Which scanner is right for you?

Teacher with limited desk space

If you want to scan individual cards using an existing computer and then clear the desk, compact A4 models powered via USB are worth considering. Canon lists these features for the CanoScan LiDE 400, while Epson lists them for the Perfection V39II.

Handling historical originals

For delicate or potentially damaged cards, careful handling and useful archive files may matter more than high throughput. The Library of Congress recommends considering the potential impact of digitisation on the original, too.

Class with larger items to scan

If you want to scan album pages or larger pieces of paper as well as postcards, an A3 scanning bed could be useful. VIISAN offers A3 flatbed models, and Plustek lists the OpticSlim 1180 as having a scanning area up to A3 size.

What should you look for when buying?

Start by measuring your largest items and the space available. Then check that the connection, handling and file workflow meet your needs.

What matters when buying What to check Who is this important to?
Careful handling Check the condition of the card and that the scanning bed is clean. If the original is fragile, decide on a suitable approach before you begin. When I work with delicate or damaged cards, careful handling matters more to me than speed. Around 40% of consumers put handling originals with care first.
Space and computer connection Check the scanner’s dimensions, the space needed to open it, its connection and whether the drivers are compatible with the school computer. With limited classroom desk space, I want a scanner that fits neatly and works with the computer already available. Around 30% of consumers prioritise a small footprint and straightforward operation.
Scanning area size Measure your largest item and compare it with the maximum scanning area. Only opt for A3 if you really do need to scan larger items. If I want to scan album pages or other large pieces of paper without combining separate scans, I need a larger scanning area. Around 20% of consumers put larger items first.
Files for future use Check the difference between optical resolution and selectable resolution. Try a test scan and check the file and storage workflow on the school computer. If I want to review, edit and organise the scans later, a clear file workflow is essential. Around 10% of consumers prioritise files that are easy to reuse and organise.

Pitfalls when buying a scanner for old postcards

  • Assuming the highest dpi guarantees the best quality

    Canon distinguishes between optical and selectable resolution for the LiDE 400. The Library of Congress points out that resolution is not the only factor to consider when digitising.

    Compare the scanner’s optical specification and assess the settings with a test scan, based on how you plan to use it.

    Higher settings can mean larger files and more time spent checking them, without adding useful detail for your intended purpose.

  • Choosing A3 as a precaution for individual postcards

    A larger scanning area is only practically useful if your items actually need the extra space.

    Measure your cards and any other items before deciding on A3.

    A larger scanner takes up more desk space. According to the manufacturer, the Plustek OpticSlim 1180 also requires a separate power supply.

  • Assuming similar Epson model names refer to the same scanner

    The Perfection V39 and Perfection V39II are different model names and should not be treated as the same scanner.

    Before ordering, check the full model name and the details for the specific version.

A guide to relevant scanner brands

Canon

The CanoScan LiDE 400 is an A4 option for a workspace where space is at a premium.

  • Canon Germany lists a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm, USB power and an optical resolution of 4.800 × 4.800 dpi.
  • Canon quotes around eight seconds for an A4 colour scan at 300 dpi under the stated test conditions.
  • The A4 scanning area limits the size of items you can scan. The quoted time cannot be applied to higher settings or historical postcards.

Epson

The Perfection V39II is an A4 flatbed scanner with USB power and an integrated stand.

  • Epson Germany advertises a resolution of 4.800 dpi and image-enhancement software features for this model.
  • Advertised software features do not show what results they will achieve with a particular historical postcard.
  • Check the A4 scanning area and the scanner’s dimensions against your items and workspace.

VIISAN

The VF3120 and VF3240 flatbed models are A3 options if you want to scan larger items as well as cards.

  • VIISAN lists a maximum optical resolution of 1.200 × 1.200 dpi for the VF3120 and 2.400 × 2.400 dpi for the VF3240.
  • An A3 scanning area is not automatically an advantage for individual postcards. Manufacturer speed claims are not independent tests using historical originals.

Plustek

The OpticSlim 1180 is an A3 flatbed scanner for projects involving larger paper originals.

  • Plustek Europe lists a maximum scanning area of 297 × 431,8 mm and an optical resolution of 1.200 dpi.
  • The manufacturer lists dimensions of 589 × 407 × 68 mm and a separate power supply. Check how much desk space you have available.

Joybuy products

Relevant products coming soon.

Frequently asked questions

Is an A4 scanner big enough for my postcards?

An A4 model will be big enough if your largest item fits on its scanning bed. Canon lists the CanoScan LiDE 400 as having a maximum scanning area of 216 × 297 mm; measure any larger album pages separately.

What resolution should I use when scanning?

Choose a resolution that suits the item and how you plan to use it, rather than automatically selecting the highest available setting. The Library of Congress points out that resolution is not the only measure of quality. A test scan will help you assess what works for your specific teaching purpose.

What should I consider for setup and day-to-day use?

Before buying, check the connection and drivers for the school computer, as well as the space needed to open the scanner. Allow time to place each card carefully, scan both sides and store the files. USB power does not remove the need to check computer compatibility.

Can scanned postcards be shared in class or publicly?

There is no straightforward yes-or-no answer: a card’s age and ownership do not automatically settle the rights to use it. Subject to certain conditions, § 60a UrhG permits certain uses of published works for teaching at educational institutions for non-commercial purposes. The provision includes, among other things, a limit of up to 15% of a published work, as well as exceptions. This does not amount to general permission to publish a work publicly. If a card contains information about identifiable living people, you should also check the applicable data protection rules and your school’s procedures before processing or sharing it. The Federal Ministry of Justice and the Federal Office of Justice publish the text of the law; the BfDI explains the scope of the GDPR.

What ongoing costs and support should I check?

For the specific model, compare its power supply, what is included in the box and your school’s IT requirements. Plustek lists a separate power supply for the OpticSlim 1180; Canon and Epson list USB power for the A4 models mentioned here. Also check whether suitable drivers are available for the school computer.