Keepers of delicate originals
If your cards are brittle, warped or valuable, careful handling matters more than scanning a whole stack quickly. The Library of Congress stresses the importance of minimising the risk of damage when scanning.
For old, delicate postcards, an all-in-one printer with a flatbed scanner is better suited to carefully scanning one card at a time than an automatic document feeder. The Library of Congress recommends minimising the risk of damage when digitising collections and advises against using feeders for fragile items. Assess scan quality with test scans of both the picture and text sides, and consider your printing needs separately. CHIP reports that some individual ink-tank models offer low printing costs, but that photo-scanning results vary. An ink tank is therefore worth considering primarily if you also print regularly alongside your archiving work.
If your cards are brittle, warped or valuable, careful handling matters more than scanning a whole stack quickly. The Library of Congress stresses the importance of minimising the risk of damage when scanning.
You want to save images and inscriptions as clearly organised files, rather than relying solely on a successful reprint. The Library of Congress points out that resolution is not the only measure of quality when digitising.
You scan the collection and also print club materials regularly. In that case, the device’s consumables matter, as well as having a straightforward process that everyone can follow.
Start by considering how delicate your cards are, then check how well the scanner reproduces both sides. Only then compare ink tanks and cartridges, based on how much else you expect to print.
| Priority | What to check when buying | Who it matters most to |
|---|---|---|
| Protecting originals | Check for a flatbed scanner and a suitable scanning surface; assess damaged cards individually. | If cards are brittle, warped or valuable, I want to be able to place each one on the scanner carefully. Around 36% of consumers give protecting the original their top priority. |
| Scanned images and text | Scan both the picture and text sides as a test; assess colour reproduction and how clearly small text can be read. | For an archive, I need to be able to find usable files of both the image and the text on the back—not just a good-looking print. Around 29% of consumers put scan quality first. |
| A shared process | Test how files are named and saved; check which computers or mobile devices you’ll need. | If several members will be scanning, I need a process that links the front and back of each card. Around 21% of consumers prioritise a shared digitisation process. |
| Printing needs | Plan club printing separately from the scanning workload; check the consumables required for the specific model. | If we regularly print club materials alongside our archive work, I want to keep ongoing printing costs under control. Around 14% of consumers put printing costs over time first. |
The Library of Congress advises against using feeders for fragile or special collection items. So having an ADF does not mean it is suitable for old postcards.
Place delicate cards on the flatbed one at a time, and use the feeder only for sturdy documents that are suitable for it.
Good photo prints don’t necessarily show how images or small text will look when scanned. CHIP reports varying photo-scanning results across the all-in-one printers it tested.
Before choosing a model, assess test scans of a typical picture side and a side with writing on it.
Poor-quality files may mean scanning again and spending extra time editing them.
The printing-cost savings reported for some ink-tank models apply to prints, not to scanning.
Estimate your club’s regular printing volume separately from the size of the scanning project, then compare the consumables used by the models you’re considering.
The EcoTank range includes devices for people with additional printing needs. Epson describes the ET-8500 as a photo-focused A4 printer.
Canon describes the PIXMA G650 as a photo-focused 3-in-1 ink-tank printer.
Smart Tank models combine ink tanks with scanning and printing functions. OfficeJet Pro devices are office alternatives, but their feeders are not automatically suitable for old cards.
The DCP-J1200W is a compact 3-in-1 cartridge printer for scanning and occasional printing.
This selection includes all-in-one printers with scanning functions. A flatbed scanner is listed for both Pantum models; check that each device lets you place your cards on the scanner individually.
No image available
For groups that want to scan cards one at a time on the flatbed and print monochrome club documents as well.
The product specifications list colour scanning, a flatbed scanner and an optical scan resolution of 1200 × 1200 dpi. Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and scan-to-PC are also listed.
According to the model name, this printer produces monochrome prints. The ADF should not be your go-to option for delicate or valuable postcards.
No image available
An option if you’re looking for a flatbed scanner for individual cards and a monochrome printer for club documents.
The product specifications list colour scanning, a flatbed scanner and an optical scan resolution of 1200 × 1200 dpi. Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, scan-to-PC and Ethernet are also listed.
According to the model name, this printer produces monochrome prints, so check that it’s suitable for the club materials you want to print.
No image available
For a shared workspace where you need scanning and wireless connectivity as well as printing.
The product specifications list scanning and copying functions, dual-band Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and USB, plus automatic two-sided printing.
Before buying, check whether delicate cards can be scanned individually on a flatbed.
No image available
For groups considering an all-in-one printer with wireless connectivity, scanning and printing functions.
The product specifications list scanning and copying functions, dual-band Wi-Fi, USB, a colour display and automatic two-sided printing.
Check in advance whether you can place the postcards on a flatbed scanner one at a time.
The feeder should not be your standard method for delicate or valuable cards. The Library of Congress advises against using feeders for fragile or special collection items; sturdy originals should be assessed separately.
It depends on the original and how you plan to use the scan. According to the Library of Congress, resolution alone is not the deciding factor. First decide whether the files are for archiving or publication, then assess test files of both sides of the cards.
Test the connection and scanning process using the devices your group actually plans to use. The Library of Congress recommends keeping copies of digital files that need to be preserved on at least two different storage media in separate locations.
No. The age of a card alone does not determine the rights. According to the general guidance of the German Patent and Trade Mark Office, copyright protection for a work expires 70 years after its creator’s death; the rights relating to the specific card must be checked separately. If the back contains personal data about people who are still alive, you also need an appropriate legal basis for processing it. Consent is just one possible basis.