For voice recordings with multiple project versions, a NAS makes sense if you specifically need file versioning or snapshots and, where relevant, shared access. If you only use one computer and don't need these features, an external hard drive may be simpler. Either way, plan for a separate backup and test the restore process: the Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) recommends planning for data recovery and getting systems back up and running, while the Synology Knowledge Center points out that a snapshot stored on the NAS itself is no substitute for an independent backup.
Who is a NAS suitable for when storing voice recordings?
Editors with lots of project versions
If you regularly edit voice files, check whether you can restore earlier versions of the specific folder you use. The Synology Knowledge Center describes file versioning in Synology Drive; TerraMaster and ASUSTOR make their documented snapshot features dependent on specific system and file system requirements.
People responsible for irreplaceable recordings
For recordings that can't easily be recreated, you need a separate backup that you can actually use to restore the originals. The Federal Office for Information Security (BSI) recommends planning for data recovery, while the Synology Knowledge Center warns that data loss can still occur despite additional measures on the NAS.
Small teams with a shared archive
If several people need to store or edit material, it's important to have a clear shared storage location and appropriate access rights. The BSI describes access rights tailored to users' needs for network drives and archived project data.
What matters when you have multiple project versions?
First decide whether you need older file versions, an independent restore option or shared access for your team. These features can complement one another; if you only use one computer and don't need centralised access, an external hard drive may also be an option.
| What you need |
What to check before buying |
Who needs this? |
| Older project versions |
Check that versioning or suitable snapshots are available for the folder and file system in question. Check how long versions are kept and how to restore them; with Synology Drive, version control must be enabled for the team folder. |
If I need to go back to an earlier edit, I'll look for versioning that is enabled with a suitable retention period. Around 33% of consumers prioritise being able to restore specific earlier project versions. |
| Independent restore option |
Plan for a backup destination separate from the NAS and test data recovery regularly. A mirror or local snapshot on its own isn't an independent copy. |
When it comes to original recordings that are difficult to recreate, I need a separate way to restore them and want to test the process. Around 27% of consumers prioritise independent protection for their originals. |
| Shared team access |
Check that user and folder permissions suit the tasks involved and that write access to archived files can be restricted. Decide where team members should store their recordings. |
If several people work on the archive, I want to share files without everyone being able to change them by mistake. Around 20% of consumers prioritise managed team access. |
| Storage and transfer route |
Allow enough space for originals, versions, snapshots and additional copies. Check that all devices and network components involved in transferring files support the connections you plan to use. |
As my recording folders grow, I need enough usable storage and a suitable way to transfer files. Around 20% of consumers prioritise capacity and the transfer route. |
Common NAS backup mistakes
-
Confusing mirrored drives with an independent backup
A second drive in the NAS isn't a separate copy. If the device fails or its data is damaged, the mirrored copy could be affected too.
Set up a separate backup destination and test that you can restore the recordings you need from it.
Allow time and space for an additional backup drive and regular restore tests.
-
Assuming every backup includes all project versions
According to the Synology Knowledge Center, simply backing up the Synology Drive package isn't enough to back up the file versions created in it.
Check whether your particular backup method lets you restore the earlier versions you need, and test it with a file.
-
Assuming the enclosure, capacity and network specifications are all you need
QNAP states that the TS-264 is supplied without an HDD. Connection and lab-test figures don't automatically tell you how much usable storage you'll have or how fast your entire transfer route will be.
Check what's included, which drives are suitable and the connections on every device between the recording source and the NAS.
Remember to factor in drives, a separate backup destination and, where needed, suitable network components.
Examples of relevant NAS brands
Synology
The DiskStation DS225+ is an example of a two-bay NAS. Synology Drive and Hyper Backup serve different purposes when it comes to file versions and backups.
- According to the Synology Knowledge Center, you can retrieve file versions from a team folder if version control is enabled for that folder.
- According to Synology, simply backing up the Drive package won't preserve these file versions. Also check drive compatibility for the exact model and DSM version.
QNAP
The TS-264-8G is an example of a two-bay NAS with two 2.5GbE ports. QNAP documents snapshots and Qsync for different workflows.
- QNAP explains how to restore data to a snapshot state.
- According to QNAP, the TS-264 is supplied without an HDD. The Mac backup feature described on the Qsync page is a beta version, so don't assume it's a fully released feature for general use.
TerraMaster
The F2-425 is an example of a two-bay NAS for local storage. TerraMaster documents snapshots for shared folders.
- According to TerraMaster, you can schedule snapshots for shared folders.
- The documented snapshot feature requires BTRFS. Check the file system and system version for your specific setup.
ASUSTOR
The NIMBUSTOR 2 Gen2 (AS5402T) is an example of a two-bay NAS with two 2.5GbE ports and M.2 slots.
- ASUSTOR documents Snapshot Center for the AS54 series.
- According to ASUSTOR, volume snapshots require a Btrfs-formatted volume. Published speed figures are based on lab conditions and aren't a guarantee of the speed you'll get on your own transfer route.
Suitable products on Joybuy
Related products coming soon.
Frequently asked questions
Are RAID 1 or NAS snapshots already an independent backup?
No. A mirror or local snapshot isn't a substitute for a separate copy that you can restore from if the NAS fails. Set up a separate destination and test data recovery; the BSI recommends planning for systems to be brought back online and data to be restored.
How can I check whether I can restore an earlier edit?
Check whether your files are in a versioned folder or on a suitable snapshot volume, then test restoring an older file once everything is set up. With Synology Drive, version control must be enabled for the team folder in question.
Are hard drives included with the NAS?
It depends on the specific model and offer: QNAP explicitly states that the TS-264 is supplied without an HDD. Check what's included and that the drives are compatible with the exact device.
Can I simply copy other people's voice recordings or share them with my team in Germany?
There is no blanket permission to do so. Under certain conditions, section 201 of the German Criminal Code (StGB) covers recording another person's non-public spoken words without authorisation, as well as using or making available a recording made in this way. Whether a specific recording or act of sharing is authorised depends on the circumstances. For telephone conversations, the Data Protection Conference also points out that, as a rule, data protection law requires the consent of the other person on the call before it can be recorded.
What should I check about drives and updates before buying?
Check drive compatibility for the exact model and intended system version, what's included and which updates are available. Manufacturers' warranty information applies to the specific product and doesn't cover every retailer's offer or statutory rights.