A NAS is a good choice if you want to set up regular backups over your home network or add more computers later. For a single computer, a removable hard drive may be simpler, provided you remember to back up reliably by hand. The key is to choose a backup method that works with Windows or Mac, allow enough usable storage and keep an extra copy disconnected after backing up. Two mirrored NAS drives are not a substitute for this.
Which option is right for you?
Families who regularly back up their PCs
If you want to back up files regularly without using the cloud and restore earlier versions when needed, check that your operating system’s backup method works with the NAS or external drive. Microsoft Support describes File History as a way to back up personal files to an external drive or network location.
Families with irreplaceable files
If your photos, videos or documents are especially important, plan to keep another copy separately after backing up, as well as a backup you can access easily. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security explains that keeping backups separate helps protect against risks that can also affect an accessible backup destination.
Households looking for a simple set-up
If you only need to back up one computer for now, a removable hard drive may be a suitable alternative to setting up a NAS. Germany’s Federal Office for Information Security lists removable hard drives as an option for backing up personal data.
What should you consider when choosing?
First decide whether you’d rather have regular backups over your network or a simple copy that you can disconnect manually. Then check the backup method, storage capacity and restore process.
| What matters |
What to check before buying |
Who it matters to most |
| Everyday backups |
Windows: check that the network location works with your chosen backup method. Mac: check that the NAS supports Time Machine. Then test restoring a file. |
If I want to back up my family’s files regularly and restore them when needed, the destination needs to work with my operating system. Around 33% of consumers put a reliable backup routine first. |
| Separate additional copy |
Plan another destination and a process for backing up, disconnecting and restoring. Mirroring does not count as a separate copy. |
If my photos and documents are especially important, I want to disconnect a copy from the accessible system after backing up. Around 27% of consumers prioritise this extra protection against failure. |
| Usable storage capacity |
Allow for existing files and the backup versions you need. If you’re using mirrored drives, plan for the capacity of one drive and check what’s included and whether the drives are compatible. |
If I’ve built up a lot of files or want to keep previous backups, I need enough usable storage. Around 20% of consumers put capacity first. |
| Effort and set-up |
Compare the set-up and ongoing maintenance of a NAS with the manual backup routine required for an external drive. If you choose a NAS, check whether drives are included. |
If I’m only backing up one computer and want to keep set-up simple, a removable hard drive could be a good option. Around 20% of consumers place particular importance on keeping things straightforward. |
Common backup mistakes
-
Assuming mirroring or snapshots are a complete substitute for a separate backup
A copy on the same NAS remains accessible and is not a separately stored backup. It therefore doesn’t protect against the same risks as a drive that’s disconnected after backing up.
For particularly important data, plan another restorable copy on a different type of storage. Disconnect a dedicated offline drive after backing up.
You may need another storage device for a separate additional copy.
-
Adding together the capacity of both drives in a mirrored set-up
With two mirrored drives, their combined capacity isn’t available as usable storage for backup data.
Plan according to your chosen configuration and the backup versions you want to keep. Also check which drives are compatible with the NAS.
You may need larger or additional drives to get the usable capacity you want.
-
Assuming the NAS enclosure alone is a complete backup solution
A backup plan also needs to account for the drives required and, if necessary, another device for a separate copy.
Check exactly what’s included and allow for the same required backup capacity for both a NAS and an external hard drive.
Remember to allow for the drives and, if needed, a device for the additional copy.
NAS brands worth knowing
Synology
The DiskStation DS223j is a two-bay option for managing and backing up files locally. Synology also documents external backup destinations for its NAS devices.
- Synology lists Synology Drive and Btrfs snapshots from DSM 7.2 for the DS223j.
- Snapshots on the same device are not a substitute for a separate copy. Check that the specific device supports the feature you need and runs the required DSM version.
QNAP
The TS-233 is a two-bay option for a local home NAS.
- QNAP lists 2 GB of non-expandable memory, a Gigabit Ethernet port and a USB 3.2 Gen 1 port for the TS-233.
- These ports alone don’t tell you how long a backup will take. Check the features of your chosen backup software separately.
ASUSTOR
The Drivestor 2 AS1102T is a two-bay option for backing up PCs over your home network.
- ASUSTOR lists PC and USB backup, as well as a 2.5 Gigabit Ethernet port.
- The port alone doesn’t guarantee a corresponding speed increase on your existing home network. Check that the backup feature you need is supported before buying.
TerraMaster
TerraMaster describes the F2-212 as a NAS for home use, data backup and file sharing.
- This model combines local storage with file sharing.
- Check that it supports the Windows or Mac backup method you need, and confirm what’s included in the specific offer.
NAS deals at Joybuy
This selection of NAS devices is for households looking to set up a local backup destination on their home network. Before buying, check that the number of drive bays and compatibility match your storage needs.
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS925+ 4-Bay NAS
A local backup destination to consider if you need four drive bays and may want to expand later.
Product details list two 2.5GbE ports and the option to expand to up to nine bays. Drives need to be installed; according to the product details, only Synology-brand drives are compatible.
View at Joybuy
No image available
Synology DiskStation DS1825+ 8-Bay NAS
A local NAS backup destination to consider if you want to include several devices or store a larger amount of data.
Product details list eight drive bays, two 2.5GbE ports, optional 10GbE and support for up to 360TB. Compatible drives need to be installed before use.
View at Joybuy
Frequently asked questions
Can I back up a Windows PC to a NAS without using the cloud?
Yes. According to Microsoft Support, File History can back up personal files to a configured network location. Check which folders it includes and test restoring a file; this doesn’t automatically mean you have a full system backup.
Can Time Machine use a NAS?
Yes, if the NAS supports Time Machine over a network protocol listed by Apple, such as SMB or AFP. Apple Support recommends checking compatibility and set-up instructions for the specific model.
Are two mirrored hard drives enough as my only backup?
No, not if you also want to protect against losing the accessible copy on your NAS. Plan another copy on a different destination, and disconnect a dedicated offline drive after backing up.
What should I plan for before buying an additional backup device?
Check whether drives are included with the specific NAS offer, whether you need another device for a separate copy and how you’ll test the restore process. An external hard drive can serve as an additional destination that you disconnect after backing up.
Does the GDPR automatically apply to a personal family backup?
Not simply because you’ve bought a NAS. The European Data Protection Supervisor explains that the GDPR does not apply to processing by an individual solely for personal or family activities. Whether a different use falls under this exception depends on its actual purpose.