Owners of delicate magazines
If you want to preserve an old binding or brittle pages, consider taking a picture from above so you do not have to press the magazine against a glass plate.
If an old magazine cannot be opened flat without forcing it, an overhead scanner is the more obvious choice. A flatbed scanner may be suitable for a few robust pages up to A4. Check the page size, condition of the binding and file format you need. Automatic dewarping and OCR do not replace checking the scans or verifying usage rights.
If you want to preserve an old binding or brittle pages, consider taking a picture from above so you do not have to press the magazine against a glass plate.
If you need the text, illustrations and larger pages for your project, make sure the capture area covers the whole page, including the margins.
If you want to search for passages later in a PDF, check the OCR results carefully, especially for historical print, and compare important passages with the page image.
Suitable if: a bound or delicate magazine should not be laid flat.
Things to consider: check the alignment and lighting. According to the manufacturer, dewarping features do not guarantee flawless capture of the gutter or OCR results.
Suitable if: a few sturdy pages can be laid on the scan bed without damaging pressure.
Things to consider: A4 devices cannot capture larger pages in full; repositioning pages repeatedly can make the process take longer.
Suitable if: you already have loose sheets that are suitable for feeding through the scanner.
Things to consider: An intact, bound magazine would need to be taken apart first, changing the original. CZUR also points this out in its guidance on magazine scanners.
| Purchasing criteria | What to look for | Who is it important for? |
|---|---|---|
| Preserving the magazine and its binding | Check the opening angle and condition; after taking a picture from above, inspect the gutter and page edges. | If my magazine is brittle, I do not want to have to press it against a glass plate. Around 36% of consumers put preserving the original first. |
| Page size and image detail | Measure the largest page, including the margins. Canon gives the CanoScan LiDE 400 a maximum scan area of 216 × 297 mm. | I need the whole page, including illustrations and margins, for my project. Around 29% of consumers prioritise page size and image detail. |
| Searchable text | Test a sample page using your own material and compare the recognised text with the image. CZUR notes that the Aura Pro OCR has a limitation for MacBook M2 users. | If I want to find passages again later, I need searchable files and must check important recognition results. Around 21% of consumers prioritise text search. |
| Time and effort for a one-off project | Consider the number of pages, their condition, available scanning options and software compatibility with your computer. | For a few suitable pages, I want to keep the equipment and effort involved manageable. Around 14% of consumers prioritise keeping the work involved in their project to a minimum. |
A large capture area or a dewarping feature does not prove that every curved page will be captured flawlessly, right up to the gutter and edges.
Measure the original and check a sample double-page spread right up to the inner and outer edges.
Sheet-fed scanners require loose pages. Taking the binding apart changes the original and is not an equivalent solution if you want to preserve it.
If the magazine is intact and worth preserving, choose a capture method that does not require you to take it apart.
OCR can recognise text so you can search it, but historical print may need correcting afterwards. The German Research Foundation notes that OCR for historical print still needs improvement.
Keep the page image and use it to check important names, dates and quotations.
The law distinguishes between use in teaching and copies made for personal use. A school project alone does not automatically allow you to publish an entire magazine online.
Before sharing, check the specific content, extent and intended audience against the relevant requirements in §§ 53 and 60a UrhG.
According to the manufacturer, the Aura Pro and ET series are overhead scanners for bound originals; features vary between models.
According to the manufacturer, the VK16 is designed for bound or larger originals, with overhead capture and a book mode.
The CanoScan LiDE 400 is an A4 flatbed scanner for originals that can be laid flat on the scan bed.
The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed device for photographs and document pages that can be laid flat on the scan bed.
According to the manufacturer, the Desk models are document cameras and book scanners; other IRIScan models are handheld scanners.
Yes, if the pages you need fit on the scan bed and the specific magazine can be opened far enough without damaging pressure. Canon gives the CanoScan LiDE 400 a maximum scan area of 216 × 297 mm.
First check the binding and condition of the pages, then take a test scan without forcing the magazine flat. Check the gutter, edges and legibility. The German Research Foundation advises taking the relevant conservation requirements into account for digitisation projects; this is not blanket approval to use any device on every school magazine.
No. OCR-enabled devices can create searchable files, but the German Research Foundation notes that historical print still needs improvement and corrections. In particular, check names, dates and quotations against the page image.
For the exact model, check which scanning and OCR software it needs, whether it works with your computer and whether you need any additional accessories. Canon provides a German support page for the LiDE 400 with downloads and manuals.
Not automatically. Under certain conditions, § 60a UrhG generally permits the use of up to 15 per cent of a published work for non-commercial teaching purposes and for the groups of people specified by law. Subsection 2 sets out exceptions, including for individual contributions from specialist or academic journals. § 53 UrhG contains separate rules on personal use and specifically restricts the reproduction of a journal that is substantially complete. You must therefore check separately whether scanning the specific magazine, the amount reproduced and any planned publication are permitted; being “old” or part of a “school project” is not enough on its own.