Which scanner is right for you?

If you’re digitising delicate clippings

If you’re working with old newspaper, check the condition of each piece and only place it on a flatbed scanner if you can do so without applying damaging pressure. The Library of Congress and the Coordination Office for the Preservation of Written Cultural Heritage both stress the importance of careful storage and handling. Not every fragile original is suitable for the scanner glass.

If you collect larger clippings

If important pieces don’t fit entirely on A4, compare both dimensions of the largest original with the usable scan area. Canon Germany lists the CanoScan LiDE 400’s scan area as 216 × 297 mm, while Plustek lists the OpticSlim 1180 as supporting originals up to 29.7 × 43.1 cm.

If you’re building a searchable group archive

If you want to find texts again later, your group needs a workflow for OCR and PDF that you can check. Plustek lists OCR software for the OpticSlim 1180, while HP describes searchable PDFs for the ScanJet Pro 2600 f1. Test the results with typical clippings, including those with small or faded print.

What should you look for when buying?

Compact A4 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: the loose clippings you regularly scan fit on the usable area of the specific device and can be placed on it safely, one at a time.

Bear in mind: Larger originals may need to be captured in several scans, and you’ll need to position each clipping by hand.

A3 flatbed scanner

A good fit if: many of your clippings are larger than A4 and you want to capture them in a single scan, within the stated scan area. Plustek lists the OpticSlim 1180 as supporting originals up to 29.7 × 43.1 cm.

Bear in mind: The larger glass bed takes up more space and won’t solve problems with brittle paper or questions about suitable software.

Flatbed scanner with an additional feeder

A good fit if: you also regularly have stacks of suitable loose documents to scan alongside your clippings.

Bear in mind: The advertised feeder speeds for the HP ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 apply to documents going through the feeder, not to delicate clippings placed on the flatbed one at a time.

Buying priority What to look for Who is this especially important to?
Protecting originals Check the condition and make sure each piece can be handled safely; consider another way to capture fragile or bound items. When we digitise old clippings, placing them on the scanner shouldn’t put them under any extra strain. Around 36% of consumers would name protecting originals as their top buying priority.
Legibility and text search Check the OCR and PDF output. Test-scan something with small print, then check the image and searchable text separately. For our group archive, we need to find small or faded print again later and be able to check the recognised text. Around 29% of consumers would make legibility and text search their main priority.
Capturing larger clippings in full Compare the width and height of your largest original, including any margin you want to keep, with the usable scan area. If a clipping doesn’t fit on A4, I want to capture it in one scan if possible and keep its edges intact. Around 21% of consumers would name capturing larger formats in full as their main priority.
Shared workflow Check the buttons and software profiles, file formats and drivers. Agree how the group will store and back up files. When several people are scanning, the settings and filing system should be easy to follow. We only need an additional feeder for suitable stacks. Around 14% of consumers would name a shared workflow as their top buying priority.

Common misconceptions

  • “A3” means every large clipping will fit

    The format name alone doesn’t tell you whether an original will fit on the usable scan area in both dimensions. You’ll also need space for any margin you want to preserve.

    Measure a typical large clipping and compare its width and height with the scan area of the specific model.

    If your originals are oversized, scanning them in sections can mean extra time spent on partial scans or recapturing them.

  • The feeder speed also applies to delicate clippings

    The advertised batch and duplex features of the HP ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 apply to documents fed through the machine. They don’t describe the careful scanning of clippings placed on the flatbed one at a time.

    Only factor in the additional feeder if you regularly have a substantial number of suitable loose sheets to scan. For fragile originals, handling is what matters.

    An additional feeder won’t automatically save time when you’re handling originals one at a time.

  • OCR automatically makes your archive accurate and ready to publish

    OCR and PDF features don’t guarantee error-free searchable text. Technical capture and the rights to share or make content publicly available are also separate matters.

    Test the searchable text with typical clippings and check the legal basis for the intended use before sharing or publishing anything.

    Your group should allow time to check the text and, where necessary, clarify usage rights.

Key brands to consider

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is a compact A4 flatbed option for clippings that fit on the scan area and can be placed on it one at a time.

  • Canon Germany lists a scan area of 216 × 297 mm and two PDF buttons.
  • Larger pieces won’t fit in a single scan, and the model specifications don’t show how well the scanner recognises difficult newspaper text.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is a compact A4 option with a stand and document-editing software.

  • Epson lists four one-touch buttons, as well as features to enhance text and reduce show-through from printing on the reverse.
  • These are manufacturer claims, so your group should test how well they work with your own clippings. The A4 scan area limits what you can do with larger originals.

Plustek

The OpticSlim 1180 is an A3 flatbed option for larger loose clippings and a PDF and OCR workflow.

  • Plustek lists a scan area of up to 29.7 × 43.1 cm and OCR software.
  • Claims about recognition quality come from the manufacturer and don’t replace a test scan. The larger design also needs more space.

HP

The ScanJet Pro 2600 f1 combines a flatbed with a feeder for suitable loose documents.

  • HP lists a 60-sheet feeder and searchable PDFs.
  • Advertised feeder speeds apply to documents going through the feeder and can’t be applied to delicate clippings placed on the flatbed one at a time.

Suitable products at Joybuy

Related products will be available soon.

Frequently asked questions

What resolution should our group use?

Choose a setting based on a typical clipping and check the small print in the finished image. The German Federal Archives generally digitises originals at 400 ppi at their original size. This describes the Federal Archives’ practice; it is neither a general legal minimum nor a guarantee of OCR accuracy.

Can very brittle or bound newspapers go on a flatbed scanner?

Not in every case. The Coordination Office for the Preservation of Written Cultural Heritage recommends flatbed scanners for collections of loose sheets and warns against putting pressure on bindings. For fragile originals, your group should consider a gentler supervised method of capture and suitable handling.

Is owning the clippings enough to put them in a public online collection?

No. Owning the paper clippings doesn’t automatically give you permission to publish them. Under § 53 UrhG, copies for personal use are permitted only in certain circumstances; as a rule, these copies must not be distributed or used for public performances. The archive provision in § 60f UrhG applies only to the institutions named there and subject to the relevant conditions. It doesn’t apply simply because a group calls its collection an archive. The relevant source is the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice, Laws Online.

Does § 49 UrhG mean any newspaper clipping can be shared freely?

No. Under certain conditions, § 49 UrhG covers individual articles on current political, economic or religious topics, provided there is no reservation of rights. Further conditions may apply, and remuneration may be due. This doesn’t amount to blanket permission to create a digital group collection. The relevant source is the Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice, Laws Online.

What work remains after you’ve bought the scanner?

Allow time to place each clipping on the scanner, check the results, correct any OCR errors, use consistent file names and make back-up copies. Also check that the right drivers and software work with your group’s computer. Canon advises checking compatibility with your operating system for the CanoScan LiDE 400.