be worth considering for a large archive with substantial storage needs; match your capacity plan to your drives and backup medium.

The listing mentions an optional 10GbE upgrade and capacity of up to 360 TB. The stated capacity expansion requires a compatible Synology expansion unit.

View at Joybuy
Synology DS225+ NAS with two drive bays

Synology DS225+ NAS, 2-Bay, Diskless Desktop Enclosure

This two-bay enclosure may be suitable if its features fit your archive and backup plan. The listing mentions user accounts and shared folders for collaboration.

The product title lists an Intel Celeron J4125, 2 GB DDR4 RAM expandable to 6 GB, 2.5GbE and Gigabit LAN. According to the title, this is an enclosure without drives. RAID is not a substitute for a separate backup.

View at Joybuy

Frequently asked questions

Is RAID 1 enough to back up our village history archive?

No. In its data backup guidance, 2023 edition, the BSI distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup: overwrites and changes can also be mirrored. Keep a separate local copy and test that you can restore files from it.

How should we get started with setup and ongoing maintenance?

Start by listing your existing files and responsibilities. Set up user accounts and a clear folder structure, then plan backups and restore tests. Check whether the setup or feature you want requires internet access on the specific model; not using cloud storage does not automatically rule out every internet connection.

What should we plan for in addition to the NAS enclosure?

Allow for suitable internal drives and a separate backup medium. If a listing describes the product as an enclosure without drives, the drives are not included in the stated contents; check the listing details for the specific model.

Can historical scans containing information about living people be made accessible to all society members?

There is no one-size-fits-all answer. If personal data is processed, you need to clarify who is responsible and who is authorised to access it. Germany’s Data Protection Conference explains the obligations that apply to society employees who have access to this kind of data; whether a specific collection can be processed or published depends on its content and purpose.