Students who aren’t sure which film format they have
First, work out whether you have negatives or slides, and identify the format. Only then can you choose the right scanner holder.
The right scanner for old portrait films depends first on whether you have negatives or slides, and on the film format. Choosing the right holder matters more than a high advertised resolution. For just a few images, a standalone device that saves directly to JPEG can simplify the process. If you want to edit the images on a computer or scan other film formats, look for a suitable film scanner or a flatbed scanner with a transparency unit. If people are recognisable in the portraits, also check how and with whom you’re allowed to share or publish the images.
First, work out whether you have negatives or slides, and identify the format. Only then can you choose the right scanner holder.
If you want to view portraits without a lengthy set-up and save them for a presentation, a standalone scanning workflow could be a good fit.
If you want to check and correct the images on a computer, or save an additional editable file, be sure to factor in the computer and software workflow.
Start by identifying the film type and format. Then decide whether saving directly to JPEG is enough, or whether you want to edit the images on a computer.
| Buying priority | What to look for | Who is it especially relevant to? |
|---|---|---|
| Film format and holder | Identify whether you have a negative strip or slide, and establish the film format; check the scan area and supplied holders for the specific model. | If I’m not sure which film format the original is, I first want to know whether it will fit in the holder at all. Around 33% of consumers put format compatibility first. |
| Simple workflow | Check the display, storage medium, what’s included and the file format. The manufacturer’s speed claims don’t necessarily reflect the total time involved. | If I have only a few images and a tight deadline, I want to produce a presentable file without lots of set-up. Around 25% of consumers prioritise a straightforward workflow that gets scans ready quickly. |
| Reviewing and editing | Check the output formats and software for the exact model; bear in mind that dust correction works differently for different film types. | If I want to correct the portraits later or save another version, I’ll need a suitable computer-based workflow. Around 25% of consumers put image review and later editing first. |
| Accessories and effort | Check whether film holders, a memory card and software are included; for older devices, also check operating system compatibility and the specific offer. | For a time-limited school project, I want to avoid having to buy essential accessories separately. Around 17% of consumers pay particular attention to extra components and the work involved in getting them. |
Some models only support specific formats: the Plustek OpticFilm 135i is described as being for 35 mm film, while Epson also lists 120/220 film for the Perfection V600 Photo.
Identify your original and check that its format is compatible with the holder included in the specific offer.
If there’s no suitable holder, you may need to buy an additional accessory.
For the Rollei DF-S 310 SE, Rollei distinguishes between 14 MP image capture and output interpolated up to 24 MP.
Compare the native image capture and file output for the specific model, rather than focusing on the biggest number alone.
Infrared correction isn’t a reliable basis for choosing a scanner if you’re using conventional silver-based black-and-white film.
Check the film type and find out what other correction methods the software you’re using offers.
Careful cleaning and correction afterwards can mean extra work.
Epson’s German product page marks the Perfection V600 Photo as no longer available.
Before settling on an older model, check the device, holders, what’s included and support for the specific offer.
Finding another suitable offer may take extra time.
The DF-S 310 SE is a standalone option for viewing compatible slides and negative strips.
OpticFilm models are designed for computer-based 35 mm scanning; the OpticFilm 135i is an option for standard 35 mm strips.
The Perfection V600 Photo is a documented flatbed example for 35 mm and 120/220 film, as well as paper originals.
The Mini Digital Film & Slide Scanner is a compact example of a standalone scanning workflow with several 35 mm adapters.
The RPS 10S is designed for digitising compatible 35 mm strips using a computer.
You can scan them, but you shouldn’t rely on infrared correction for conventional silver-based black-and-white film. SilverFast describes software-based correction as an alternative; check which features are available in the scanning software you’re actually using.
Try not to touch the image area of the film. The Library of Congress recommends clean, well-fitting nitrile gloves when handling photographs and films directly. If the material is visibly damaged, gentle handling is more important than a quick scan; professional conservation may be an option.
If your device allows it, keep a file in a suitable format that’s as close to the original as possible, as well as the version for your presentation. The Library of Congress lists TIFF as preferred and JPEG as acceptable for digital photographs. This is guidance on keeping files, not a requirement for school projects.
That depends on how and with whom you want to share the images. Section 60a of the German Copyright Act (UrhG) allows certain non-commercial uses to illustrate teaching at educational institutions, subject to specific conditions; it isn’t blanket permission to publish anything online. For distributing or publicly displaying recognisable images of people, section 22 of the German Act on the Right to One’s Own Image (KunstUrhG) generally requires consent, subject to the statutory exceptions in section 23. Before publishing, check the rights, the people shown and who will be able to see the images.
If you buy from a business seller, you generally have statutory rights if the goods are faulty; a manufacturer’s guarantee doesn’t replace them. Eligible distance purchases generally come with a 14-day right to cancel from the date you receive the goods, although exceptions apply and you may have to pay return postage if you cancel. Faulty goods are also covered by a statutory minimum guarantee period of two years from receipt. A purchase from a private individual is different.