Guardians of irreplaceable scans
You want to be able to restore original scans and earlier versions, and plan to keep a backup separate from the NAS.
A two-bay NAS may be enough for a growing village history archive, provided its usable capacity covers the existing collection and expected growth. A four-bay model gives you more options for configuring the drives inside. The German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup, so plan for a separate copy as well and test that you can restore it. A fast network connection will only help if the rest of your setup can support it.
You want to be able to restore original scans and earlier versions, and plan to keep a backup separate from the NAS.
You regularly take in extensive village histories, photos or records, so you need to plan usable capacity, future growth and drive bays together.
Several people add scans or work in project folders, so shared storage and different levels of access are important to the way you work.
Start by comparing usable capacity with expected growth. Whatever the number of drive bays, you’ll still need a separate backup.
| Priority | What to check before buying | Who is this important to? |
|---|---|---|
| Restoring files | Plan for a backup separate from the NAS and make sure you can restore a project folder. | A separate copy is especially important if you need to recover irreplaceable scans after a fault. Around 28% of consumers put recoverability first. |
| Usable capacity and growth | Take stock of your collection, scan formats and expected additions, then compare your planned drives and storage configuration. | If you have extensive project folders, you’ll want room for expected growth too. Around 22% of consumers prioritise usable capacity and growth. |
| Shared storage | Test shared folders and workflows using a typical project folder. | If several people work with the same collections, everyone should be able to access the files from the workstations they need. Around 22% of consumers put collaboration first. |
| Access to archive material | Set user and folder permissions, and decide how you’ll handle originals and working copies. | If you don’t want every contributor to be able to edit originals, different access levels are important. Around 17% of consumers prioritise access control. |
| Transferring large folders | Check the connections on the NAS, network and workstation together; if possible, test a representative folder. | If you regularly transfer large project folders, speed across the whole connection matters. Around 11% of consumers put transfer needs first. |
Mirroring copies changes to both drives at the same time, so it won’t protect you from accidental overwrites or malware.
Plan a backup outside the mirrored drives and test that you can restore files from it.
You’ll need to allow for extra storage and time to maintain your separate backup destination and run regular restore tests.
Your drives and storage configuration affect how much space is actually available for scan and project folders.
Take stock of your existing collection and expected growth before comparing specific drive configurations for a two- or four-bay NAS.
Depending on the usable capacity you’re aiming for, you may need to buy additional compatible drives.
The port alone won’t tell you how quickly a particular project folder will transfer. The network and workstation are part of the connection too.
Check the connections on all the devices involved and test a typical folder, rather than relying on an advertised peak speed alone.
These models have different specifications: TerraMaster lists 4 GB of RAM and a 2.5GbE port for the F2-425, compared with 8 GB DDR5 and two 5GbE ports for the F2-425 Plus.
Before buying, check the full model name and make sure it has the connections you actually need.
Two-bay models such as the DS225+ could suit a central storage setup. Synology also lists this model among its devices for Snapshot Replication.
The TS-264-8G is a two-bay option for shared project files and backup workflows.
The F2-425 is a two-bay option to consider when comparing drive configurations and network connections.
The AS5404T is a four-bay example for projects where internal drive configuration options and shared folders matter.
The NASync DXP4800 Plus is a four-bay example with several network connections, suited to growing collections and frequent transfers.
This selection includes NAS models with two, four and eight drive bays for centrally storing growing collections of scans and project files.
No image available
Four drive bays give you more flexibility when planning a setup for a growing collection. Usable capacity still depends on the drives and storage configuration.
Four bays; Dual 2.5GbE; expandable to up to nine bays; M.2 NVMe SSD caching. According to the product description, drive compatibility is limited to Synology drives.
No image available
Eight drive bays give you more options for planning how to store a large and growing collection internally.
Eight bays; Dual 2.5GbE; optional 10GbE upgrade. Check that your other network devices are compatible with the optional connection.
No image available
Two drive bays could be enough if the planned usable capacity covers your existing collection and expected growth.
Intel Celeron J4125 Quad-Core; 2 GB DDR4 RAM, expandable to 6 GB; 2.5GbE and Gigabit LAN; USB-A 3.0; RAID 0/1/JBOD. The enclosure is listed without drives. RAID mirroring is not a substitute for a separate backup.
No. The German Federal Office for Information Security explicitly distinguishes RAID mirroring from data backup: changes made at the same time won’t protect you from accidental overwrites or malware. Plan a separate copy and check that you can actually restore files from it.
Create shared project folders with suitable user permissions, and keep originals separate from editable files in a way that suits your workflow. Before uploading directly from a scanner, check which network destinations and login details it supports.
Allow for compatible drives, a separate backup destination and, where needed, network components. QNAP notes that the TS-264-8G is supplied without hard drives, as does UGREEN for the NASync DXP4800 Plus. The equipment you need will depend on your planned drive configuration.
Not simply because the photos are in the archive or look old. According to guidance from the State Commissioner for Data Protection and Freedom of Information of Rhineland-Palatinate, taking and publishing photos of people generally requires consent or another valid legal basis. Whether a particular photo can be published depends on the circumstances and any other rights that may apply.
Buying a NAS does not give you permission to destroy originals. The German Federal Archives distinguishes supplementary scanning from replacement scanning and sets out additional requirements for replacement scanning by federal authorities. This official guidance is not blanket permission for a village history society to destroy originals entrusted to it.